Skip to main content

Consumers concerned about self-driving cars, study finds

google reportedly pursuing manufacturing partner for self driving car
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Carmakers, tech companies, and a growing cadre of advocates seem pretty gung ho about self-driving cars, but will consumers be as enthusiastic when these vehicles finally arrive in showrooms?

A recent study by the University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute found that consumers prefer to keep control of their cars. The majority of the 505 respondents seemed to prefer vehicles with less automation, and expressed concern about riding in autonomous cars.

The results were released by researchers Brandon Schoettle and Michael Sivak Wednesday, days before a 32-acre testing facility for autonomous and connected cars is scheduled to open at the University of Michigan’s Ann Arbor campus.

When asked what level of vehicle automation they preferred, 43.8 percent of respondents said none. That was the most frequent response, followed by partially self-driving at 40.6 percent. Completely self-driving was the least-chosen option at 15.6 percent.

Similar reticence was expressed about riding in a self-driving car. The study found that 35.6 percent of respondents were “very concerned” about riding in a fully automated car, 32.7 percent were “moderately concerned,” and 20.8 percent were “slightly concerned.” Just 10.9 percent of respondents were “not concerned at all.”

Things were somewhat different with partially self-driving cars. When asked about riding in one of those,  14.1 percent of respondents said they were “very concerned,” 34.7 percent said they were “moderately concerned,” and 35.0 percent were “slightly concerned. That left 16.2 percent “not at all concerned.”

Regardless of their level of comfort with self-driving cars, the vast majority of respondents said they wanted the means to take manual control, with 96.2 percent saying they would want an autonomous car to have a steering wheel and throttle and brake pedals.

Those are things many proponents of self-driving cars would like to get rid of. By eliminating human error, self-driving cars are supposed to dramatically reduce crashes, and the more consistent driving style of machines will save fuel as well, the argument goes. Plus, all of that time normally spent concentrating on the road can be used for other things.

But first, manufacturers will have to deliver on those promises. The somewhat utopian vision of a future where self-driving cars are dominant rests on the assumption that the technology will work as advertised when the big moment comes.

While companies like Google have seen encouraging results from prototype vehicles, it will be at least a few years before a fully autonomous car is ready to be put on sale. Until that happens, the promises made by advocates of self-driving cars are just that, which perhaps makes consumer concerns justified.

Editors' Recommendations

Stephen Edelstein
Stephen is a freelance automotive journalist covering all things cars. He likes anything with four wheels, from classic cars…
Waymo expands robotaxi service area in San Francisco
The upcoming Zeekr vehicle from Geely.

Robotaxi leader Waymo is expanding its ridesharing service area in San Francisco.

The Alphabet-owned company announced move on Monday in a message on X, the social media platform formerly known as Twitter. It means that more riders can now take trips in Waymo’s driverless vehicles within a 47-square-mile area of the city.

Read more
Cruise autonomous vehicle drives over woman just after she was hit by another car
A Cruise autonomous car.

An autonomous vehicle (AV) operated by Cruise ran over a pedestrian in San Francisco on Monday night just after she’d been hit by another car, the San Francisco Chronicle reported.

According to witnesses, the force of the initial impact knocked the woman into the path of the Cruise robotaxi, leaving her pinned under one of its wheels. The driver in the other car reportedly fled the scene.

Read more
Cruise says it’s nearing approval for mass production of futuristic robotaxi
Interior of Cruise's Origin vehicle.

Robotaxi company Cruise is “just days away” from getting regulatory approval that would pave the way for mass production of its purpose-built driverless vehicle, CEO Kyle Vogt said on Thursday in comments reported by the Detroit Free Press.

General Motors-backed Cruise unveiled the vehicle -- called Origin -- in early 2020, presenting the kind of driverless car that we all dreamed of when R&D in the sector kicked off years ago; a vehicle without a steering wheel and without pedals. A vehicle with passenger seats only.

Read more