Inkjet Cartridge Refills Violate U.S. Law?

Last week the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled that opening an inkjet cartridge labelled "single use only" creates an enforceable contract between the customer and the cartridge manufacturer, and that refilling the cartridge could constitute a violation of contract and patent law.

The decision comes in a case between printer and cartridge manufacturer Lexmark and the Arizona Cartridge Remanufacturers Association (ACRA), and appears to be an extension of the so-called "shrinkwrap license" which appeared on software products to patented goods available for sale. By opening the product, customers are agreeing to the single-use terms specified by the manufacturer. If they then turn that product over to another party—such as a cartridge remanufacturer—they are violating that agreement and would be subject to action under contract and patent law. Moreover, companies which offer to remanufacture or enable customers to re-use such products in ways prohibited by the customer agreement could be subject to legal action for inducing customers to violate patent and contract law.

Lexmark previously tried to shut down inkjet cartridge remanufacturers using the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA); the U.S. Sixth Circuit court did not side with Lexmark, specifically finding the DMCA could not be used to create monopolies on manufactured goods.

The Ninth Circuit’s ruling could conceivably open the door to many different types of on-box contracts consumers tacitly accept by opening the package of a patented product. Agreements could forbid or restrict or forbid repair, alteration, resale, or certain applications of the products. For instance, a contact could specify that a product could only be serviced by the manufacturer, could not be sold by the customer, or could not be modified by the customer or a third party.

If the ruling stands, the implications could be widespread. Manufacturers could seek to restrict what customers can do with patented products, both to make certain types of activities illegal (e.g., developing and selling modifications to video game systems, for instance) or lock in revenue streams by preventing third parties from refurbishing, repairing, or upgrading products (e.g., printer cartridges, adding storage capacity, selling systems on eBay, etc.).


It’s 2025. How has 5G changed our lives? We asked experts to predict the future

2025 is the year that mobile carriers say 5G goes mainstream. How will the technology change, revolutionize, or make obsolete the things we do today? We asked futurists to give us an idea of our future 5G connected world.
Product Review

Frigidaire FGIP2468UD dishwasher review

This Frigidaire dishwasher has a lot of pros, including the ability to run quietly and impressive cleaning capabilities. But do they come at a price? Read our review to find out how it stacks up.
Product Review

You can’t ask for more in a budget robot vacuum with the Eufy RoboVac 15C MAX

If you're looking to get your first robot vacuum without breaking the bank, then the Eufy RoboVac 15C MAX is worth considering with its Wi-Fi connectivity, Google Assistant/Amazon Alexa integration, strong cleaning performance, and sleek…
Smart Home

Hello Fresh vs. Blue Apron: Which service is better, cheaper, and tastier?

These days, you have several meal-delivery services to choose from if you don't have hours to slave over a hot stove. We compared two of the bigger competitors: Hello Fresh vs. Blue Apron.
Smart Home

Foxconn interns reportedly work long hours to produce Amazon Alexa products

A recent report from the Chinese Labor Watch said that student interns are forced to work long hours without rest in order to meet Amazon Echo production goals at the Foxconn factory in China.
Smart Home

New Ecovacs Deebot Ozmo models vacuum and mop with multi-floor mapping

Ecovacs Robotics launched two new robotic home floor care models. The Deebot Ozmo 920 and Deebot Ozmo 950 add new laser-based navigation and multi-floor mapping capabilities combine robotic vacuuming and mopping for total floor cleaning.
Smart Home

Google Assistant’s reminders will soon nag your significant other for you

Let Google take the heat for all that nagging: Google Assistant will soon allow you to assign reminders to others. The feature will roll out to Google Assistant-enabled phones, speakers, and displays over the next few weeks.

Locate a runaway pet with the Whistle 3 GPS Pet Tracker, now $64 on Amazon

A good way to monitor your pet’s movements is through a GPS tracker. A great option is the Whistle 3, which is available on Amazon for only $64 as an early Prime Day deal. It’s normally sold for $80, so you get $16 savings.
Buying Guides

Back to school smart home gadgets under $50 for your dorm

Today’s students are accustomed to a high-tech lifestyle, which they'll want to maintain when they start college. But they're also strapped for cash, so these back to school smart home gadgets under $50 for the dorm are perfect!
Smart Home

Startup Camect is on track to deliver a private, unified smart camera hub

It's not every day you run across a crowdfunded startup that has raised nearly three times its goal but startup Camect has done just that to fund the development of a secure smart camera hub expected to launch in 2020.
Smart Home

Smart thermostats explained: How they work and how they save you money

Thinking of buying a smart thermostat, but don't know exactly what you're looking for? We explain how smart thermostats work, the features they offer, and how they can save you money.
Smart Home

The best pet tech products on the market for dog and cat owners

Pet-centric tech has come a long way in the past decade. From self-cleaning litter boxes to DNA tests designed to trace your pup's ancestry through the ages, here is some of the best pet tech available.
Smart Home

Amazon and Walmart match lower prices on Echo Dot and Google Home Mini

Amazon and Walmart resumed their price competition on the entry-level smart speakers for the Amazon Echo and Google Nest Home smart home ecosystems. The price cuts have started with 40% discounts on the Echo Dot and the Google Home Mini.
Smart Home

Alexa’s Custom Interfaces hope to augment gadgets, games, and smart toys

Alexa is growing smarter again with a new feature for developers called Custom Interfaces. The feature is aimed at augmenting interactivity between users of Alexa-powered devices like Amazon's Echo and developer's newest products.