For the past three years, online backup provider BackBlaze has been testing the reliability of the hard drives (HDD) it uses to store its customers’ data. With almost 62,000 drives running in its service, sometimes they’re going to fail. And when they do, BackBlaze notes it down, letting the world know which ones have caused it the most problems.
Since the beginning of this documentation, BackBlaze found HGST proved to be the most reliable, regardless of size or brand of drive, while Western Digital and Seagate duked it out for the dubious honor of having the most failed drives. This year, though, things are quite different.
For the first quarter of 2016, the backup provider found that of the 35,000-plus Seagate drives it operates, slightly more than 200 failed, or around 3.5 percent. That’s a huge dropoff from 2015’s near 11 percent failure rate. Clearly, moving to Seagate’s newer 4TB drives has made a big difference in reliability.
Unfortunately for Western Digital, though, the same cannot be said for its latest crop of HDDs. Of the 1,691 in operation at BackBlaze, 6.55 percent failed
That said, none of these results should suggest the drives in use are poor quality or prone to failure. Indeed, they have been subjected to (in some cases) millions of days worth of operation, with intense usage far beyond what you could expect in an average consumer’s system.
The heat, vibrations, and other stress factors that must be considered with any such testing should mean that these results be of only minor consideration when making your own purchases, but they do give us a large sample size to work wit.
As ExtremeTech points out, when it comes to buying drives itself, BackBlaze’s first consideration is cost. Even though HGST is the most reliable drive by its own testing metrics, it still employs more Seagate drives — which is surprising considering they were some of the most unreliable until recently. However, that was mostly due to one particular three terabyte drive, which we are well aware of.
- Best cheap external hard drive deals for October 2021
- The best external hard drives for 2021
- The best Black Friday external hard drive deals for 2021
- How to choose an external hard drive
- The best external hard drives for Xbox Series X