Skip to main content

Mobile phones listed as carcinogenic hazard

Talking on cell phone
Image used with permission by copyright holder

For years, debate has raged as to whether the electromagnetic fields and radiation emitted by mobile phones pose a health risk to humans—not so much because the levels are all that high, but because untold millions of individuals spend hours a day holding these radiation-emitting devices as close to their brains as is humanly possible. Although research is still ongoing and scientific studies so far have generally been regarded as inconclusive, the International Agency for Research on Cancer today waded waist-deep into the controversy: a team of scientists decided to list mobile phones in the same category of “carcinogenic hazard” as things like engine exhaust, chloroform, and lead (PDF) based on an increased risk for a malignant type of brain cancer.

The announcement comes from a team of 31 scientists from 14 countries, based on peer review of a number of studies on cell phone safety, including studies that are in-press and not yet available to the general scientific community. The listing puts mobile phones into “category 2B” items that are “possibly carcinogenic to humans.” The review found there was limited association between the use of wireless phones and both glioma and acoustic nueroma, and inadequate information for drawing conclusions for any other types of cancer. The group did not make any effort to quantify the risk, but notes that a 2004 study found a 40 percent increased risk for gliomas amongst people who used a mobile phone for 30 minutes a day over a 10-year period.

Recommended Videos

“Given the potential consequences for public health of this classification and findings, it is important that additional research be conducted into the long‐ term, heavy use of mobile phones,” said IARC Director Christopher Wild in a statement. “Pending the availability of such information, it is important to take pragmatic measures to reduce exposure such as hands‐free devices or texting. ”

As recently as this month, the World Health Organization claimed no adverse health effects from mobile phone use had been established.

The IARC assigns ratings to agents from 1 to 4, with substances rated a 1 known to be carcinogenic to humans (like asbestos and tobacco), and agents rated a 4 being “probably not carcinogenic” to humans. Group 3 agents aren’t classifiable as carcinogenic (usually due to insufficient evidence either way). Group 2 has two sub-categories: 2A, where an agent is deemed “probably carcinogenic,” and 2B, where an agent is deemed “possibly carcinogenic.” Agents in category 2B—now alongside cellphones—include things like gasoline, welding fumes, engine exhaust, vinyl acetate, and DDT. Also classified 2B: coffee and some forms of pickled vegetables.

Many long-term studies of cell phone use have been controversial because they ask participants to accurately assess their levels of cell phone use as much as a decade ago, and both cell phone usage patterns and technology have changed radically over time—meaning it may not be possible to apply older research and usage data to current devices and behaviors. A decade ago, texting and hands-free calling weren’t as common as they are today; similarly, today’s mobile phones tend to emit less microwave radiation than earlier handsets—although virtually all phone manufacturers recommend users hold the devices at little a little bit away from their heads when in use.

Geoff Duncan
Former Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Topics
The best phone plans for one person in 2023: our 6 favorites
The home screen on the Apple iPhone 15 Plus.

Although it seems that the big three carriers are all about family plans these days, you don’t need to feel left out if you’re venturing out on your own. There are still great cellular plans out there for only one person at very affordable prices.

A single-line plan is often the best way to go, even when you have family members, friends, or roommates willing to join in on a plan. After all, if you’re the only person on your plan, you don’t need to worry about what other people need or be concerned that changes you make down the road could affect a larger group. Plus, if you’ve just moved to a new city or you’re heading off to college, staying on a group plan can get even more complicated.

Read more
It’s 50 years to the day since the first cell phone call
Old cell phones

It's 50 years to the day since American engineer Marty Cooper stepped out onto New York City's Sixth Avenue to make the first-ever cell phone call.

As you can imagine, the phone was like a brick and would’ve given Mr. Cooper a decent workout as he held the hefty device up to his ear.

Read more
More than 5 billion mobile phones to become waste this year
A pile of e-waste.

What do you do with your old phone when you replace it? If you’re one of the responsible folks who trade it in or recycle it, then good for you.

But according to the Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) Forum, most mobile phones that get switched off for good simply disappear into drawers, closets, and garages, or get chucked into trash cans bound for landfills or incineration.

Read more