Skip to main content

Judge rules that internet TV service FilmOn should be treated as a cable provider

filmon treated as cable provider
Image used with permission by copyright holder
This past Thursday, U.S. District Judge George Wu ruled that FilmOn X LLC, a free internet-based television service, should be treated like a cable provider. Wu did, however, allow for an immediate appeal in the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. And you can bet your last dollar that Fox Television Stations (the plaintiff in this case) will avail itself of that option.

But if (and it’s a big if) this ruling were to be upheld in higher courts, it would have enormous implications for broadcast television.

Like the now-defunct Aereo — which was shut down after a June 2014 Supreme Court ruling that determined it violated broadcasters’ copyrights — FilmOn allows users access to one of thousands of remote antennae, which capture TV signals in much the same way as the “rabbit ears” of yore, and then broadcasts them online so that users can watch the content at their leisure in DVR format from virtually any location.

The question that has long carried throughout this debate is whether or not allowing over-the-air access to the masses is tantamount to (illegal) redistribution, or just a clever way of doing business within the framework of the law.

Wu’s ruling, legally-speaking, says it’s the latter, but the decision is just the latest battle in a war that has been raging in the courts since 2011. Back in 2013, for instance, a host of plaintiffs (Fox, CBS Corp, NBCUniversal, etc.) succeeded in securing a nationwide injunction against FilmOn, preventing the company from offering its antenna/DVR service. Despite Thursday’s decision, that injunction still stands — a sign that even the courts are deeply conflicted about this issue.

Even as viewers consume an ever-larger share of video content via mobile devices, broadcast television remains reluctant to embrace un-tethered entertainment and resolved to fight internet-based options tooth and nail.

Reuters reports that, when interviewed about the recent ruling, FilmOn X Lawyer Ryan Baker said “The broadcasters have been trying to keep their foot on the throat of innovation,” and added “the court’s decision today is a win for technology and for the American public.”

A statement by Fox Networks, on the other hand, said the decision “contravenes all legal precedent.”

We’ll bring you news of the appeal as it becomes available, but this is an ongoing legal quagmire that likely won’t be resolved anytime soon.

Adam Poltrack
Adam is an A/V News Writer for Digital Trends, and is responsible for bringing you the latest advances in A/V…
NFL games today: schedule, channels, live streams for December 3
Kyler Murray prepares to throw a football.

Heading into Week 13, the two best teams in the NFC are the Philadelphia Eagles (10-1) and the San Francisco 49ers (8-3). The 49ers and Eagles met in last year's NFC Championship Game in a highly-anticipated showdown. However, the Eagles knocked San Francisco quarterbacks Brock Purdy and Josh Johnson out of the game, resulting in a 31-7 blowout victory in favor of Philadelphia. With Purdy back under center, Sunday's matchup between the Eagles and 49ers should be much closer.

There are 11 NFL games scheduled for Sunday, December 3. Many teams are jockeying for playoff positions and need to win to move up in the standings. Remember that every game is available to watch on NFL Sunday Ticket through YouTube TV. NFL Sunday Ticket only costs half the price for the rest of the season. Explore the NFL Week 13 schedule, channels, and live stream information below.
Los Angeles Chargers vs. New England Patriots start time, channel, and live stream

Read more
Aging rockers Kiss to let digital avatars tour instead
Rock band Kiss in concert.

Kiss during an earlier concert in Finland. Fileri/Creative Commons

Performing their final in-person concert on Saturday night at New York City’s Madison Square Garden, Kiss used the encore to unveil digital avatars of themselves that will allow the legendary glam-rock band to stay on the road.

Read more
The best shows on Max (formerly HBO Max) right now
A man looking dirty and disheveled, teeth weirdly at the side of his mouth in a scene from 30 Coins.

From The Last of Us to Succession, The White Lotus to Barry, the best shows on Max (formerly HBO Max) right now include plenty of Max originals. It's no surprise that HBO and the Max streaming service dominate in nominations come awards season. Every month, new shows or seasons are added to the list, so there's always something entertaining to check out on Max.

If you don't know where to start, we're here to help. This list of the best shows on Max right now is always updated with new shows as they come out. But we only include the shows that are truly worth watching.  We also want to keep you apprised of when your favorite shows return with new seasons. Bottom line: this list is a one-stop shop for helping you decide what to watch next.

Read more