Skip to main content

Reports find Firefox faces upgrade lag, security debate

The Mozilla Foundation’s Firefox browser has been facing a bit of a crisis, with the organization’s search deal with Google in limbo — and with it, most of the public foundation’s funding. While Mozilla and Google are reported to still be working on a new version of their search deal, new reports show Firefox is facing new challenges:Many Firefox users are failing to keep up with Mozilla’s rapid release schedule for the browser, and Google may be deliberately trying to undermine Firefox by commissioning security reports that tout Chrome at Firefox’s expense.

First, a new report from advertising analytics firm Chitika finds that while the majority of Firefox users are embracing Mozilla’s new rapid release methodology (which sees a new major version of Firefox every couple months), as many as a quarter of Firefox users are three or more major revisions behind, with nearly 23 percent of Firefox’s user base still using Firefox 3.0 or 3.x. The current version — this week —  is Firefox 8.

Chitika-Firefox-versions-Dec2011
Image used with permission by copyright holder

“While a majority of Firefox users have the current version of the browser, there is a significant portion—at least a quarter—who are at least three releases behind,” wrote Chitika’s Haze Jayachandran. “Firefox’s plans to allow silent updates may help this problem, though they aren’t scheduled to debut until version 12 is released.”

Recommended Videos

A “silent upgrade” feature won’t automatically migrate users of very old versions of Firefox (like Firefox 2 and 3) to new versions—the support simply isn’t in those older versions of the browser, and in some cases Mozilla no longer makes a version of Firefox for the platform. For instance, while Firefox still supports Windows XP, it left PowerPC-based Macs in the dust with Firefox 4.

Chitika also underscores the value of Mozilla’s search deal with Google, finding that nearly 80 percent of Firefox users have Google as their default search engine, as measured across impressions last week.

In the meantime, accusations are flying that Google may be trying to stack the deck against Firefox (and other browsers) by commissioning a report on browser security from Accuvant. Accuvant named Google’s Chrome the browser most secure against attacks. Accuvant’s senior research scientist claimed the test were “completely different and more extensive methodology than previous, similar studies,” and considered anti-exploitation technologies and browsers’ security methodology.

However, at least one other security firm is crying foul: NSS Labs has released its own response to Accuvant’s report (PDF), saying it appears Google may have set the testing parameters to Chrome’s advantage, in part because the test methodology completely ignored some Firefox security technologies such as frame poisoning and particular JIT hardening techniques employed by Firefox.

NSS Labs doesn’t question Accuvant’s expertise or that Chrome is working hard to be secure. In fact, NSS Labs lauds Accuvant’s discussion of JIT hardening and sandboxing tchnologies, and says it found Chrome increased its protection against traditional malware nearly fivefold just from November 22 to December 2. But NSS Labs pulls no punches about why it thinks Chrome won in Accuvant’s testing: “Google paid product reseller Accuvant to publish a report comparing browser security. However, given the deficiencies in the methodology it would appear that the main aim of the report was to undermine confidence in Firefox.”

Of course, NSS Labs is no stranger to commissioned security reports itself: A year ago, NSS Labs was commissioned by Microsoft to test IE9’s anti-malware features…and NSS Labs declared IE9 the most secure browser available.

Geoff Duncan
Former Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Topics
Why even Chrome devotees should give the Arc web browser a shot
The Arc web browser running on macOS Ventura, showing an Easel with live snippets listing temperatures in New York and flights there from London.

Google Chrome is one of the best browsers you can get, and its popularity among internet users is absolutely unrivaled. But there’s a new kid on the block called Arc that aims to steal some of Google’s thunder.

We’ve written about it before, and Arc is an intriguing web browser for a whole host of reasons. But should you ditch Chrome for Arc? That’s what we’re hoping to answer in this guide. Here, we’ve compared the two browsers across a range of metrics, from design and features to performance and security. If you’re not sure which browser is best for you, read on to find out.
Design
Arc features a Split View mode that lets you view multiple tabs side-by-side. Alex Blake / Digital Trends

Read more
The best Firefox extensions to level up your browser
Firefox

Firefox is one of the best browsers you can use, but it gets even better when you start to power it up with a selection of add-ons and extensions. In fact, it has one of the best extension libraries of any browser out there, meaning you’re absolutely spoiled for choice if you want to add new features and abilities to your browser.

Here, we’ve rounded up our picks for the best Firefox extensions that you can use today. Each one brings something different to the table, but they all significantly improve your web-browsing experience.
Productivity
Gesturefy

Read more
The best web browsers for 2024
Lenovo IdeaPad 530S

All web browsers have the same basic function, and yet, the choice between them has always been one of the most contentious in tech history. You have more options these days than ever before, whether you're looking for the best web browser for privacy, the best for speed, or perhaps something a bit more adventurous.

To help you decide on the best web browser, we grabbed the latest browsers and put them through their paces. Even if some could use a complete overhaul, these options are your best chance for a great online experience.
The best web browser: Google Chrome
Google Chrome version 116 Mark Coppock / Digital Trends
Chrome is ubiquitous -- and for good reason. With a robust feature set, full Google Account integration, a thriving extension ecosystem (available through the Chrome Web Store), and a reliable suite of mobile apps, it’s easy to see why Chrome is the most popular and the best web browser.
Chrome boasts some of the most extensive mobile integration available. Served up on every major platform, keeping data in sync is easy, making browsing between multiple devices a breeze. Sign in to your Google account on one device, and all Chrome bookmarks, saved data, and preferences come right along. Even active extensions stay synchronized across devices.
Chrome's Password Manager can automatically generate and recommend strong passwords when a user creates a new account on a webpage. Managing saved passwords and adding notes to passwords is even easier. The search bar, or Omnibox, provides "rich results" comprised of useful answers, and it now supports generative AI capabilities. Favorites are more accessible as well, and they're manageable on the New Tab page. And it's now easier to mute tabs to avoid unwanted sounds.

Read more