Skip to main content

Apple vs. Samsung: Judge puts hold on $450 million of $1 billion award

Apple-vs-Samsung5Last summer, everyone in the tech world watched excitedly to find out just how the Apple vs. Samsung lawsuit would play out. For those who were asleep, Apple sued Samsung for $2.5 billion dollars for a slew of what were, at the time, alleged patent infringements.

As we reported at the trial’s conclusion, the court ultimately ruled largely in favor of Apple. And while the Cupertino conglomerate didn’t get the full amount they were hoping for — in fact, it got less than half — it still dealt a major blow to Samsung (though not nearly enough to put the company into financial distress), awarding it $1,049,343,540.

Recommended Videos

However, as reported by Foss Patents, five months later, Judge Lucy Koh, the federal judge that resided over the trial, ordered a strike against nearly half of the damages: specifically $450,514,650. This doesn’t necessarily mean Apple won’t get the money, eventually. This is in response to Samsung’s lawyers questioning the fairness in which the jury awarded damages to 14 individual Samsung devices: Captivate, Continuum, Droid Charge, Epic 4G, Exhibit 4G, Galaxy Prevail, Galaxy S2 AT&T, Galaxy Tab, Gem, Indulge, Infuse 4G, Nexus S 4G, Replenish, and Transform

So now, Apple and Samsung are headed back to the courthouse, though there’s no word yet as to when this trial will take place. But we do know that an entirely new jury is going to be summoned, so this could be another lengthy trial, as the lawyers on both sides will have to reintroduce most of the evidence again in order to educate them.

But there’s more money still to potentially be awarded to Apple aside from the damages from the device infringements. Before the first trial, Apple requested, and was ultimately awarded the right to, supplemental damages for all sales that took place during the course of the trial.

In addition, Apple also requested, and was granted, interest on these sales through to the time a verdict was finally reached. While Apple requested the prime interest rate, Samsung countered, asking for the 52-week Treasury bill rate, which is significantly lower — today it’s at just 0.15 percent. This was one part of the trial in which Samsung “won.”

Of course, neither of these could happen until the trial ended and the court could review official sales numbers throughout the time the verdict was reached. But now that’s being pushed back again, until trial number two ends, so this will still have to wait. (It’s unclear whether or not the court will consider sales from the time between the original verdict and the follow-up; likely, it will have to be at Apple’s request.)

It will be interesting to see how this all plays out. We’ll be watching the story closely and will keep you all posted.

Joshua Pramis
Spending a childhood engrossed in such technologically inspiring television shows like Voltron, Small Wonder, and Power…
Samsung Galaxy S25 Plus vs. iPhone 16 Plus: which mid-priced phone is the best?
Samsung Galaxy S25 Plus vs. iPhone 16 Plus.

The Samsung Galaxy S25 Plus is the latest mid-sized flagship phone from Samsung, positioned between the Galaxy S25 and Galaxy S25 Ultra. This makes it a strong contender against the Apple iPhone 16 Plus in terms of specifications and pricing. Both devices have a lot to offer, but is one clearly better than the other?

The Galaxy S25 Plus features a powerful processor, a stunning display, and a versatile camera system. On the other hand, the iPhone 16 Plus is praised for its sleek design, user-friendly interface, and deep integration with the Apple ecosystem.

Read more
Samsung may be about to score a double victory over Apple — here’s how
The Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max and the Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra's screens.

The latest Power On newsletter from Bloomberg journalist Mark Gurman asserts that Samsung is ahead of Apple in both artificial intelligence (AI) and with its ultra-thin phone efforts. Does that actually matter, though?

Well, yes and no. While I think being first is an empty accolade if it’s not backed up by quality, Apple can’t afford to be too late to the party -- particularly in the case of AI.

Read more
Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra vs. iPhone 16 Pro Max: Flagship throwdown
Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra vs. iPhone 16 Pro Max.

With the new year comes Samsung's launch of the Galaxy S25 Ultra, which competes with Apple’s iPhone 16 Pro Max.

Performance-wise, the Galaxy S25 Ultra runs on the Snapdragon 8 Elite processor, while Apple’s efficient A18 Pro chip powers the iPhone 16 Pro Max.

Read more