Skip to main content

Study shows drivers aren’t ready to relinquish full control to autonomous cars

Acura RLX Automated Development Vehicle
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Self-driving cars are on the way, it seems, but are consumers ready for them? A new study by the University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute (UMTRI) found that most drivers aren’t ready to give up complete control to the machines, but that they will accept some vehicular autonomy.

Of 618 respondents, about 46 percent said they preferred to retain full control of a vehicle, while about 39 percent said they prefer a partially self-driving car that requires only occasional assistance from a human driver. Less than 16 percent said their top choice would be to ride in a fully autonomous car.

About two thirds of the respondents said they were moderately or very concerned about riding in a fully autonomous car, and about half of respondents expressed the same level of concern over riding in cars that are partially autonomous. UMTRI researchers conducted a similar study last year, and say results for the 2016 study largely mirror the results from that one.

Read more: Google’s self-driving car has an algorithm for honking

“Overall public opinion has been remarkably consistent over the two years that this survey has been conducted, despite the increased media coverage of self-driving vehicles,” Brandon Schoettle, who, along with Michael Sivak, conducted both studies, said in a statement. Carmakers, the tech industry, and various analysts are pushing self-driving cars because of anticipated safety and efficiency benefits, and relief from the stress of commuting. They generally assume those benefits will be enough to get consumers onboard.

Respondents were also asked whether self-driving cars should have backup manual controls, and the overwhelming response was “yes.” There has been much discussion about the need for steering wheels and accelerator and brake pedals in self-driving cars, but 95 percent of respondents said they wanted them. The most popular method for inputting destinations was the touchscreen, with 38 percent of the vote, followed by voice command, with 36 percent.

The bridge between conventional cars and fully autonomous vehicles is partially autonomous cars that still require humans to take control in certain situations. Automakers are currently struggling with how to keep drivers from simply tuning out when going into autonomous mode. The UMTRI study showed that 59 percent of respondents preferred a combination of sound, vibration, and visual warnings to notify them, although that doesn’t necessarily mean those methods will be effective in getting a person’s attention in time.

Editors' Recommendations

Stephen Edelstein
Stephen is a freelance automotive journalist covering all things cars. He likes anything with four wheels, from classic cars…
Ford and VW close down Argo AI autonomous car unit
An Argo AI autonomous car on the road.

Autonomous-car specialist Argo AI is closing down after Ford and Volkswagen, Argo's main backers, ended support for the Pittsburgh-based company.

First reported by TechCrunch and later confirmed by the two auto giants, some of the 2,000 workers at Argo will transfer to Ford and Volkswagen, while others without an offer will receive a severance package. Argo’s technology is also set to end up in the possession of the two companies, though at this stage it’s not clear how it might be shared.

Read more
Ex-Apple employee pleads guilty to nabbing Apple Car secrets
The Apple logo is displayed at the Apple Store June 17, 2015 on Fifth Avenue in New York City

A former Apple employee on Monday pled guilty to the theft of trade secrets from the tech firm.

The material stolen by Xiaolang Zhang was linked to Apple’s work on its first-ever automobile, a project that’s been in and out of the headlines for years though never officially confirmed by the company.

Read more
A weird thing just happened with a fleet of autonomous cars
A passenger getting into a Cruise robotaxi.

In what must be one of the weirder stories linked to the development of autonomous vehicles, a fleet of Cruise self-driving cars gathered together at an intersection in San Francisco earlier this week, parked up, and blocked traffic for several hours. And to be clear: No, they weren't supposed to do that.

Some observers may have thought they were witnessing the start of the robot uprising, but the real reason for the mishap was more prosaic: An issue with the platform's software.

Read more