Skip to main content

Lodsys sues App Store developers

apple v lodsys

Patent holder Lodsys is amping up its legal battles over in-app purchasing technology: fresh from filing suits against selected Android developers, the company has now filed a lawsuit against a selection of iOS developers, claiming their products infringe on its patents. The move comes after a withering assertion from Apple that iOS developers are covered by Apple’s licensing rights to the patents.

The suit was filed in the historically patent holder-friendly Eastern District of Texas, and currently targets Combay, Iconfactory, Illusion Labs AB, Michael G. Karr (dba Shovelmate), Quickoffice, Richard Shinderman, and Wulven Game Studios. At issue are U.S. patents 7,222,078 and 7,620,565, which Lodsys claim cover in-app purchasing.

The move ups the ante in the patent dispute between the two companies. Patent litigation can be a drawn-out, expensive proposition, and Lodsys is apparently betting that most iOS developers won’t have the deep pockets or resources to sustain a drawn out legal battle. The burden is now on Apple and Google to step forward and indemnify their developers, taking on the legal battle against Lodsys themselves, or attempt work out a settlement with Lodsys. However, if either Google or Apple capitulates or settles, it could have a dampening effect on development for the iOS and Android platforms, because if Lodsys can succeed in suing app developers for patent infringement, other patent holders are sure to consider the same strategy.

In its blog, Lodsys claims it has been in discussion with Apple and that there was “clearly disagreement on the interpretation” of the terms of Apple’s license agreement. Lodsys asserts Apple’s claim that iOS developers are covered under the company’s licenses “has no discernible basis in law or fact”—and the company is sure enough of it’s position that it is offering $1,000 to any company to whom it has sent an infringement notice of Apple’s existing license rights prove to cover them. Lodsys also notes that Apple’s contract with its developers limits the company’s legal responsibility for third-party patent infringement to $50.

Neither Apple nor Google have responded to Lodsys’ latest suit or comments. Apple’s World Wide Developer Conference (WWDC) opens next week, and it’s safe to say thousands of iOS developers will want to know how Apple intends to deal with Lodsys.

Editors' Recommendations

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
I hate my iPhone’s keyboard, but this app made it better
Theming on SwiftKey

The iPhone does a lot of things right. From serving a secure environment, a smooth operating system, unmatched performance, and consistently good cameras, there are plenty of practically justifiable reasons to overlook any of the best Android phones in favor of a pricey iPhone.

Interestingly, Apple tends to take a conservatively slow approach when it comes to smartphone innovations and only serves them after nearly near-perfecting the formula. But the default iPhone keyboard is a tale of stagnation. Or, to put it more accurately, it’s absurdly feature-devoid and depressingly non-exciting.

Read more
I really like the Pixel 7a, but there’s one big issue I can’t ignore
Google Pixel 7a laying on ground

Google revealed the Pixel 7a at Google I/O 2023, and it is available for purchase right now for $499. It’s the cheapest of the Pixel 7 lineup, and it packs in the Google Tensor G2 chip, a crisp display with a 90Hz refresh rate, and a 64MP main shooter, plus it’s the first Pixel A-series with wireless charging. The Pixel 7a even comes in four fun colors: Charcoal, Snow, Sea, and the Google Store-exclusive Coral.

But with all of those upgrades from its predecessor, the Pixel 6a, the Pixel 7a is $50 more than the original price of the Pixel 6a, which was $449 at launch. However, Google also decided to keep the Pixel 6a around (this is the first time the previous model has remained for sale) and even gave it a $100 price cut, so it is now just $349.

Read more
I’m excited for the Google Pixel Fold, and you should be too
Side view of the Pixel Fold

It’s official: the Google Pixel Fold is coming. After months of rumors and speculation, Google revealed the Pixel Fold on Star Wars Day, of all days. With the tagline “May The Fold Be With You,” Google dropped a tweet that showed off the Pixel Fold in all of its glory. And now, after the official announcement at Google I/O 2023, the Google Pixel Fold is shaping up to be one of the more exciting releases this year.

I’ve always been an iPhone gal, but since I joined Digital Trends, I’ve been checking out Android phones more than ever before. I’ve taken quite a liking to the Pixel lineup of devices, including the Pixel 7 and Pixel 7a, which also just dropped today. But the Google Pixel Fold is the one device I can’t wait to get my hands on, especially when compared to the competing Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 4 (and the Galaxy Z Fold 5, which is likely coming this year too).
It looks like the perfect compact size

Read more