Skip to main content

Watchdog not letting Microsoft off the hook on Windows 10 privacy, choice issues

windows 10 insider preview 14955 outlook mail calendar narrator upgrade
Bill Roberson/Digital Trends
While the free upgrade offer for Windows 10 ended at the end of the July, the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) isn’t letting Microsoft off the hook for alleged privacy and consumer choice infringements.

According to the digital rights nonprofit, Microsoft has “trampled” on privacy and consumers’ right to choose a product. Since its release, Windows 10 has been criticized for frequent upgrade reminders — including accusations of unsolicited automatic upgrades — as well as gathering an unnecessary amount of data on its users.

The insistent upgrade ads and reminders are part of Microsoft’s ambitious mission to have a billion devices running Windows 10 by 2018.

“The tactics Microsoft employed to get users of earlier versions of Windows to upgrade to Windows 10 went from annoying to downright malicious,” said Amul Kalia, EFF intake coordinator. He pointed to Microsoft reinstalling an advertising app for Windows 10 in users’ system trays as an example.

“Eventually, Microsoft started pushing Windows 10 via its Windows Update system,” he added, further criticizing the company for making the upgrade a recommended update for users next to the standard updates. “Time after time, with each update, Microsoft chose to employ questionable tactics to cause users to download a piece of software that many didn’t want.”

EFF continued to draw attention to security and privacy shortcomings that have been well-documented in Windows 10. The organization said the OS collects an “unprecedented amount of usage data” such as location data, text input, voice input, touch input, browsing history, and what programs you are running.

Microsoft has defended these practices, saying they help make the OS more personalized to the user. EFF raises concerns over whether or not opting out of these features is sufficient enough for the user as some data is still likely being gathered and sent back to servers.

“Microsoft should come clean with its user community,” said Kalia. “The company needs to acknowledge its missteps and offer real, meaningful opt outs to the users who want them, preferably in a single unified screen.”

He added that the company needs to clearly separate its operating system upgrades from its regular system updates to avoid any confusion.

EFF warns Microsoft that it may face lawsuits and government investigations into its practices if it doesn’t remedy these. One person is already petitioning on Change.org for EFF to carry out its own investigation into Windows 10.

Editors' Recommendations

Jonathan Keane
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Jonathan is a freelance technology journalist living in Dublin, Ireland. He's previously written for publications and sites…
I hope Microsoft adds this rumored AI feature to Windows 11
A Windows 11 device sits on a table.

From smart speakers to ChatGPT and Bing Chat, AI has slowly crept into our lives, but not all instances of AI are as prominent as those three examples. Sometimes, the effect is subtle, but still pretty nice. It appears that Microsoft is working on one such instance of AI-enhanced tech that could make using Windows 11 just a little more pleasant. We're talking about AI-powered live wallpapers, and they might be coming soon.

First spotted by Windows Latest, Microsoft is readying an AI-powered desktop that could make the whole user experience feel a lot more interactive. The idea is to adjust depth perception and make some backgrounds appear more "alive" when moving your cursor or the entire device. The wallpaper might move or shift, depending on what you're doing on the desktop.

Read more
Microsoft is removing a Windows app that’s almost 30 years old
Computer user touching on Microsoft word icon to open the program.

Microsoft is saying goodbye to WordPad, its long-supported rich text application, which will no longer receive updates as of September 1.

The brand recently announced that the app is now among its list of deprecated Windows features. Microsoft explained the difference between deprecation and removal, noting that the former is when a feature is at the end of its life cycle and is no longer in active development, and the latter is when a feature is removed after having been deprecated.

Read more
Ranking all 12 versions of Windows, from worst to best
Windows 7 desktop.

You can tell a person's age by which version of Windows is their favorite. I have fond memories of XP and Windows 98 SE, so you can take a guess at mine, but I have colleagues who are much more enamored with Windows 7 or Windows 95. We all have something disparaging to say about Windows 8 though, and the less said about Windows Vista the better.

Ranking the different versions of Windows is about more than what era of computing you grew up in, though. There are some very serious duds in Microsoft's back catalog, just as there are a few wins too. With rumors about Windows 12 swirling, it's worth looking back at some of all the previous versions, ranked from the absolute worst to the very best.
12. Windows ME

Read more