Prefer to pedal your way to a beach bod? Computrainer vs. Flywheel Spin Class

flywheel computrainer spin class feature flywheel1
FlyWheel
As any avid cycler might attest, keeping a consistent and rigid cycling schedule during the winter months is much easier said than done. Of course, with the right kind of gear and a proper approach to layering, a simple downpour or snow storm won’t completely derail a cycling session in December — but it’s certainly not ideal. Enter the world of indoor spin classes, and their ability to keep cyclists in tip-top shape, no matter the elements.

Currently, there exist two indoor options — Flywheel and CompuTrainer — which not only offer a setting void of snow, rain, and whipping wind, but also promise to keep cycling intensity high despite its environmental restrictions. After all, nothing beats actually cycling outside. To get a true sense of which class offers the best chance at retaining cycling shape, we took to the task of attending each and assessing its viability as a cardio substitute during the winter.

Though it’s high on fun, Flywheel seems like a missed opportunity

A national spin boutique chain which specializes in targeting millennials, Flywheel offers an intense and pulsating hour of cardio and calorie blasting while giving riders access to real-time feedback and data. Typically a class focuses on a rider’s torque and revolutions per minute (RPMs), though one of the Chicago locations we visited also incorporated upper body weight training exercises using a bar in conjunction with spinning.

Disappointingly, the Flywheel class fails to use its data and technology appropriately.

Right away, it became apparent a Flywheel bike looks and feels different than a typical spin cycle. The bikes themselves don’t come equipped with a traditional resistance knob but instead a dial that digitally increases the torque level displayed on the bike’s data screen. Despite the display showing a rider’s speed and power, the trainers failed to explain either metric or its importance to the rider in the session we attended. Ultimately, the metric doesn’t do much to fulfill Flywheel’s goals of implementing real-time performance.

During class, an instructor guided riders through a workout by shouting various torque levels and RPM numbers at different points, creating an interval workout. The class gave riders the discretion to adjust the torque depending on their fitness, but it is required participants hit the desired RPM level. Riders often resorted to bouncing and bobbing to hit that mark, rather than focusing on their individual torque. They end up spending their time over-spinning.

Elsewhere in the room hung two large screen monitors which only went live for several seconds three times during the class. They displayed the classes divided by gender, usernames, seating locale, and order of highest power.

flywheel computrainer spin class feature flywheel2
FlyWheel
FlyWheel

Assuming the bikes have the technology available, why not briefly explain all the ways riders might measure their workout? If people realized their watt output was too low because they didn’t have enough torque, they’d have the ability to adjust rather than over-pedal.

The Flywheel class failed to use this data and technology appropriately. Knowing exactly what these specific metrics mean and how it impacts the rider increases the quality of a workout, and allows riders to measure progress over time. For experienced cyclists, this may not be a big deal, but it’s a disservice to those new to the sport and looking to find ways to improve.

With so many different instructors teaching these classes, it’s entirely possible the data might not seem as relevant to the instructor as, say, the class’ workout music. Because of this, Flywheel comes across as being more about finding a specific teacher — who provides individual riders with the correct atmosphere and relevant information — rather than a data-driven, personalized cycling program designed to empower and transform participants.

CompuTrainer brings professional cycle training to your living room

For the serious cyclist or triathlete, longer workouts or cycling-specific training helps maintain the fitness already gained from riding outdoors. To achieve this type of workout, there’s no better option than taking a bicycle and plopping it onto a CompuTrainer. The program allows riders to create their own custom routines, or make their way to a facility to join in on an offered CompuTrainer-specific class.

There’s no better option to achieving cycling shape than taking a bike and plopping it onto a CompuTrainer.

Our session consisted of a VO2 ride — a high-intensity cardio ride which includes timed intervals at up to 300 percent of our Functional Threshold Power (FTP). To put it plainly, this wasn’t a fun ride. However, it did prove to be highly effective at training us to increase our overall cycling strength. By focusing on speed and cadence — the program tracked and monitored both — we had the ability to keep wattage at its correct level. To help get a better understanding of which cardio zones we cycled in, we threw on a Garmin 225 heart rate monitor to track our heart rate zones alongside our FTP.

Using CompuTrainer allowed us to accurately measure calories, heart rate, and power-to-weight ratio (watts per kilogram), while also showing how much we were able to improve our fitness and technique. Furthermore, the workouts allow riders to adjust effort level to help accommodate for recovery rides or all out sprints.

flywheel computrainer spin class feature computrainer2
CompuTrainer/Twitter
CompuTrainer/Twitter

When initially starting a CompuTrainer session, riders simply enter their weight and FTP, then connect a bike to the computer to calibrate. Most CompuTrainer facilities allow riders to save profiles, meaning they won’t need to calibrate their bike every time. Riders don’t shift gears, as the computer applies resistance automatically, though it does allow for flexibility regarding FTP in the event it becomes too difficult to maintain. The software even allowed for the selection of a pre-designed route, meaning anyone has the ability to ride sections of the Tour de France, or even the Ironman Kona cycling route.

There’s a large variety of riding options on a CompuTrainer, assuming someone has the available space to set it up. The big screen listing a user’s information does tend to get competitive, but it’s an excellent way of trying to improve training and technique.

Human vs. machine — what’s best?

Though Flywheel and CompuTrainer offer very different ways of training indoors, they both incorporate good uses of technology and staying fit throughout the winter months. An instructor’s knowledge for both classes remains paramount to not only motivating their class but also in utilizing superior innovations in fitness data.

There’s no doubt data has the ability to aid a cyclist in achieving their specific goals, but the onus is on the instructors to adequately explain its importance, and how to best utilize it. As we found in the Flywheel classes, that aspect of indoor cycling needs improvement.

Paying attention to one’s form goes a long way in assuring a cyclist gets the most out of a workout. Poor form leads to bad habits — and that’s exactly where the proper evaluation of data helps immensely.

CompuTrainer is the best option for any outdoor cyclist or triathlete looking for intense winter workouts capable of maintaining strict outdoor fitness. It offers highly tailored programs allowing users to completely specify a range of versatile workouts. Whether it’s a recovery run, a course route through digital France, or an aerobic, heart-pounding session, nothing beats the well of available options native to the CompuTrainer.

Emerging Tech

MIT’s smart capsule could be used to release drugs in response to a fever

Researchers have developed a 3D-printed capsule which can monitor patients' vital signs, transmit this information to a connected device, and release drugs in response to symptoms.
Mobile

Walk, run, and stretch with these handy iPhone fitness apps

Working out and getting yourself in shape isn't easy, but it's easier with the right set of apps. These best iPhone fitness apps will help you to track your calories, monitor your sleep, and achieve your fitness goals.
Mobile

Doubts emerge over when LG will reveal its folding smartphone

LG may be working on a folding smartphone, making it the latest device manufacturer to be linked to the technology, which may become one of the standout designs of the coming year.
Music

Here's our head-to-head comparison of Pandora and Spotify

Which music streaming platform is best for you? We pit Spotify versus Pandora, two mighty streaming services with on-demand music and massive catalogs, comparing every facet of the two services to help you decide which is best.
Outdoors

Conquer the cold season with the best heated clothing and outdoor apparel

If you're thinking about going outside this winter, heated apparel is a must. Luckily, we've rounded up some of the best heated clothing, whether you're looking for battery-powered gloves or heated insoles.
Outdoors

Crush your next workout with the best Fitbit for every activity

Fitbits are amazingly helpful tools for setting fitness goals and tracking progress. However, different activities require different metrics. We've gathered a list of the best Fitbits for running, swimming, biking, and other activities.
Emerging Tech

Warm ski beanie instantly hardens into a head-protecting helmet upon impact

Wool hats are way more comfortable than hard helmets. You know what they're not? Safer. That could soon change, thanks to an innovative new ski beanie which instantly hardens upon impact.
Smart Home

Tired of running outdoors? Check out the best treadmills of 2018

Running can burn up to 900 calories per hour, melting away fat and strengthening your muscles.  Compared to running outdoors, you're safer staying indoors on a cushioned track. We've rounded up the best treadmills on the market
Outdoors

Need gift ideas? Here’s what to get the skiers and snowboarders in your life

You can't purchase snow, but you can grab your favorite skier or snowboarder some sweet gear this holiday season. We've hand-picked some of the best available that'll wow even the most well-equipped terrain park junkie we know.
Outdoors

Puma revives its classic 1986 smart shoe, complete with high-tech heel hump

More marketing stunt than serious effort to dominate the smart shoe space, Puma is about to re-release its classic RS-Computer Shoe. The high-tech footwear from 1986 was a breakthrough at the time, despite its unsightly heel hump.
Photography

These are the best action cameras money can buy

Action cameras are great tools for capturing videos of your everyday activities, whether it's a birthday party or the steepest slope you've ever descended on your snowboard. These are the best money can buy.
Outdoors

Drink what nature provides with the best water purifiers

Looking for reliable water purification? Staying hydrated is important, especially when you are hiking or camping far from civilization. Check out our picks of the best water purifiers for your camp, backpack, or pocket.
Wearables

Our favorite fitness trackers make it fun to keep moving

Looking for your first fitness tracker, or an upgrade to the one you're already wearing? There are plenty of the wrist-worn gadgets available. Here are our picks for the best fitness trackers available right now.
Outdoors

Google Maps makes it easier than ever to find a Lime bike or scooter

Google Maps has added a new feature that helps you find a Lime bike or scooter in just a few taps. The feature currently works in 11 U.S. cities served by Lime, with more coming next year.