Skip to main content

Destiny 2’s hot new exotic is another pay-to-win headache

Few things get the Guardians of Destiny 2 excited like hunting for the latest and greatest exotic weapons. Osteo Striga is one such weapon. This unique SMG debuted with Destiny 2: The Witch Queen, but with a problematic caveat: Only players who are willing to pay extra are eligible to acquire the gun at launch.

It’s the latest in a troubling trend of Bungie turning the pay-to-win screws into one of the best fanbases in gaming, and is one of the few black marks in how the developer engages with its community.

Further reading

The problem with Osteo Striga

Crafting the Osteo Striga in Destiny 2.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Osteo Striga is a crafted weapon, part of a new system that has debuted with The Witch Queen. “Eligibleplayers can retrieve a Pattern (aka blueprint) for the gun at any time after completing the new campaign from their triumphs tab, and use it at the Artifact, a device at the center of the crafting mechanic.

So, what makes a player eligible? Spending money. At launch, only players who have purchased the $80 Deluxe Edition of Destiny 2: The Witch Queen can get their hands on Osteo Striga. All other players will need to wait until the weapon joins the general loot pool, at an indeterminate future date.

That means players need to make a choice whether or not to spend additional real-world money in order to unlock a powerful item that can directly impact their success in PVP and PVE activities. A weapon is being held hostage behind a paywall, and gamers can either pay the ransom or risk being on the receiving end of a weapon they themselves cannot wield.

A history of pay to win

The inventory card for Gjallahorn in Destiny 2.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

This isn’t an isolated example of dangling desirable weapons in front of players to coax more real money investment from them. No Time to Explain is an Exotic pulse rifle from Destiny 2: Beyond Light that began as an item reserved for higher-paying customers before being made available to everyone in a later season.

The most egregious example of this pay-walling was Gjallarhorn. This Exotic Rocket Launcher was the most iconic weapon in the first Destiny game. Its return was heavily requested by the community, and Bungie delivered during the studio’s recent 30th Anniversary Event. It should have been a celebration by Guardians franchise-wide.

It’s arguably the most powerful and desirable heavy weapon in the game. Having access to Gjallarhorn is a tangible advantage for players and it’s only available to players willing to pay for premium content. It’s the textbook definition of pay-to-win, even if there are plenty of other powerful, free weapons players can use.

This isn’t just an issue of free-to-play versus paid content. The Witch Queen isn’t free, players have spent the $40 in order to access the new content and experience the next story in the overarching Destiny narrative. Those players have paid, but not enough to earn Osteo Striga. It’s the kind of upsell you’d expect from a door-to-door salesman, not a video game.

No one can reasonably demand a game as vast and complex as Destiny 2 be perfectly balanced across all possible loadouts and weapon permutations. It is perfectly reasonable to offer value to your best-paying customers. But everyone who loads into Destiny, or any online-focused game, should be able to expect the basic courtesy of a level playing field, where spending money doesn’t directly translate into better and more effective equipment. It’s exploitative and erodes so many years of well-earned trust between a developer and the community that supports it.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Justin Koreis
Justin is a freelance writer with a lifelong love of video games and technology. He loves writing about games, especially…
Destiny 2: Lightfall fails to deliver its Avengers: Infinity War moment
A titan wielding a grenade launcher in Destiny 2..

The comparison between Destiny 2: Lightfall and Avengers: Infinity War is immediate from the opening moments of Bungie's latest expansion. There is no more exposition to get through; the Witness, a mythical villain that represents the root of the Darkness that Guardians have fought against for close to a decade, is here, and the Traveler who has given our heroes the Light and their god-like abilities is under direct threat. The stakes couldn't be higher, but Lightfall doesn't live up to that moment.

I'm not drawing connections here that shouldn't be made -- the bombastic opening moments of Lightfall call back Infinity War's unrelenting momentum in its first act. The Traveler is under siege in Lightfall and Guardians are dismantled by a flick of the Witness' wrist, echoing the immediate slaughter brought by the hands of Thanos moments before he arrived on Earth. That feeling is the same; our antagonist is here, and there's nowhere else to run. In the final moments of the campaign, a member of my fireteam even exclaimed, "hey, that's a line from Infinity War."

Read more
Modern Warfare 2’s new season is proof Call of Duty needs to take a year off
Main characters of Modern Warfare 2.

The eagerly anticipated second season of Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 has a lot in store. It'll incorporate a new small-scale Warzone 2.0 battle royale map called Ashika Island, along with new DMZ features and a fresh set of weapons to try out. While Season 2 certainly has lots of exciting new content in the pipeline, things are looking dire for Modern Warfare 2 multiplayer, as very few new features are planned for the update.

Sure, it's nice that Warzone 2.0 and DMZ are getting so much attention during Season 2, but the latest update is a grim sign for the overall life cycle of Modern Warfare 2 -- a game that seems to have been left in the dust as Activision sprints on to its next project,
Modern Warfare 2 road map
So, what exactly is Modern Warfare 2 getting alongside Season 2? On paper, it seems like a sizeable amount. That is, until you break down what's in the works.

Read more
Why the Destiny 2 and Fortnite collab makes perfect sense for Bungie
Destiny 2 skins in Fortnite.

Destiny 2 is collaborating with the Epic Games Store, including swapping some cosmetics with Fortnite and Fall Guys. This announcement leaked ahead of Bungie's Destiny 2 showcase on Tuesday, and the community reaction was mixed. After all, Destiny 2, Fortnite, and Fall Guys aren't similar games at all. But after seeing the collaborations in action, they make perfect sense. Destiny 2has seen a lot of changes over the past year, and although it's still a far cry from Fortnite or Fall Guys, trading cosmetics fits right into where Bungie, Epic Games, and Sony are heading.

Destiny 2 on Epic Games Store - Fortnite + Fall Guys Crossover Trailer
A tale of two games
The new skins come on the heels of Destiny 2 launching on the Epic Games Store, where Bungie is offering its 30th Anniversary content pack for free for the first week. Bungie says the collaboration is a celebration of the new launch, with three new skins each in Fortnite, Destiny 2, and on September 13, Fall Guys. Nothing is changing with any of these games; they're just adding new cosmetics. Still, the community isn't taking it that way. The friction with the Fortnite and Destiny 2 collaboration centers around how different the games are. The only common thread they share is that they're both multiplayer shooters, but even then, the games are so different in style and structure that they can't be compared.

Read more