Skip to main content

And now, here’s a second lawsuit against book publishers over e-books

kindleLast month, the “big six” book publishers – Hachette, Holtzbrinck, Penguin, Harper Collins, Random House, and Simon & Shuster – managed to extricate themselves from a lawsuit over allegations of conspiring with Apple to price fix its eBook releases. Now, they’ve found themselves faced by another lawsuit over the possibility that their digital practices broke anti-trust laws. This time, the lawsuit may end up changing the eBook market in unexpected ways.

The New York Times has a report about a lawsuit filed at the end of last week in Federal District Court for the Southern District of New York by three small bookstores claiming that they were being forced out of the digital market by an agreement between the large publishers and, ironically, Amazon – the company that the earlier anti-trust-breaching agreement was reportedly designed to hurt. The complaint argues that the existing agreements between the publishers and Amazon – agreements that will have to be replaced as a result of the publishers’ settlements with the Department of Justice – “unreasonably restrain trade and commerce in the market of e-books sold within the United States.”

Related Videos

According to the Times report, the lawsuit’s argument revolves around the somewhat nebulous idea that the publishers in question have all entered into a secret agreement with Amazon that requires them to code their eBooks in a way that make them only readable on Kindles or devices with Kindle apps. The method, the small stores argue, unfairly trains the eBook audience to conflate digital publishing with Amazon and the Kindle specifically. While this is clearly true for Kindle editions of the digital releases, it’s blatantly untrue of, say, Apple iBooks editions of the same titles or other digital editions, which makes the complaint somewhat confusing.

The lawsuit argues that the publishers should instead offer their eBooks with open-source coding that makes them readable on any device using any software, pointing to Apple eventually moving to offer music free of Digital Rights Management-software after a series of legal challenges. That comparison feels false, however; surely the more appropriate Apple analogy would be the fact that it offers iTunes downloads as mp4 files locked to Apple devices instead of mp3s playable on other devices. The legal action seeks an immediate injunction to the practice, as well as damages resulting from the estimated lost sales it may have induced.

Presuming that this lawsuit isn’t immediately dismissed by the court, especially in light of the new agreements required by the DOJ settlements each of the publishers have agreed to, it’ll be interesting to see what effect this will have on eBooks and the digital market on the whole. The aim is clearly to open the market up to more retailers, but it’s not unimaginable that a legal order to remove DRM from eBooks may change publishers’ attitudes towards the format for fear of accidentally facilitating piracy with every new release.

The three booksellers behind the suit – Posman Books, the Book House of Stuyvesant Plaza, and Fiction Addiction – report that the lawsuit is a class action filed on behalf of other independent booksellers in addition to themselves. In response to the lawsuit, Amazon says, as matter of company policy, it will not comment on ongoing litigation.

Editors' Recommendations

IFTTT routines for fall
Best IFTT Recipes

For those who want more from our smart home gadgets, it can be frustrating when brand-based apps don’t do as much as you need them to or when certain smart home devices don’t talk to other smart home gadgets. IFTTT solves a lot of those issues by creating pathways for communications between disparate brands, ecosystems, and gadgets. If you’re not familiar with IFTTT, or If This Then That, it’s worth getting to know this tech platform, because it can make your life a lot easier, particularly as we start the slow slide to fall and winter.

As days get shorter, and schedules get busier, now is a great time of year to put automation to work for you in a smart, productive way. IFTTT uses Applets which are like tech recipes to create triggers and results for your devices. The good news is IFTTT works with almost every tech brand. Here are a few of our favorite IFTTT Applets for the fall season.
Automate your morning coffee
When your alarm begins to go off before the sun peeks over the horizon, it can be tough to start the day. Imagine what your world would be like if you could have your coffee brewed and ready for you before you get out of bed. Even if you don’t have a smart coffee maker, you can create a smart coffee experience with some gadgetry and IFTTT.

Read more
How to update Alexa
A man uses the Xiaomi S1's Amazon Alexa capabilities.

From talking about the weather to answering questions about the latest celebrities, Alexa is one useful voice assistant – and even more so if you connect compatible smart devices around your home or try out some more complex skills for playing games or music. But like all software, Alexa needs occasional updates to help make the voice assistant more efficient, fix bugs, make it easier to understand commands, and add new capabilities.

Read more
How to delete or hide apps on an Apple TV
Apple TV Settings App.

Apple prides itself on clean interfaces in its operating systems with quick and easy navigation to your apps, and the latest versions of tvOS for the Apple TV are no exception. But over time, as you add new apps like streaming services, games, music apps, and more, this interface can get crowded and cluttered, especially if you have to navigate through apps that you don’t really use. When you once whipped through your apps with instinctive ease, you now have a hard time finding even Netflix.

If old or un-used apps are clogging up your Apple TV experience, there are ways to clean up the clutter. Here we're going to show you how to delete or hide apps on an Apple TV.

Read more