Skip to main content

Survey says: We’d rather let robots cook than drive

More people would be comfortable letting robots service cars than drive them, a new survey shows. And fully half of those surveyed would be fine with a robot chef or personal trainer.

The survey by Study.com, a web site that offers online instruction for college courses, queried 1031 Americans aged 18 and over about which of a range of tasks they’d entrust to a robot powered by artificial intelligence.

Unsurprisingly, the highest percentage of robot acceptance came for the most menial tasks, with 73 percent saying they’d let robots clean house or deliver packages. Next highest on the list were providing tech support (69 percent) and landscaping your yard (64 percent).

Equally predictably, the lowest numbers were for tasks of a highly personal nature, or those involving complex judgments and advanced education: A mere 8 percent would let a robot choose their spouse (actually, that almost sounds high), while only 14 percent would let a robot defend them in court or choose their party’s senatorial candidate.

Only 29 percent of respondents said they’d be comfortable with a robot driving their car—and even fewer (14 percent) would let a robot drive their kids to school.

Ominously for journalists, half of those surveyed would accept robots researching and reporting news — the same number that supported robot chefs. Robots might be even more of a threat to film and TV critics (70 percent of respondents would accept a robot’s entertainment recommendations), auto repair workers (54 percent would let a robot service their car), and guidance counselors (60 percent would let a robot recommend colleges to apply to).

Slightly less endangered professions included tax preparers (47 percent supported robots doing this), security guards (43 percent) and retail salespeople (40 percent).

Robots proved less acceptable substitutes for some highly trained professionals: 33 percent of respondents said they’d let a robot teach their child, 27 percent would let them invest their money, 24 percent would let them write their will, 23 percent would let them perform surgery or prescribe medicine, and then there’s the aforementioned 14 percent who’d go with a robot lawyer.

But you don’t necessarily need an advanced degree to be more acceptable than a robot: Only 20 percent of respondents said they’d let a robot cut their hair or plan their wedding. But we’re apparently less confident about our taste in clothes: 38 percent said they’d let a robot choose their wardrobe.

Study.com said survey respondents were randomly selected from an opt-in panel of millions via Survey Monkey, and the survey was performed in late July. The margin of error was plus or minus 3 percent.

Editors' Recommendations

Denny Arar
A longtime PC World/TechHive editor and contributor, Denny Arar (a.k.a. Yardena Arar) has also written for The New York…
Electrify America will build a robotic charging facility for self-driving cars
electrify america and stable auto robotic charging stations for self driving cars

If self-driving cars become mainstream, it's likely that many of them will be electric. But if no one is driving, will anyone be around to plug them in? Electrify America -- the entity created to spend Volkswagen diesel emissions fines on zero-emission vehicle infrastructure -- is teaming up with charging company Stable Auto to solve that problem. The solution? Robotic charging stations.

Electrify America and Stable plan to open a pilot charging site in San Francisco in early 2020. In addition to being Stable's hometown, the City by the Bay hosts fleets of test vehicles from Waymo and General Motors' Cruise division. Waymo uses Chrysler Pacifica Hybrid plug-in hybrid minivans, and recently added the all-electric Jaguar I-Pace to its fleet. Cruise uses modified Chevrolet Bolt EV electric cars. That should provide a ready source of customers, although neither Waymo nor Cruise has commented on the announcement.

Read more
Faith in superior abilities of machines is key to accepting self-driving cars
aaa survey us drivers fear self driving car afraid to ride in cars

Some people love the idea of self-driving cars, while other people find the concept terrifying or creepy. A new survey has revealed that the biggest difference between these groups is not whether or not they think self-driving cars are cool, or how open they are to new technology in general, but rather whether they believe machines can outperform humans in driving tasks specifically.

The researchers surveyed 404 participants through the Mechanical Turk crowdsourcing website, collecting information on their demographics as well as their opinions about self-driving cars. They found that acceptance of self-driving cars was related to beliefs about their safety and was negatively influenced by the "creep factor" of seeing a car without a driver.

Read more
Stanford wants to teach its autonomous race cars to learn from their past
Stanford Audi TTS

Researchers at Stanford University are leveraging the power of artificial intelligence to help their autonomous prototypes learn from the past as they prepare for the future. They have designed a control system that drives a car using a blend of real-time data and data generated by past experiences, and they're putting it through its paces on California's Thunderhill race track.

Stanford -- an early pioneer in self-driving technology -- explained the control systems in many of the autonomous prototypes zigzagging the world's roads rely on up-to-the-minute information to plan their next move. If a car detects a bend in the road, it knows it needs to turn in order to avoid going straight where the pavement doesn't. The school developed a neural network capable of powering what it calls a flexible, responsive control system that, to use our previous example, tells the car how fast it can go around the bend by searching through its vast data library for information about previous bends it has encountered.

Read more