Skip to main content

Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Why trust us?

The new HomePod is still too expensive, which is exactly how Apple wants it

Apple just announced its second-generation HomePod. And it did so without too much fanfare, via press release and just a day after it unveiled new M2 processors inside new a MacBook Pro and Mac mini. And while there maybe wasn’t much fanfare, there was plenty of flourish — also in typical Apple fashion — without divulging all that many details about what’s new.

Apple HomePod 2023 model.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

There’s the lower price, of course, with $50 shaved off the first-gen HomePod price. The internals have been reworked some, though whether that’s to lower the overall cost, or just to make things better, remains to be seen. But It’s got a new S7 processor instead of the older (and less purpose-driven) A8. It’s got support for the Matter smart home standard and can listen for things like carbon monoxide alarms. And it’ll still play music and do other smart home stuff.

Recommended Videos

It’s also too expensive for most folks at $300. The catch is that the price probably doesn’t matter if you’re the sort who will be purchasing a new HomePod.

The new HomePod is a little less expensive, but still a smart speaker for the upper crust.

Consider, for a minute, the biggest competitors to the HomePod which, to be clear, is a premium smart speaker. This isn’t some $50 throwaway music maker. Amazon’s Echo Studio costs $200. A Sonos One is $219. Google’s awkwardly named Nest Audio isn’t quite in the same ballpark, but it’s $100, just for comparison’s sake. Or you could get Roku’s wireless speakers and wireless subwoofer for less than a single HomePod — and still have enough left over for lunch.

Does the new (or old, for that matter) HomePod do that much more than any one of those speakers? They all connect to the internet and do internet things, from music to smart home. (OK, Roku is really about home theater and not smart so much smart home.) They can all be paired with other speakers for whole-home audio, or (for Amazon and Sonos, anyway) paired with your television for audio.

Apple HomePod 2023 internals.
Meet the new HomePod — slightly less expensive, but still priced at a premium. Image used with permission by copyright holder

No, as is the case with Apple’s other products, you’re not just paying $300 for a smart speaker. You’re paying $300 for an Apple smart speaker. One (and again, just a single, standalone speaker) that ties into the larger Apple ecosystem in ways no competing speaker can do, from setup to everyday use. Put your iPhone next to the new HomePod and it’ll suggest things you can play. You can use the Find My feature on the speaker to find missing devices around your home. (Hopefully not too often.)

Give HomePod the benefit of the doubt and presume that it’ll have superior audio. But is it $100 better? For a single speaker? Maybe it is. Maybe your standards of what’s “better” just aren’t worth that much more money. Maybe you care less about Apple’s privacy and environmental lines and just want something that works well enough, if not as close to perfect as can be.

It’s the totality of the product that lets Apple charge that much more than its competitors. Also just the company’s sheer size — it can afford to sell fewer of these things, though even that doesn’t make it immune from being deemed less than a success, as was the case with the original HomePod.

Will this new model suffer the same fate? Good — great, even — though at a price that simply was too high for the market to bear?

We’ll start to see after February 3, when the second-generation HomePod is released.

Phil Nickinson
Former Section Editor, Audio/Video
Phil spent the 2000s making newspapers with the Pensacola (Fla.) News Journal, the 2010s with Android Central and then the…
How the Apple TV and AirPods Max solved my TV headphone woes
The AirPods Max and Apple TV 4K with remote on a table.

What began with an old pair of Bluetooth headphones to watch late-night TV movies became an all-consuming quest to get great-sounding wireless audio and a reliable connection from my television. It really shouldn’t have been complicated, but it turned out to be far harder than I could have ever imagined. And I’ve spent months and months -- and a whole lot of money -- solving the problem.

This is how I did it.
How it all started
Toward the end of 2021, I began watching TV late into the night, and I didn't want to be “that neighbor” when doing it. So I grabbed a pair of Bluetooth headphones and connected them to my TV. I didn’t think much of it at the time. It’s a modestly sized room so I didn’t expect range to be an issue. It’s a modern television, and the headphones sound very good connected to my phone. I thought it was problem solved right then and there.

Read more
No new AirPods Pro (yet) as Apple event births new Mac
AirPods Pro in a Nomad case.

Another Apple event has come and gone. It was exciting. It was magical. It invented all sorts of things that we've never seen before until Apple invented them just now. (That's sarcasm, folks.) It brought a new iPad Air, a new Mac Studio, and Studio Display, powered by even more powerful hardware that's better and faster and stronger and more beautiful than what came before.

Because that's how all this works.

Read more
Apple AirPods patent shows how they could track activity
New Apple AirPods 3 - Spatial Audio - Long Battery

Your smartwatch may not be enough to monitor your exercise routines, especially when you're working out with an Apple Fitness+ trainer. Apple has revealed a patent that explains how AirPods models could be used to track a user's physical activity.

Dubbed the "Wireless Ear Bud System With Pose Detection," the patent, which came to light on February 17 courtesy of Apple Insider, proposed that the AirPods "may have sensors to gather orientation information such as accelerometer measurements during user movements. A host electronic device may communicate wirelessly with the ear buds and may form part of an ear bud system that supplies the user with coaching and feedback while evaluating user performance of a head movement routine or other exercise routine."

Read more