Skip to main content

Android found to contain copied Java code

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Back in August, Oracle filed a patent infringment suit against Google, claiming that the open source Android operating system violated several Oracle patents by including proprietary technology from Sun Microsystems’s Java implementation. Now, IP activist Florian Mueller has outlined several instances in the Android source where Google appears to have copied Java source code outright and included it in Android…all the way down to notices that the files are confidential and not to be redistributed.

Recommended Videos

Mueller’s 46-page analysis (available as PDF files) details instances that seem to support Oracle’s claims against Google, including cases where Google apparently derived source files using a decompiler and made meaningless changes to source files (such as in comments or immaterial line ordering). Mueller also notes nearly 40 instances where Google included files with clear Sun/Oracle copyright notices that, Mueller asserts, could not be legally be redistributed under Android’s Apache license.

Google’s initial response to Oracle’s suit was surprisingly weak-chinned, offering virtually no evidence to support its defense theories. Google has also not countersued Oracle on its claims, a move which would be typical for gaining leverage in a patent battle.

If Google is found guilt of infringement in this case, the impact on the broader Android community could be considerable: instead of an open source operating system that any device manufacturer could use, Android could become a mobile operating system controlled under licensing burdens from Oracle.

If the discoveries bear fruit—and Mueller is not a party to the case—the results could reflect very badly on Google and have wide-ranging implications for the broader Android community. Android is already the target (direct or indirect) in a number of intellectual property suits, including a high-profile spat between Apple and HTC, as well as suits against Google by Interval Licensing and Gemalto. Numerous suits have been filed against Android device makers: Microsoft and Motorola are going at it (as are Apple and Motorola), and two Android device makers are even suing each other: LG and Sony have recently crossed swords. A major patent cloud hanging over the Android operating system could dissuade developers and device manufacturers from using the platform…and potentially curb its success just as Android is gaining market momentum.

Geoff Duncan
Former Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Google just leaked images of the upcoming Android redesign
Design elements Google Material 3 Expressive.

Google is due to unveil its new "Material 3 Expressive" design system at I/O 2025 this month, but someone at the company accidentally published a blog post about it this week. It was promptly deleted but the Wayback Machine already archived it and the quick-thinking folks at 9to5Google saved the images as well.

The blog post itself was all about the research that went into the new design system for Android 16. Google spent three years carrying out various studies and experiments with over 18,000 participants, including:

Read more
Android’s desktop mode for phones is taking shape, and it looks familiar
Android 16 logo on Google Pixel 6a kept on the edge of a table.

Google’s mobile operating system comes with a hidden desktop mode that opens on an external screen, mimicking what you would get from a computing interface. However, it is buried within the developer mode, and it's far from polished to get any serious work done. 

The company, however, continues building a next-gen experience for Android’s native desktop mode. The overarching idea is to turn your phone and tablet into a desktop computing device. Mishaal Rahman, over at Android Authority, was able to enable this mode in the latest beta build of Android 16, though he warns that it might not be ready for the stable release in the coming months.

Read more
The latest Android 16 beta is hiding a significant UI overhaul
Android 16 logo on Google Pixel 6a kept on the edge of a table.

Google has been releasing various beta versions of Android 16 for a while now, but the juicy stuff is often hidden away. We have confirmation that Google is going to show us new design changes at I/O this month, and some of those changes can already be seen in the latest and final beta release.

Android Authority has done the work to enable the hidden design features in Beta 4, showcasing a range of subtle and not-so-subtle changes to the UI. Because these changes are still "off" even in the final beta, it's likely that they won't be included in the first stable release of Android 16. Instead, Google might activate them in a quarterly update sometime down the line. With any luck, they'll give us some more information during the upcoming developer conference.

Read more