Skip to main content

Do you really want Alexa buying your socks? Why voice assistants suck at shopping

Amazon Echo Alexa
Greg Mombert/Digital Trends
“Hey Siri, find me Black Friday deals on televisions under $500 that support….ahh, forget it. I’ll do it myself.”

According to new research from the Consumer Technology Association, the trade group behind the enormous CES electronics show, one in five U.S. shoppers (19 percent!) will use a smart assistant like Amazon Echo or Google Home to purchase holiday gifts. That’s a huge number — but dig into the stats a bit and the claim sounds as hollow as a digital assistant’s soul.

One in five U.S. shoppers will use a smart assistant like Amazon Echo or Google Home to purchase holiday gifts.

Consider other CTA research, for example, which reveals that only 15 percent of adults in the U.S. currently own a smart speaker. How could one in five shop with a product that only one in seven or so own?

“The ‘one in five’ statistic came from self-reported consumer data,” a spokeswoman told Digital Trends. “Since this is self-reported, there could be a few reasons why this is high such as consumers considering many different ‘voice-enabled’ products (such as asking their smartphone) rather than specific devices like Alexa or Google Home.”

That makes a little more sense: Cortana, Siri, Google Now, and Bixby wound their way deep into our daily lives in a short period of time, and it stands to reason that they’d do everything for us.

But wait: Does it really make sense? Is shopping really the best use for a digital assistant? With products, you want to compare user reviews or expert reviews, look at a gadget, or even hold it in your hands. You want to push a button to see what it does or slide your finger on a surface to see if it leaves a fingerprint.

smart assistant
Image used with permission by copyright holder

There are some things we don’t need to try before we buy, such as diapers, paper towels, and orange juice. Amazon’s Dash Buttons are a neat answer to that problem, and yes, you can also buy these home essentials by simply asking Alexa or Google Assistant to place an order.

Even with these products, there are limitations to shopping, of course. You have no control over price, for example: are paper towels on sale? Does the Dash Button care?

“Has Siri really helped you shop, or merely facilitated navigation?”

To address that, shoppers might say to their assistant, “Hey Siri, show me Black Friday deals on TVs,” and then turn to the browser and their fingers to do the actual shopping. In this scenario, has Siri really helped you shop, or merely facilitated navigation? So what are people actually using their smart speakers and virtual assistants for these days? Good question.

According to a recent Business Insider story, the most popular uses for smart assistants have next to nothing to do with shopping. The most popular use is general questions (“How tall is the Empire State Building?”), followed by weather, streaming music, setting alarms and reminders, home automation, and so on. According to the ComScore report in which BI’s chart is based, shopping doesn’t crack the top 10.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

This makes sense: Despite the stereotype of the executive asking his assistant to “pick up a birthday gift for my wife,” in real life that’s not what assistants do. They schedule meetings, remind people to do things, set up conference rooms, and yes, sometimes run a few errands. They help us be more efficient — but they don’t blindly purchase products for us.

That may be changing, of course. As smart speakers and smart assistants pervade our lives, we’ll lean on them for more everyday tasks. And shopping may be one of those things, even big ticket items and hunting down deals. We’ll see what this year’s shopping season yields. Meanwhile, I’ve gotta run: Google Assistant just told me I’m out of paper towels.

Editors' Recommendations

Jeremy Kaplan
As Editor in Chief, Jeremy Kaplan transformed Digital Trends from a niche publisher into one of the fastest growing…
Google has three new Nest Cams, but there’s really only one you should buy
A hand adjusting the Google Nest Cam (battery).

If you didn’t know yet, Google announced a trio of new security cameras in its Nest Cam lineup. The upgrades were long in the making given that the original Google Nest Cam was released in 2015, followed by the outdoor variant in 2016 and subsequently two cameras in the Nest Cam IQ series -- the Nest Cam IQ Indoor and Outdoor in 2017. The toughest part about Google’s new Nest Cams is that they’re all similarly named, but they essentially break down to a battery-powered model, another with a floodlight, and an indoor cam that requires a wire for power.

While the indoor model is Google’s lowest-priced security camera ever with a $100 sticker price, I would actually vouch for choosing the battery-powered model instead. It’s without question the most versatile of the bunch. Here’s why.
Double duty security, inside and out
Google Nest Cam (Battery) Image used with permission by copyright holder

Read more
7 things you didn’t know your home security system could do
SimpliSafe bast station sitting on a table infant of a mirror.

Your home security system is the main line of defense against burglars and unwanted visitors. It can provide peace of mind when you're away, but there are a lot of things your security system can do that you might not be aware of. For example, rather than just catching suspicious activity, it also lets you record your pets being silly for video clips worthy of America's Funniest Videos.

With the right setup, your home security system can extend its functionality far beyond the basics. Here are seven things you didn't know your home security system could do.
Connect to your smart home to disarm the system and turn on the lights
When you come inside, your first step is typically to turn on the lights and/or disarm your security system. You can actually disable your security system with the right key code and connect it to your smart lights so they automatically turn on when you enter the code. You can also connect it to other smart devices like a smart plug to turn on other devices.

Read more
7 things you didn’t know your Google Nest Hub smart display could do
The Google Nest Hub on a table.

Google's line of Nest Hub smart displays can work as a digital photo frame, give customized greetings based on the time of day, and even stream YouTube videos to give your office a bit of background noise. It shows us exactly how effective smart displays are in various aspects of our lives.

That's not all the Nest Hub can do, though. It's also packed with features that a lot of people don't know about, but which can greatly improve your overall experience with the platform. Some are pretty straightforward, like home access control to your connected devices and video calling, but there is some other stuff most people don't realize they can do with it.

Read more