Skip to main content

Land Rover R&D chief hates self-driving cars, says people aren’t ‘cargo’

audi piloted a7 concept
Audi’s piloted driving prototypes drive themselves, but always with a human driver in the front seat, just in case. Image used with permission by copyright holder
Land Rover may have just built a remote-control Range Rover, but the company’s R&D chief Wolfgang Epple isn’t too enthusiastic about self-driving cars. In fact, he claims Jaguar Land Rover won’t build a fully autonomous car on his watch.

“We don’t consider consumers cargo. We don’t want to build a robot that delivers the cargo from A to B,” Epple told Automotive News Europe at the press event where Land Rover unveiled its prototype remote-control feature.

Epple said that JLR prefers to develop autonomous systems that assist drivers, but never fully remove them from control. The remote-control system allows a driver to get out and maneuver a vehicle using a smartphone in certain situations, but ultimately the human is still in charge.

Land Rover says the system could go into production by 2020. By that time, Mercedes-Benz, Nissan, and Tesla plan to have cars with something approaching full self-driving capability on sale.

Epple also disagrees with Tesla CEO Elon Musk’s belief that human-driven cars will eventually be outlawed. A few months ago, he said nonautonomous cars could be made illegal because the public will eventually decide they’re too dangerous.

audi-piloted-a7-concept-dash
Image used with permission by copyright holder

“The reason is that lawmakers are human beings,” Epple said. He and officials at other carmakers are counting on people’s emotional investment in driving to preserve the soul of the car business.

Epple said that even with increased autonomy, drivers will always be able to take control on their favorite stretch of road, and they’ll always want to.

“People want to use the emotional side of the brain and autonomous driving does not generate that experience,” he said.

Carmakers rely on emotionality and subjective features like the character of handling or ride quality to differentiate their products. That will be hard to do if the way a car drives is removed from the consumer equation.

At the same time, despite all of the talk of increased safety, efficiency, and free time, it’s hard to imagine that everyone will be content being a passenger in an undifferentiated transportation pod. If people were really that ambivalent about driving, they wouldn’t pine after cars like the Jaguar F-Type or Corvette Z06.

Corporations use emotions to manipulate consumers, but that doesn’t mean emotional attachments to products can’t be genuine. The human experience is about more than guaranteeing safety and productivity, and it remains to be seen whether self-driving cars will be able to achieve that higher level of purpose.

Stephen Edelstein
Stephen is a freelance automotive journalist covering all things cars. He likes anything with four wheels, from classic cars…
To reach level 4 autonomy, these self-driving cars head to winter boot camp
Sensible 4 winter driving

Is there a more magical seasonal sight than snowflakes falling on banks of snow under a white sky, the only bursts of color to break up the merry scene being a jolly holly bush or a Christmas robin hopping across the top of a frozen fence? Maybe not if you’re a human. If you’re a self-driving car, on the other hand, that scene is pretty darn terrifying.

Autonomous vehicles are increasingly great at parsing street scenes and safely navigating according to either camera images or bounced Lidar inputs. Unfortunately, snow is an issue for both cameras and laser scanners due to noise (read: falling snow) blocking the sensors, and white-out conditions preventing the camera from seeing surroundings properly.

Read more
Uber gives up on developing its own self-driving car
Uber self-driving car

Uber has announced it's selling its self-driving car unit, although it isn’t entirely cutting its interest in autonomous vehicles.

The company will sell its autonomous-vehicle unit -- Advanced Technologies Group (ATG) -- to Aurora, a Silicon Valley-based company founded in 2017 by former contributors to self-driving-car projects operated by Google (now Waymo) and Uber.

Read more
This self-driving racing car could have done with a driver
watch this self driving racing car slam straight into a wall roborace accident

No one ever said building an autonomous car would be easy.

While a number of companies have certainly made incredible progress with the technology over the last decade or so, some are clearly faring better than others.

Read more