Skip to main content

New FCC proposal threatens to eradicate the open Internet

Detailed within a report published by the Wall Street Journal earlier today, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) will be distributing a proposal tomorrow that allows broadband Internet providers the ability to provide preferential speed treatment to content providers that pay for that privilege. While each deal must be considered “commercially reasonable” by FCC regulators on a case-by-case basis, this would allow large companies to pay for faster delivery of high-bandwidth content like streaming video and multiplayer games. However, smaller companies that can’t afford the speed upgrade will have to try to survive without that advantage.

This policy shift goes against the core promise of net neutrality, a belief that all Internet traffic should be treated equally. Assuming the new FCC proposal is passed before the end of the year, it’s inevitable that some companies will be discriminated against simply because they can’t pay a speed tax. This proposal spawned after an appeals court ruled against the FCC’s net neutrality rules during January 2014.

Recommended Videos

“Barriers to innovation will rise, the marketplace of ideas on the Internet will be constrained, and consumers will ultimately pay the price.”

It’s also likely that the cost of faster content delivery will be passed along to the consumer, regardless of the size of the company. Companies like Netflix and Amazon will have to add that cost into the subscription fee for their video streaming services. The same goes for gaming publishers like Electronic Arts that provide online gaming access to millions. While probably unlikely, that additional cost could be offset by broadband Internet providers providing faster Internet speeds for a reduced cost to consumers since new revenue is being generated from content providers.

Conceptually, the FCC’s proposal is attempting to halt broadband Internet providers from intentionally slowing down access to content providers. By providing a structured route to pay for preferential treatment, situations like Verizon or Comcast limiting Netflix access speeds could be eliminated. It’s important to note that the FCC rules would only be applied to broadband Internet providers, not wireless carriers. At this time, mobile service providers don’t have to apply net neutrality rules to their services.

Prior to news of the proposal, FCC chairman Tom Wheeler, the creator of the proposal, has indicated that the rules dictating a level playing field for the Internet would have to be changed. The remainder of the commission voting on the proposal is comprised of two Republicans, Ajit Pai and Michael O’Reilly, as well as two Democrats, Mignon Clyburn and Jessica Rosenworcel. Assuming the commissioners voted based on party leanings, the vote could end up split with Wheeler passing the deciding vote in favor of the proposal. 

Not surprisingly, reactions to the proposal have been fairly negative from consumer advocacy groups. For instance, a representative from the American Civil Liberties Union released a statement which read “If the FCC embraces this reported reversal in its stance toward net neutrality, barriers to innovation will rise, the marketplace of ideas on the Internet will be constrained, and consumers will ultimately pay the price.” 

Todd O’Boyle, director of Common Cause’s Media and Democracy Reform Initiative, told the New York Times “If it goes forward, this capitulation will represent Washington at its worst. Americans were promised, and deserve, an Internet that is free of toll roads, fast lanes and censorship — corporate or governmental.”

(Image © tr3gin via Shutterstock.com)

 
Mike Flacy
By day, I'm the content and social media manager for High-Def Digest, Steve's Digicams and The CheckOut on Ben's Bargains…
Topics
This iBuyPower gaming PC with 16GB of RAM is on sale for $830
The iBuyPower Element SE gaming PC on a white background.

For gaming PC deals that will give you excellent value, you should check out iBuyPower offers. Here's one from Best Buy: the iBuyPower Element SE gaming desktop at $100 off, which pulls its price down from $930 to $830. Gamers who are looking for a gaming PC for less than $1,000 won't want to miss this bargain, but you're going to have to hurry if you're interested because there's no assurance that the discount will still be online by tomorrow.

Why you should buy the iBuyPower Element SE gaming PC

Read more
The Dell XPS 13 and XPS 14 are both on sale at $300 off — hurry!
Angled front view of the Dell XPS 13 with Snapdragon X Elite processor inside.

Are you in the market for a new laptop? You simply can't go wrong with any of the Dell XPS deals that are available, and we've identified two of the best ones you can shop right now. The Dell XPS 13 9350, originally sold for $1,400, is down to $1,100 for savings of $300, while the Dell XPS 14 9440, which has a sticker price of $1,560, is on sale for $1,260, also following a $300 discount.

Following the Dell XPS reset early last year, the Dell XPS 13 and the Dell XPS 14 have further blossomed in popularity. That means you'll have to act fast if you're interested in either of these laptop deals though, as the stocks up for sale may run out at any moment.

Read more
Meta made insane offers in bid to nab OpenAI talent, Altman claims
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman during the Uncapped podcast in June 2025.

OpenAI chief Sam Altman has said that Meta tried to tempt his top AI researchers to switch sides by offering hiring bonuses of $100 million. Yes, you read that right -- $100 million. Altman said that up to now, none of his top team have left for Mark Zuckerberg's Meta.

Altman made the claim on Tuesday in the Uncapped podcast, hosted by his brother, Jack.

Read more