optical-drive

From modems to serial ports and IR transmitters, these useless built-in technologies still keep popping up in computers even though the world has moved on.

When Microsoft sent out an alert yesterday that there was a security hole in the Bluetooth stack, my reaction was simple: “Not worried, don’t use it.” Twitter follower Paula Thornton (who I now also follow) responded with a different insight: “I’m always amazed and dismayed by all the perfectly great but useless technology we pay for.”

Thinking back, there is a ton of stuff we pay for in a PC that we don’t actually use or care for. Let’s go down a list.

bluetooth-iconBluetooth

This was supposed to be the universal “personal area network” for everything we connected to a smart personal device. Some TVs even have Bluetooth technology built in. But have you ever used a Bluetooth peripheral on a PC? Most folks haven’t, and I’ve tested a number of them over the years and never found one that I could recommend. I recall one of the most beautiful mouse-keyboard combinations from Microsoft a few years back, it was kind of a deep translucent blue with a slight touch of purple. It was gorgeous, but latency was so bad that often I could type up to three words before the letters actually appeared on the screen. It was like the interface passed through some warp in time; it was totally unusable and it broke my heart because it was just so damned good looking.

Even with wireless headsets, which generally do work and are used heavily with cell phones, the range is far less than their proprietary counterparts for desktop use. While I can actually walk outside the house with a proprietary headset, a Bluetooth alternative is only good in the room next door. It just doesn’t make that much sense in a PC.

irIR

This is mostly gone, but for years PCs had an Infrared interface in them. I was never really sure what you used it for, other than letting the person next to you in a plane could easily hack into your PC and get to your stuff if it wasn’t secure. In short, its only purpose seemed to be to allow someone to mess with you at meetings (not that I ever did that myself) or for someone you didn’t want to have access to your laptop to have access to it.

modem-cardModems

Yep these are still in a lot of PCs, but who exactly are people calling to get modem connections? Granted, if you live out in the middle of nowhere, this may be the only way you can get a network connection and exchange email, but it will take you hours to download a file that would fit of an old floppy drive. If you really need one, you don’t need it built into the PC or laptop anyway, because you’ll likely only be able to use it at home (phones at hotels went to digital phones, for the most part, in the 1990s).

parallel-serial-portsParallel and serial Ports

I’m still seeing these on some products, but what the heck are people hooking these into? Printers stopped using them a decade ago, and are dirt cheap. I can’t actually recall anymore the last time I saw something that used a serial port. USB adapters exist for both and, seriously if you need one of these for anything it suggests you haven’t been on the same timeline with the rest of us. They just take up space and add to the complexity of the PC.

pause-breakThe break key

There aren’t a lot of us around who even remember what you used this key for. It goes back to when PCs worked as terminal emulators. It was like someone grandfathered this and can’t think of anything else they want to use this key for. I can think of something, how about cursor radar, because I’m often losing the damn thing on my screen.

laptop-optical-driveOptical drives

Apple stopped putting optical drives in many of its computers (notably the MacBook Air) some time ago. They are the new floppy drive. Blu-ray drives never really caught on in PCs, and it is vastly easier to use a hard drive backup product that will hold up to terabytes of data than an optical drive which, at most, holds under 5GB. Flash drives are faster, smaller, and far more convenient anyway. In addition, most of the software you now get comes down from the Web, and increasingly through app stores.

Granted there are a few times I’ve watched a DVD while on the road or on an airplane, but recently I’ve started streaming while I’m in a hotel, and airplanes have become so tight that using the laptop for anything has become just too uncomfortable.

One thing to fix

You know, the one thing that even Apple hasn’t done a good job with is the laptop power supply. MacBooks use the nice magnetic connector, but by integrating the supply and the plug, they often take up to three sockets on a power strip (unless you swap the built-in prongs for the cable, as with later Mac power supplies), making Apple users disliked at meetings. You can have a beautiful, lightweight laptop only to have the entire experience ruined by an ugly brick.

Tablets have smaller chargers, but cable management still sucks and contributes to the rat’s nest of cables I have floating around in my backpack. You can use the Zipling cords, but that is only a stop gap. As I’m thinking about getting rid of things, this is one more thing on my wish list that really needs another pass.

What do you think? What would you like to see expire or get fixed on your desktop or laptop computer?

Showing 15 comments

  1. Jonathan Patrick Hines at 5:49pm 13th July 2011 Bluetooth still has its uses. Bit more secure at home (30m range), and less complex interfacing vs wifi. Just need to introduce a stronger pairing protocol.
  2. Charl Pantaleon at 10:43am 13th July 2011 Optical drives are still very useful if you don't have a huge HDD and want to play games / music / etc.| Not to mention CD ripped to FLAC provides better sound quality (and the guarantee that the file is actually FLAC)
  3. BurntHam77 at 9:28am 13th July 2011 Ever since I moved to buying games via download services, like Steam and Impulse, I do find that my DVD drive gets minimal usage. However, I still buy CDs and rip them, so I don't see myself giving up my optical drive anytime soon. I am just not yet ready to move my music collection to a digital download service, mainly because I switch media players once every few years and I don't want to be tied to one service. Plus my HTPC plays blu-rays and I love those. Everything else on this list does need to go.
    1. Ian Bell at 9:40am 13th July 2011 So true. I don't even have a Blu-ray player in my high-end system because I didn't see a need for it. I have been using Steam and EA's origin for downloading games to my system. And on my laptop, the only time I used a CD drive (external one) was to install my software. I haven't used it since.
  4. Digital Trends at 4:25pm 13th July 2011 @Sais - I think Rob means in a desktop PC only....
  5. Sais Shishir KS at 3:31pm 13th July 2011 Bluetooth is uselesss?? :O
  6. Ilya D at 3:11pm 13th July 2011 I always wanted a laptop with no optical drive but with a power cord that came out like on a vacuum cleaner... I never understood why the power supply and cord were not integrated into laptops... cuz honestly when do you actually ever take you laptop without the powersupply anywhere?
  7. Michael Stewart at 2:57pm 13th July 2011 isn't that what tablets are for?
  8. jadis40 at 7:55am 13th July 2011 I don't think that optical drives are useless - coming from the viewpoint of someone who likes to play PC games, and depends on the CD/DVD drive for that very purpose. With that being said, I will concede the point that when it comes to backing up data on a large scale, a CD is inferior to something like a flash drive. I know I would not consider buying an Apple computer, because they don't include the optical drive.
  9. Ian Bell at 7:52am 13th July 2011 Not sure why Bluetooth is on this list. If anyone has tried using a WiFi enabled printer, they quickly realize how bad they suck. I also think Bluetooth mice are great for traveling with a laptop. Travel WiFi mice require a USB dongle to send the signal, and I hate having a USB port dedicated to it.
  10. Dan Gaul at 7:49am 13th July 2011 All macs still come with the optical drive except for the Macbook Air. Makes sense that they don't include it in that product, as they are trying to keep it light and thin.
  11. TechMichael at 7:07am 13th July 2011 Nice article, however, with respect to the Apple MacBooks, mine came with a three prong adapter for the "Brick." This means that I may sit farther from the power socket and still charge my computer without wreaking havoc with my neighbors.
  12. Jan Galeon at 6:33am 13th July 2011 i actually use the bluetooth from my laptop. oh well
  13. hvdkooij at 6:24am 13th July 2011 Right. Being an engineer I have been very refusing replacement laptops several times just because there was NO serial interface on the laptop. I rather have an old laptop that has a build in serial port then a newer one without one. You just can't afford blue screens when troubleshooting vital equipment in the middle of the night because a USB device disconnects too easily.
  14. barrilchrist at 4:51am 13th July 2011 in very rare cases a writer will not read a home burnt disk from another computer them it is handy to have a normal cd/dvd rom since they read most any disk types.
Close Suggestion Email could use a revamp, not a replacement
View Article