Skip to main content

Court upholds Microsoft ruling to protect data in Ireland from U.S. government

Image used with permission by copyright holder
A federal appeals court ruled the U.S. government cannot search a server in another country, upholding the original verdict.

The case pertained to a Microsoft server in Dublin that was reportedly central to an ongoing narcotics investigation. Law enforcement wanted to access emails of a suspect that were stored on the server but Microsoft denied access.

Microsoft stated that U.S. law did not allow for search warrants to be issued for servers in other countries, even if it’s an American company and the data belonged to an American citizen. The company and its supporters believed that allowing such access would set a bad precedent.

The U.S. government had appealed the original ruling from July but on Tuesday, the 2nd  Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals in Manhattan declined to overturn the ruling. Law enforcement had employed the Stored Communications Act to issue the search warrant in the first place. They will now have to seek some other legal means to accessing the data. The Department of Justice had previously stated that the ruling would inspire more companies to store data outside the U.S. to avoid the reach of authorities.

The ruling was not a clean sweep, though. Judges ruled 4-4, meaning the original ruling would stand but opposition judges voiced their dissatisfaction. Some dissenting opinions from judges pointed out that the ruling could hamper law enforcement investigations in the future.

“We are reviewing the decision and its multiple dissenting opinions and considering our options,” a spokesperson for the Department of Justice said.

Microsoft’s chief legal officer Brad Smith, on the other hand, said the company welcomed the ruling. “We need Congress to modernize the law both to keep people safe and ensure that governments everywhere respect each other’s borders,” he said. Smith has been a regular critic of how the government conducts these kinds of searches, calling for better and clearer laws on the matter.

Microsoft has become one of the U.S. government’s most vocal critics of how it issues search warrants for data. In 2016, it launched a legal battle against the government to try and overturn a law that prevents service providers from informing users when their data has been seized by law enforcement. It has called the gag orders unconstitutional.

Editors' Recommendations

Jonathan Keane
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Jonathan is a freelance technology journalist living in Dublin, Ireland. He's previously written for publications and sites…
Google will charge law enforcement and government agencies to access user data
Google's Logo

Google has begun charging law enforcement for access to user data, according to a report by the New York Times. The company is levying fees of $45 for a subpoena, $60 for a wiretap, and $245 for a search warrant, according to documents reviewed by the NYT.

The company receives a high volume of requests from law enforcement agencies to hand over data about its users and has therefore decided to bring in charges to "offset the costs" of compiling this data. According to the report, Google is legally allowed to levy these charges but traditionally big technology companies have handed over data without any charges.

Read more
U.S. may call a halt to its civilian drone program over security fears
DJI Mavic 2 Pro

The U.S. Department of Interior (DoI) is set to permanently ground its fleet of around 1,000 drones because of fears over security, the Financial Times (FT) reported.

The remotely controlled quadcopters were taken out of service in October 2019 pending a thorough review of the civilian drone program amid concerns that the Chinese-made machines could be used to send sensitive data back to China.

Read more
The U.S. government says you need to update Firefox right now
Mozilla Firefox

If you use the Mozilla Firefox web browser, the government recommends that you update the browser because of a zero-day vulnerability that could enable hackers to take control of your computer. 

The United States Department of Homeland Security's Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) is encouraging those with the Firefox browser to update to versions 72.0.1 and ESR 68.4.1.

Read more