Microsoft’s Surface Dial is proof your mouse is holding you back

microsofts surface dial mice holding us back

How do you control your computer? For most people, the answer is “a keyboard and mouse.”

In the last 20 years of computing, the biggest innovation in input has been the slow shift from cursor-based pointing devices to touchscreen. Yet even here, many users are reluctant to give up their computer mouse, because they see touchscreens as a less efficient and less accurate method of obtaining very similar results.

But what if it’s the computer mouse that’s holding us back?

Mouse trap

Mice are considered a jack-of-all-trades that can handle just about any task. Billions of people use them, from gamers to scientists. You might think it was built with broad use in mind — but actually, it was designed to solve a very specific problem.

The modern computer mouse is thought to be a jack-of-all-trades – but is it?

The roller ball technology used by the first mice dates to 1946, when British scientist and electrical engineer Ralph Benjamin invented the technique for use with the Royal Navy’s Comprehensive Display System. The CDS was used to predict the future position of aircraft, using a joystick to input and control calculations. Sound awkward? Well, it was.

Benjamin felt he could provide a more elegant input method.

In the 1960s, Douglas Engelbart and Bill English constructed the first prototype of their computer mouse while working at the Standford Research Institute. It used a wheel, rather than a ball, to track movement — but its physical implementation was like today’s mice. When that idea was combined with the roller ball mechanism, the computer mouse was born.

In his 1962 paper, Augmenting Human Intellect: A Conceptual Framework, Engelbart refers to his proto-mouse as a “pointer,” and that has a greater relevance. At the time, a peripheral that could point at elements on the screen was sorely needed. But today, our needs have become more sophisticated than the basic “point and click.”

Dialing in

Almost everyone, regardless of their familiarity with technology, is expected to know how to operate a computer mouse. Yet, as the history shows, the mouse wasn’t invented to solve every problem. It’s perfect for selecting a point in a two-dimensional area, but modern computers let users do a lot more than that.

Microsoft’s Dial is a great example. Though it’s new, the dial as a concept is not, even in relation to computers. Dials are used extensively in digital music production and performance. Adjusting the frequency or the volume of a track in a composition is better served by a twistable knob; performing the same action with a mouse cursor feels clumsy and inaccurate.

Yet the advantages of a dial stretch beyond the world of audio. Nashville, Tennessee’s Griffin Technology has been selling a peripheral of this kind since 2001. Called the PowerMate, it’s a rotatable knob that connects to your computer via USB. Users have more adopted it as part of various do-it-yourself projects, or as an alternate control method for driving games and space sims.

One size does not fit all

Calvin Chu is a man that knows more than most about introducing a new input peripheral to the computing market. In 2013, he spearheaded a Kickstarter campaign to fund the development of a product called Palette Gear, a modular set of physical inputs intended to help every user find a set-up that works for their individual needs. One of these inputs is a dial.

“A lot of our inspiration came from the past,” Chu explained when spoke to Digital Trends. “There have been a lot of previous interfaces that used the rotation paradigm to increase or decrease a certain value, or a certain function — we just thought it was very natural.”

A lot of value can be found in tools made to fit the way you work.

Chu and his team decided to include a dial as one component of Palette Gear because it’s a fundamental feature for certain tasks. As he describes it, the dial is among the “elemental forms of interaction.”

Palette Gear is comprised of three main components; dials, buttons, and sliders. Users can pick and choose as many as they like. “We think the modular aspect is very important,” said Chu. “There’s just a lot of value when the tools and the interface are made to fit the way you work.”

Both the Surface Dial and Palette Gear appeal to users because they offer a different way to interact with a computer. “We think there are a lot of similar philosophies,” said Chu. “I think both Palette and Microsoft, we’re looking to offer these new classes of input, and these new paradigms of interaction. But I think we’re both doing it in different ways. So I don’t think that it’s a competitor — I think it’s actually really great validation that people need better tools.”

Palette and Microsoft are two very different companies, but they’re linked by a common goal of introducing alternative input peripherals. It’ll certainly be interesting to see how Microsoft tackles one of the biggest challenges that Palette has faced in bringing its product to fruition; ensuring that the device plays well with others.

Better tools for the job

“We’ve been spending a lot of time expanding our software integration,” said Chu. “So, working with a lot more apps within video editing and photography.

“It’s always been a challenge for us, because we really care about the overall experience. To a user, you don’t really see who’s responsible or controlling what, so we spent a lot of time making sure that those integrations, and all the functions we had to control, are really well done.”

There’s a reason why previous dial peripherals were relegated to niche use, or adopted by tinkerers like the DIY community; it’s very difficult to ensure that a device like this works with a wide range of hardware and software. Unusual forms of input must take the time to establish custom support for individual pieces of software, or implement a catch-all solution that’s not as finely tuned.

Palette opted for the former, working with a list of companies that includes Adobe, to ensure that its peripherals work perfectly with popular pieces of software. Microsoft certainly has the clout to take a similar approach, assuming the Surface Dial is popular enough to warrant continued support.

The end of “one size fits all”

It’s not easy to introduce an all-new input device.  It’s easier to use a computer mouse for every possible eventuality, and design software around it. Yet as PCs evolve, users seem to be craving new devices that are better at specific tasks, even if they’re not useful in every app.

“I think it should have happened earlier,” said Chu. “It’s a little surprising how really only the audio industry, and maybe some other very high-end professionals, have these dedicated tools that are made for their specific uses. Everybody else — 99 percent of everybody else — uses keyboard shortcuts, and a mouse cursor, and a one-size-fits-all solution.”

Hopefully, the fact that leviathans like Microsoft, and creative upstarts like Palette, are both working on alternatives means we’re headed toward a computing landscape that’s less concerned with that “one-size-fits-all” mentality.

Product Review

With sapphire glass and analog dials, you'd never know this watch is smart

The world of hybrid smartwatches is getting much larger, and the latest comes from a name with history — New York Standard Watches. In our NYSW GTS Activity Tracker review, we find out what makes this watch special, and why we were so…
Computing

Detangle your desk with a mighty wireless mouse. Here are our six favorites

If you're looking for the best wireless mouse on the market, we've got the list for you!. These six models have something for everyone, whether you're a hardcore gamer or simply looking to ward off carpal tunnel.
Computing

Change your mouse cursor in Windows with these quick tips

The standard mouse cursor is boring, so change it! With this guide on how to change your mouse cursor in Windows, you can choose to use one of Microsoft's pre-installed cursors or download something a bit more extravagant.
Computing

Heal your wrist aches and pains with one of these top ergonomic mice

If you have a growing ache in your wrist, it might be worth considering changing up your mouse for something ergonomic. But which is the best ergonomic mouse for you? One of these could be the ticket to the right purchase for you.
Gaming

With our Steam guide, you can give the gift of gaming this holiday season

The holidays may have passed, but it's always a good time to give the gift of gaming (especially when there's a Steam sale)! Here's our quick guide on how to give a Steam game as a gift.
Photography

Forget painting-style transfers, this A.I. creates realistic portraits of fake people

Do these images look computer-generated? Nvidia researchers recently published a paper on a new variation on style transfer artificial intelligence that's able to generate entirely new portraits.
Computing

Leaked HP laptop listing reveals entry-level Nvidia MX250 GPU

Alongside powerful graphics cards, Nvidia may have more mobile GPUs to show off at next year's CES show in January. The MX250 has been spotted in a listing for an HP laptop, potentially replacing the entry-level MX150.
Computing

ZSpace’s laptop brings education to life with its own 3D technology

The ZSpace laptop wants to overhaul education and training by offering affordable access to 3D mixed reality through a bespoke screen and glasses technology that is already supported by a wide array of applications.
Computing

Former Microsoft intern claims Google may have sabotaged Edge browser

Google's Chrome web browser has been able to establish such dominance that Microsoft is abandoning its web rendering engine, switching Edge over to Chromium, but did Google play dirty in an attempt to force Microsoft to make the decision?
Computing

ViewSonic’s 1080p gaming monitor lets you experience the action in style

ViewSonic is catering to gamers with its latest monitor, the XG240R. Featuring a 1080p 144Hz panel, RGB lighting, and a fast 1ms response time, you can conquer your opponents and do it in style.
Computing

Here’s why you might still be using Wi-Fi after cellular 5G launches

Cellular 5G might be around the corner and promising to deliver lightning fast speeds, but the folks over at the Wi-Fi Alliance have a few reasons why they think you shouldn't dump Wi-Fi just yet.
Computing

Pinning websites to your taskbar is as easy as following these quick steps

Would you like to know how to pin a website to the taskbar in Windows 10 in order to use browser links like apps? Whichever browser you're using, it's easier than you might think. Here's how to get it done.
Web

Canceling Amazon Prime is easy, and you might get a refund

Don't be intimidated. Learning how to cancel Amazon Prime is easier than you might think. You might even get a partial or full refund on the cost, depending on how much you've used it. Check out our quick-hit guide for doing so.
Computing

Convert your PDFs into convenient Word documents

PDF files are great, but few document types are as malleable as those specific to Microsoft Word. Here's how to convert a PDF file into a Word document, whether you prefer to use Adobe's software suite or a freemium alternative.