Skip to main content

Privacy International Ranks Google Last

Privacy International Ranks Google Last
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Watchdog group Privacy International has conducted an analysis of the privacy policies and practices of 20 leading online businesses, inclusing firms such as Skype, eBay, the BBC, Last.fm, Apple, Microsoft, and MySpace. The results? None of the companies earned green marks for their customer privacy policies or actions, and the organization has ranked online titan Google dead last in terms of its efforts to protect its users’ privacy.

“We are aware that the decision to place Google at the bottom of the ranking is likely to be controversial,” Privacy International wrote in a release, “but throughout our research we have found numerous deficiencies and hostilities in Google’s approach to privacy that go well beyond those of other organizations. While a number of companies share some of these negative elements, none comes close to achieving status as an endemic threat to privacy.”

Recommended Videos

Privacy International assessed organizations’ privacy practices on 20 factors, including openness and transparency, data collection and processing, responsiveness, data retention, customer and user control, privacy enhancing/invading innovations, the fairness of gateways and authentications, the organizations’ ethical compass, administrative organization, and other details. Overall, Google was the only company ranked black, indicating, “comprehensive consumer surveillance and entrenched hostility to privacy,” but several companies were categorized as “substantial and comprehensive privacy threats,” including AOL, Apple, Facebook, Hi5, Reunion.com, Windows Live Space, and Yahoo. Only Wikipedia, LiveJournal, Last.fm, the BBC, and eBay were regarded as “generally privacy-aware,” although none were regarded as “privacy-friendly and enhancing.”

Privacy International cited many factors in its decision to rank Google last, including indefinite retention of customer information, retenion of search strings and query data for 18 to 24 months, tracking Google Toolbar users with unique cookies, and failing to give users ways to expunge records kept about their activities, queries, accounts, or user profiles.

For its part, Google says Privacy International’s conclusions are based on inaccurate assessments and misunderstandings of how its services operate. Privacy International in turn accuses Google of conducting a smear campaign against, and has posted an open letter responding alleged claims by Google that Privacy International reached its conclusions due to a conflict of interest.

The information released by Privacy International thusfar represents a first draft; the group plans to release a more detailed report in September.

Geoff Duncan
Former Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Google’s iconic ‘feeling lucky’ button is under threat from you-know-what
A Google logo sign at the top of a building.

Google’s “I’m Feeling Lucky” button has been a familiar part of its homepage since the launch of the search engine 27 years ago, but the company could be about to ditch it.

The web giant is currently testing with select users how to integrate its AI chatbot into its homepage. One option is to replace the “lucky” button with one that reads “AI Mode." Selecting AI Mode leads to a more conversational interaction regarding your search, eliminating the need to sift through a long list of search results. Google announced the feature earlier this month.

Read more
Can Google’s new AI experiment help me learn a language?
AI translation on Android phone.

I've lived in Germany for around a decade now, and an enduring source of shame for me is my rather underwhelming German language skills. Like many language learners, I've reached the point where I can understand what's said to me, make casual conversation, and handle everyday situations, but I've never really achieved the level of comfort with the language and the breadth of vocabulary that's required for true fluency.

I'd love to improve my language skills, but I've struggled to commit the time and resources for intensive classes. But perhaps there's a solution hiding in plain sight on my phone.

Read more
You can now interact with Google’s AI Mode in search results
Google AI Mode

Google has been working on adding more AI features to its Search feature, and now an integrated AI Mode is being rolled out to the public. Different from the AI Overview function that Google has included as a default part of Search since last year, the AI Mode is a chatbot which users can interact with as part of their search results.

AI Mode has previously only been available as a Google Labs experiment, but now Google says that it will be coming to search for "a small percentage of people" in the U.S. over the coming weeks. Those who are part of the test will see an "AI Mode" tab in Search, and clicking on it will bring up information related to your search from the chatbot.

Read more