Skip to main content

And now, here’s a second lawsuit against book publishers over e-books

kindleLast month, the “big six” book publishers – Hachette, Holtzbrinck, Penguin, Harper Collins, Random House, and Simon & Shuster – managed to extricate themselves from a lawsuit over allegations of conspiring with Apple to price fix its eBook releases. Now, they’ve found themselves faced by another lawsuit over the possibility that their digital practices broke anti-trust laws. This time, the lawsuit may end up changing the eBook market in unexpected ways.

The New York Times has a report about a lawsuit filed at the end of last week in Federal District Court for the Southern District of New York by three small bookstores claiming that they were being forced out of the digital market by an agreement between the large publishers and, ironically, Amazon – the company that the earlier anti-trust-breaching agreement was reportedly designed to hurt. The complaint argues that the existing agreements between the publishers and Amazon – agreements that will have to be replaced as a result of the publishers’ settlements with the Department of Justice – “unreasonably restrain trade and commerce in the market of e-books sold within the United States.”

Recommended Videos

According to the Times report, the lawsuit’s argument revolves around the somewhat nebulous idea that the publishers in question have all entered into a secret agreement with Amazon that requires them to code their eBooks in a way that make them only readable on Kindles or devices with Kindle apps. The method, the small stores argue, unfairly trains the eBook audience to conflate digital publishing with Amazon and the Kindle specifically. While this is clearly true for Kindle editions of the digital releases, it’s blatantly untrue of, say, Apple iBooks editions of the same titles or other digital editions, which makes the complaint somewhat confusing.

The lawsuit argues that the publishers should instead offer their eBooks with open-source coding that makes them readable on any device using any software, pointing to Apple eventually moving to offer music free of Digital Rights Management-software after a series of legal challenges. That comparison feels false, however; surely the more appropriate Apple analogy would be the fact that it offers iTunes downloads as mp4 files locked to Apple devices instead of mp3s playable on other devices. The legal action seeks an immediate injunction to the practice, as well as damages resulting from the estimated lost sales it may have induced.

Presuming that this lawsuit isn’t immediately dismissed by the court, especially in light of the new agreements required by the DOJ settlements each of the publishers have agreed to, it’ll be interesting to see what effect this will have on eBooks and the digital market on the whole. The aim is clearly to open the market up to more retailers, but it’s not unimaginable that a legal order to remove DRM from eBooks may change publishers’ attitudes towards the format for fear of accidentally facilitating piracy with every new release.

The three booksellers behind the suit – Posman Books, the Book House of Stuyvesant Plaza, and Fiction Addiction – report that the lawsuit is a class action filed on behalf of other independent booksellers in addition to themselves. In response to the lawsuit, Amazon says, as matter of company policy, it will not comment on ongoing litigation.

Graeme McMillan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
A transplant from the west coast of Scotland to the west coast of America, Graeme is a freelance writer with a taste for pop…
This smart display alternative just added a powerful new feature to help track your chores
A person using the Skylight.

Skylight is responsible for a variety of smart display alternatives with a focus on organization and schedule planning. Last summer, it launched the premium Cal Max -- a 27-inch smart calendar that we called a “streamlined smart display alternative.” Since its arrival, Skylight has continued to roll out new features to the device, and now you’ll find a powerful feature called Routines available across the Skylight Calendar lineup. Designed to simplify chores and build good habits for the entire family, it’s a unique new feature that changes how you interact with the display.

The idea behind Routines is simple -- offer visual feedback and an easy-to-use interface to make it easier than ever to keep track of (and complete) all your chores. These can be set up on a recurring schedule, allowing you to program in everything from a quick 15 minutes of reading before bedtime or a few minutes each morning for your kids to brush their teeth. Routines can be customized with various emojis and color-coding to help keep track of them, and a fun confetti animation is triggered once they’re complete.

Read more
Yale Assure Lock 2 vs. Lockly Vision Elite: which is the better smart lock?
A person opening the Yale Assure Lock 2 with their Apple Watch.

The Yale Assure Lock 2 and Lockly Vision Elite are among the best smart locks on the market. One offers a streamlined design and multiple formats, while the other is packed with features that make it an all-in-one powerhouse. Rest assured -- you can’t go wrong choosing either product. But there are some big differences between the two, and one is likely a better fit for your preferences than the other.

With that in mind, here’s a closer look at the Yale Assure Lock 2 vs. Lockly Vision Elite. From pricing and design to installation and notable features, we’ll cover everything you need to know before making a purchase.

Read more
Unlock $618 savings on the Beatbot AquaSense 2 Ultra
Couple relaxing while robot pool cleaner works

Owning a pool is fantastic, but maintaining it? Not so much. Between random yard debris, birds using it as a bath, and whatever mystery gunk floats on top after a storm, it’s a lot. That’s where Beatbot’s AquaSense 2 Ultra steps in and right now, it’s stepping in with a hefty $618 discount.
From April 14 through April 27 you can snag the world’s first AI-powered 5-in-1 robotic pool cleaner or their Amazon store. That’s not a typo, that’s next-level pool tech at a next-level price.
Why the AquaSense 2 Ultra isn’t just another robot in the pool
This isn’t your average robotic cleaner that aimlessly bounces around like a cheap robot vacuum with no sense of direction. The AquaSense 2 Ultra is smarter. Like "I’ve-got-this-go-enjoy-your-margarita" smart.

Powered by cutting-edge AI and precision path-planning, it cleans your pool like a seasoned pro:

Read more