Skip to main content

Guests are accusing Airbnb of deleting negative reviews

Airbnb is facing scrutiny as guests are accusing the company of removing negative reviews and boosting subpar hosts and their properties.

Donna Oakley, an Airbnb guest who stayed at a two-bedroom condominium in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, told Quartz that the home she arrived in looked completely inferior to the photos of the five-star property she booked. According to Oakley, the rooms were dirty, the kitchen cabinets had mold, and the vents were clogged with dust and dirt. Oakley also encountered difficulties with parking, when a neighbor parked in the Airbnb property’s designated spot, then threatened Oakley when she asked the neighbor to move the car.

“We felt it was necessary to move our car somewhere else … and this was not a safe environment due to the threat of violence,” Oakley wrote in a review of the property on the Airbnb website. “The condo is in need of a significant cleaning. It appears to have been neglected.”

Airbnb’s review policy gives hosts and guests 14 days to write a review of the experience after the guest has checked out, and reviews will only show up under the property when both parties have completed a review, or once the 14-day period is over — whichever happens first. While Oakley’s entire review was two paragraphs, Airbnb cut most of it and left her review with just one sentence: “Please be aware that this property is unclean and the neighbors are rude and threatened violence in reference to a parking space (which is extremely limited).”

In addition to Oakley, four other Airbnb users told Quartz similar stories about Airbnb allegedly deleting or editing their reviews without permission. Airbnb, however, is standing firm that its content policy makes it clear when and why a review might be removed. Nick Papas, a spokesperson for the company, said in an emailed statement, “The goal of this policy is to ensure that any fraudulent or misleading content is not allowed on the site. Just as critical, this policy also exists to protect the integrity of authentic feedback from our community.”

Airbnb is far from the only company to encounter difficulties with online reviews. The New York Times reports travel website TripAdvisor continuously deleted reviews by a woman who wrote that she was raped by a security guard at a resort in Mexico; the company later apologized.

Editors' Recommendations

Gia Liu
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Airbnb boosts search features ahead of expected travel rebound
Airbnb on a smartphone.

With coronavirus vaccination programs allowing travel to open up in some parts of the world, Airbnb is rolling out a bunch of handy new features to help improve the search experience on its website and app.

The web-based accommodation and travel service said flexibility is central to the changes, which introduce three new ways to perform searches using its online tools.

Read more
Airbnb boss reveals where he’ll go first when we can travel again
Airbnb app

No surprises, it’s been a rough 12 months for Airbnb.

As the COVID-19 pandemic took hold last year, the vacation rental company and its millions of hosts saw bookings plummet globally, leaving it with little choice but to try to ride out the storm.

Read more
Airbnb blunder leads to vanishing accounts and deleted bookings
Airbnb app

A number of Airbnb users had their accounts temporarily deactivated on Wednesday, November 11, after the company suffered a mishap while carrying out routine maintenance on its computer systems.

Affected accounts have now been restored, but some customers have since discovered that their bookings have disappeared. Worse still, when they went to rebook, some found that another traveler had already jumped in and reserved their previously booked accommodation.

Read more