Skip to main content

Human prefer faulty robots to flawless ones — but why?

faulty robots
Image used with permission by copyright holder
People love to watch robots screw up. This week a crowd cheered as a Boston Dynamics humanoid fell off the stage during a presentation. Meanwhile, Simone Giertz has amassed more than 692,000 YouTube subscribers by creating faulty robots that, among other antics, clumsily pour milk and slap her in the face.

It’s understandable how these particular machines can be funny to observers since we don’t actually rely on them to work. But a new study suggests that people really do prefer faulty robots, even when they are intended to be functional.

“From our previous research on social robots, we know that humans show observable reactions when a robot makes an error,” Nicole Mirnig, corresponding author and Ph.D. candidate at the University of Salzburg, told Digital Trends.

To err is human and mistakes make robots feel more human-like.

Mirnig and her team at the Center for Human-Computer Interaction wanted to explore this idea further, to study how and why people react to faulty robots. They intentionally programmed certain robots to screw up while making their counterparts perform actions perfectly.

After analyzing participant reactions and interviewing them about their experience with the robots, the researchers discovered the participants did not consider the faulty robots any less intelligent or relatable than those robots that performed the tasks perfectly. In fact, the participants rated faulty robots as more likable than their flawless counterparts.

It’s not obvious why people would be inclined to like faulty robots. One explanation may be the “Pratfall effect,” which occurs in people when someone’s attractiveness increases after he or she makes a minor mistake. The reasoning here: To err is human and mistakes make robots feel more human-like.

“Research has shown that people form their opinions and expectations about robots to a substantial proportion on what they learn from the media,” Mirnig said. “Those media entail movies in which robots are often portrayed as perfectly functioning entities, good or evil. Upon interacting with a social robot themselves, people adjust their opinions and expectations based on their interaction experience. I assume that interacting with a robot that makes mistakes, makes us feel closer and less inferior to technology.”

For Mirnig and other at the Center for Human-Computer Interaction, the goal is not necessarily to develop robots infallible robots but to develop robots that understand when they made an error.

“If a robot can understand that an error is present, it can actively deploy error recover strategies,” Mirnig said. “We believe that this will result in more likable robots that are better accepted.”

A paper detailing the study was published in the journal Frontiers in Robotics and AI.

Editors' Recommendations

Dyllan Furness
Dyllan Furness is a freelance writer from Florida. He covers strange science and emerging tech for Digital Trends, focusing…
In the future, welding robots could be controlled by operators’ thoughts
welding robot brain computer interface robots

Welding has always been a physical, hands-on job -- but that may be about to change. That’s because researchers from the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign have developed a new mind-control system that makes it possible for someone to control a welding robot by transmitting mental instructions via an electroencephalography (EEG) cap. While robot welders are already used in industry, this innovation could help make the process more efficient, in addition to keeping human workers at a safe distance from the potentially deadly machines they work with.

“Welding is a high-skilled task,” Thenkurussi Kesavadas, professor of Industrial & Enterprise Systems Engineering, told Digital Trends. “A skilled welder can identify the exact joints that require welding based on drawings of the part. But when robots are used to weld, programming requires additional skill set and time. Our research is focused on automating robotic welding by using human knowledge about welding and computer vision to carry out automation.”

Read more
Meet the game-changing pitching robot that can perfectly mimic any human throw
baseball hitter swings and misses

Who’s your favorite baseball pitcher? Shane McClanahan? Sandy Alcantara? Justin Verlander? Whoever you said, two of the top sports-tech companies in the U.S. -- Rapsodo and Trajekt Sports -- have teamed up to build a robot version of them, and the results are reportedly uncannily accurate.

Okay, so we’re not talking about walking-talking-pitching standalone robots, as great a sci-fi-tinged MLB ad as that would be. However, Rapsodo and Trajekt have combined their considerable powers to throw a slew of different technologies at the problem of building a machine that's able to accurately simulate the pitching style of whichever player you want to practice batting against -- and they may just have pulled it off, too.

Read more
The best portable power stations
EcoFlow DELTA 2 on table at campsite for quick charging.

Affordable and efficient portable power is a necessity these days, keeping our electronic devices operational while on the go. But there are literally dozens of options to choose from, making it abundantly difficult to decide which mobile charging solution is best for you. We've sorted through countless portable power options and came up with six of the best portable power stations to keep your smartphones, tablets, laptops, and other gadgets functioning while living off the grid.
The best overall: Jackery Explorer 1000

Jackery has been a mainstay in the portable power market for several years, and today, the company continues to set the standard. With three AC outlets, two USB-A, and two USB-C plugs, you'll have plenty of options for keeping your gadgets charged.

Read more