Skip to main content

Microsoft won’t have to turn over emails from servers in Ireland, court rules

microsoft foreign emails data center
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Microsoft prevailed in a Thursday court decision in preventing the U.S. government from obtaining emails stored on a server in Ireland, in a case that is said to have important ramifications for privacy in general. The government was attempting to seize emails of a suspected drug trafficker, but Microsoft claimed granting access could set a dangerous legal precedent and a “legal free-for-all.”

The government argued that barring access would create a legal loophole that would allow fraudsters, hackers, and drug traffickers to operate without the fear of prosecution. Microsoft countered by saying ruling for the government could open the doors for other foreign courts to demand access to servers on American soil.

A federal district court had ruled in the government’s favor in 2014, but Microsoft won on appeal in the Thursday decision. The appeals court ruled that U.S. law does not allow for courts to order the seizure of data that is stored exclusively on foreign servers.

Legal experts watched the case closely as the ruling could answer questions surrounding the privacy of data stored outside of the country. The Electronic Communications Privacy Act of 1986 was written three years before the web even existed, and at that point there was no consideration given to how the courts should act when the digital information needed in a case only exists overseas.

There is a process by which governments can request evidence from foreign countries, however it is often time consuming. There also might be stricter controls on user privacy in the country where that server is located, making data seizure all but impossible through this route.

American cloud providers also worried that any negative ruling might also deter foreign companies from using their services, given that a favorable ruling for the U.S. government might open their data up to inspection in a similar type of event.

Neither the Justice Department nor Microsoft had any immediate comment on the ruling.

Editors' Recommendations

Ed Oswald
For fifteen years, Ed has written about the latest and greatest in gadgets and technology trends. At Digital Trends, he's…
Best Buy laptop deals: Cheap laptops starting at $219
Apple M1 MacBook Air open on a desk with plants in the background.

If you're looking for the best laptop deals, we won't blame you if your first thought is taking a trip down to Best Buy. It's one of our favorite laptop dealers and is pretty much always a great place to shop for a bargain. But before you go, you should know that their online store is popping full of great deals as well. In fact, Best Buy is one of our preferred places to buy laptops online due to their tech support.

Just because you can get great laptop deals at Best Buy, including in their online store, doesn't mean that all of the deals are created equal, though. That's why we've assembled a collection of the very best laptop deals at Best Buy for your to shop through. Sometimes an item makes our list because the bargain is steep. Others, because the deal is for one of the best laptops that would be worth buying even without a discount.

Read more
Surface Pro 10: here’s what to expect from the next generation
The Surface Pro 9 in laptop mode on a table.

Microsoft has consistently put out a new version of its most popular Surface device, the Surface Pro. With it due to celebrate its 10th anniversary this year, it's an important milestone for the device and may herald some exciting changes and upgrades over the still-impressive last-generation device, the Surface Pro 9.

As we edge closer to its impending release, here's what we know about the Surface Pro 10 so far.

Read more
Should you buy the Surface Laptop Studio or wait for the Surface Laptop Studio 2?
The Surface Laptop Studio 2 on a white table.

Announced during the Microsoft September event, the Surface Laptop Studio 2 joins a growing family of Surface devices. Equipped with all the same flexibility we'd expect from the best 2-in-1 laptops, the Studio 2 may look very similar to the previous version, but it's a lot more different than it seems at a glance.

How does the new version compare to Microsoft's original Laptop Studio? Below, we'll take you on a deep dive into these two devices and help you make your pick if you're trying to choose between them.
Pricing and availability

Read more