Skip to main content

Microsoft sues Barnes & Noble over patent infringement

mico vs nookMicrosoft is going after Barnes & Noble for allegedly using its software without permission. According to the company, Barnes & Noble Android e-readers the Nook and Nook Color infringe on patents regarding UI, as well as browsing and downloading. Microsoft also claims that Foxconn and Inventec are guilty of violating its various patents.

According to Microsoft’s corporate VP and deputy general counsel Horacio Gutierrez, “the Android platform infringes a number of Microsoft’s patents, and companies manufacturing and shipping Android devices must respect our intellectual property right.” The statement goes on to say that the patents are specifically “essential to the user experience, including: Natural ways of interacting with devices by tabbing through various screens [to find information]; surfing the web more quickly; and interacting with documents and e-books.”

Gutierrez is quick to note in a separate blog post that this type of legal action isn’t something Microsoft likes doing. “This is only our seventh proactive patent infringement suit in our 36-year history. But we simply cannot ignore infringement of this scope and scale.” He also mentions that Microsoft prefers licensing its innovation instead of punishing those who use it. Despite this, general consensus so far seems to be that Microsoft is being a “patent troll,” and instead of working on its own development, reaching for grounds to sue competitors. A variety of comments on its blog criticize the US patent system and Microsoft for abusing it, and most believe it will be extremely difficult for Microsoft to get the Barnes & Noble e-readers pulled.

Microsoft sued Motorola in 2010 over its use of Android software, which has yet to find resolution. According to the company, it has similarly been pleading with Barnes & Noble, Foxconn, and Inventec to follow in the steps of Amazon and HTC: Pay up for licensing fees, and Microsoft will leave you alone. Apparently, they’re unwilling to do so and now the tech giant will see them in court.

Editors' Recommendations

Molly McHugh
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Before coming to Digital Trends, Molly worked as a freelance writer, occasional photographer, and general technical lackey…
The camera on this Android phone is confusing, but I love it
The back of the Tecno Camon 30 Premier.

I’m all for a lot of detail, and love to hear about the new technology that’s inside a smartphone I’m about to test, but when I have to search for an explanation of what something means, it’s not a good start. The Tecno Camon 30 Premier suffers from this problem, as it has a lot of cool camera tech that is explained in a mystifying way.

So, I thought the best thing to do was to just ignore the tech speak and find out if it takes great photos the old-fashioned way.
What's the problem?

Read more
The 5 best phones with IR blasters in 2024
The OnePlus 12's camera module.

IR blasters used to be a common component in smartphones, with big products from Samsung, OnePlus, and TCL giving users access to the cool gadget. Phones equipped with IR blasters could be used as a universal remote for your other electronics, making it easy to control your gear without the need for their default controller (which might be clunky and unintuitive to use).

Fast forward today, and attempting to find a smartphone with an IR blaster is shockingly difficult. What was once common technology is now relegated to just a handful of smartphones. You won't find any iPhones or Galaxy phones with IR blasters, but that doesn't mean you have to settle for a poorly reviewed smartphone if you're interested in the tech. You will, however, probably need to settle for either OnePlus or Xiaomi, as they're the two key players still churning out powerful smartphones equipped with IR blasters.

Read more
Why you should buy the iPhone 15 Pro instead of the iPhone 15 Pro Max
Natural Titanium iPhone 15 Pro with Chopper and BD-1 droids around it.

Apple releases multiple iPhones every year, offering folks choice in terms of size and features. In 2024, the iPhone 15 lineup includes four distinct models.

The regular iPhone 15 and iPhone 15 Plus are great for those who don’t need a telephoto lens and don’t care about the Action button or the 1TB of storage. But anyone who wants a more “pro” experience has the iPhone 15 Pro and iPhone 15 Pro Max.

Read more