Do you really want Alexa buying your socks? Why voice assistants suck at shopping

Amazon Echo Alexa
Greg Mombert/Digital Trends
“Hey Siri, find me Black Friday deals on televisions under $500 that support….ahh, forget it. I’ll do it myself.”

According to new research from the Consumer Technology Association, the trade group behind the enormous CES electronics show, one in five U.S. shoppers (19 percent!) will use a smart assistant like Amazon Echo or Google Home to purchase holiday gifts. That’s a huge number — but dig into the stats a bit and the claim sounds as hollow as a digital assistant’s soul.

One in five U.S. shoppers will use a smart assistant like Amazon Echo or Google Home to purchase holiday gifts.

Consider other CTA research, for example, which reveals that only 15 percent of adults in the U.S. currently own a smart speaker. How could one in five shop with a product that only one in seven or so own?

“The ‘one in five’ statistic came from self-reported consumer data,” a spokeswoman told Digital Trends. “Since this is self-reported, there could be a few reasons why this is high such as consumers considering many different ‘voice-enabled’ products (such as asking their smartphone) rather than specific devices like Alexa or Google Home.”

That makes a little more sense: Cortana, Siri, Google Now, and Bixby wound their way deep into our daily lives in a short period of time, and it stands to reason that they’d do everything for us.

But wait: Does it really make sense? Is shopping really the best use for a digital assistant? With products, you want to compare user reviews or expert reviews, look at a gadget, or even hold it in your hands. You want to push a button to see what it does or slide your finger on a surface to see if it leaves a fingerprint.

smart assistant

There are some things we don’t need to try before we buy, such as diapers, paper towels, and orange juice. Amazon’s Dash Buttons are a neat answer to that problem, and yes, you can also buy these home essentials by simply asking Alexa or Google Assistant to place an order.

Even with these products, there are limitations to shopping, of course. You have no control over price, for example: are paper towels on sale? Does the Dash Button care?

“Has Siri really helped you shop, or merely facilitated navigation?”

To address that, shoppers might say to their assistant, “Hey Siri, show me Black Friday deals on TVs,” and then turn to the browser and their fingers to do the actual shopping. In this scenario, has Siri really helped you shop, or merely facilitated navigation? So what are people actually using their smart speakers and virtual assistants for these days? Good question.

According to a recent Business Insider story, the most popular uses for smart assistants have next to nothing to do with shopping. The most popular use is general questions (“How tall is the Empire State Building?”), followed by weather, streaming music, setting alarms and reminders, home automation, and so on. According to the ComScore report in which BI’s chart is based, shopping doesn’t crack the top 10.

smart assistant shopping black friday usage business insider

This makes sense: Despite the stereotype of the executive asking his assistant to “pick up a birthday gift for my wife,” in real life that’s not what assistants do. They schedule meetings, remind people to do things, set up conference rooms, and yes, sometimes run a few errands. They help us be more efficient — but they don’t blindly purchase products for us.

That may be changing, of course. As smart speakers and smart assistants pervade our lives, we’ll lean on them for more everyday tasks. And shopping may be one of those things, even big ticket items and hunting down deals. We’ll see what this year’s shopping season yields. Meanwhile, I’ve gotta run: Google Assistant just told me I’m out of paper towels.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.

Product Review

Chris is the virtual co-pilot phone-obsessives need in their car

Driving while using your phone is dangerous, and often illegal. Meet Chris, the digital assistant for your car that wants to help keep your hands off your phone, and your eyes on the road.

Wring the most out of iOS with the best Siri commands

You may not know all the things you can say to Siri -- after all, Apple never released an official list of commands for its virtual assistant. Thankfully, we've compiled a list of the best Siri commands to help you out.
Smart Home

The best smart locks to increase your home security in 2019

A good smart lock should offer a combination of security and convenience. Fortunately, these devices keep your home protected, your family safe, and your belongings secure from possible intruders.

Protect yourself and your ride with our favorite dash cams

Dashboard cameras can assist drivers in car accident claims, settle speeding ticket disputes, and even catch glimpses of incoming meteors, among other things. Here, we've compiled a list of the most noteworthy offerings available.

Amazon shaves $50 off the Coway Mighty air purifier ahead of allergy season

When it's allergy season, a good air purifier is a must-have for sufferers. The Coway Mighty air purifier (now on sale from Amazon) is one of the best, greatly improving the air quality inside your home by removing dust, dander, pollen, and…
Smart Home

Dyson’s newest products strive to keep your home cool, clean, and well-lit

Dyson launched products to keep your home cool, clean, and well-lit. A Dyson intelligent task light cycles with nature and a personal air purifier harnesses unique airflow. Microprocessors in Dyson's vacuum self-adjust 8,000 times a second.
Smart Home

Walmart serves up a rare deal on the Google Home Max at $100 off

Some deals are predictable and others are pre-announced, but today Walmart posted a rare deal: $100 off the powerful Google Home Max. Since it rarely goes on sale, waiting may not be prudent. If you want one, grab it.
Smart Home

Smart light switches have become more affordable: Here are the best ones

The ability to control the lighting in your home can have a big effect on your living space. To have more control over your lighting, check out the best smart light switches on the market. 
Smart Home

Update your kitchen with the best refrigerators you can buy in 2019

There are tons of factors that go into buying a fridge, from size and capacity to color. It takes lots of testing and research, but we've chosen the best refrigerators to get you started, regardless of what you're looking for.

Suck up the savings with these vacuum cleaners on sale for $100 or less

Keeping your floors clean around the home is a constant chore. To help make things a whole lot easier, we've picked out some great vacuum cleaner deals available right now, from full-sized upright models to robot vacs.
Smart Home

Is your coffee maker hiding mold inside? Here's how to clean it

Are you a coffee drinker? If you brew your coffee at home and you don't clean your machine, you could be drinking mold, yeast, and other bacteria. Here's how to clean your coffee maker.

Walmart drops prices on Google Home Hub and Lenovo smart displays

Walmart slashed the prices of Google Home smart displays for two highly regarded Lenovo models and the original Google Home Hub. We can't think of a better way to improve your smart home setup and these deals can help you save up to $100.

Amazon lowers Echo Dot cost and slashes price of the Dot and Smart Plug bundle

Amazon just unleashed extraordinary price cuts on third-generation Echo Dot smart speakers. The Alexa device is back in stock following the blowout sales last holiday season. The Echo Dot is the best-selling Alexa smart speaker worldwide.
Smart Home

These best outdoor security cameras will keep porch pirates at bay

Worried about porch pirates stealing your packages, or intruders entering your home? Always be in the know about who or what is on your property by installing one of these outdoor security cameras.