Apple sued to the tune of $2.8 billion over alleged patent infringements

By Williams Pelegrin May 11, 2016

apple imessage facetime patent infringement

Just over a month after Apple started its lawsuit fight in a French court, the Cupertino-based company finds itself in the midst of another lawsuit, brought forth by VoIP-Pal (VPLM) to the tune of $2.8 billion.

According to the Bellevue-based company, which holds patents on numerous VoIP and related technologies, Apple’s iMessage and FaceTime services violate several of its patents.

“Apple employs VPLM’s innovative technology and products, features, and designs, and has widely distributed infringing products that have undermined VPLM’s marketing efforts,” the complaint reads. One such alleged infringement is the messaging system that Apple employs with iMessage, which VoIP-Pal claims violates its patent that deals with the classification of a user and the manner in which the call is routed.

VoIP-Pal originally initiated its lawsuit against Apple back in February in a U.S. District Court in Las Vegas, Nevada, but delayed the lawsuit until May, since it wants to reach an “amicable resolution” with Apple. “We are confident the current good will on both sides will result in a favorable outcome for all parties involved,” said VoIP-Pal CEO Emil Malak.

The company has been accused of being a “patent troll,” since it does not generate income and, as a direct result, has practically worthless stock. However, VoIP-Pal fought back such allegations, arguing that Digifonica, which was acquired by the former back in 2013, started design on its system in 2004.

This lawsuit comes at an awkward time for Apple, which recently saw its first year-over-year revenue decline in 13 years during the company’s second fiscal quarter. The blame for the decline seems to be on lower iPhone sales, though Apple did note it saw the greatest number of people switching from other companies’ devices to the iPhone during the quarter. Apple is slated to report on its third quarter earnings sometime in June.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics

Williams Pelegrin

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Williams is an avid New York Yankees fan, speaks Spanish, resides in Colorado, and has an affinity for Frosted Flakes. Send…

Smart Home

Samsung Memorial Day Sale: Appliances, TVs, phones, and more

Samsung Frame in a kitchen.

There aren't many Memorial Day sales that can boast huge phone deals alongside refrigerator deals, but that's the beauty of Samsung. The Korean company is an expert at developing so many much-needed appliances as well as fun but practical tech too. Its Memorial Day sale reflects that with so much to check out that it's almost overwhelming. You're likely to know what you need most, so we recommend hitting the link below to see what's out there within the sale. However, if you still need a little more guidance, we're here to point out a few highlights too.

What to shop in the Samsung Memorial Day sale
We all know that Samsung makes some of the best TVs and one of its highlights is the Samsung The Frame TV. Incredibly stylish, the TV works like a picture frame so you simply hang it on your wall and it displays art any time you're not watching TV. It's also a fantastic QLED TV in its own right so you get exceptional picture quality the whole time. At Samsung, you can save $100 off the 55-inch model or a massive $800 off the equally massive 85-inch model.

Mobile

Huge discounts arrive on Garmin smartwatches for Memorial Day

The Garmin Instinct 2X Solar on a person's wrist.

Best Buy is currently offering discounts for a range of smartwatches by Garmin, a brand that's grown in popularity among athletes and fitness enthusiasts because of the accuracy and durability of its products. Garmin devices almost always quickly sell out when ever they're involved in smartwatch deals, and we don't expect this to be any different. It won't take up too much time to browse through the 30 Garmin smartwatches that the retailer is selling for cheaper than usual -- choose what you want to buy and proceed with the purchase immediately, before the bargain ends.

What to buy in Best Buy's Garmin smartwatches sale
If you only need a basic fitness-focused smartwatch, you can't go wrong with the . It's the cheapest option in Best Buy's sale at just $120, after an $80 discount on its original price of $200, but it still packs quite a lot of features, including the ability to track your heart rate, sleep, and stress levels. It also offers an always-on mode that's often seen in high-end smartwatches, and it can last up to six days on a single charge when GPS is not activated. Meanwhile, outdoor lovers will want to take a look at the , which is in our list of the best Garmin watches as the best rugged Garmin watch. It's protected by a fiber-reinforced polymer case with a water-resistant design, with a battery life of up to 14 days, and it's available for just $180 for savings of $50 on its sticker price of $230.

Mobile

The Pixel Watch has been utterly crushed by its latest rival

A Pixel Watch and TicWatch Pro 5 side-by-side.

After using the Mobvoi TicWatch Pro 5 for the last two weeks and being seriously impressed by it, I wondered what it would be like to return to the Google Pixel Watch — a smartwatch I wasn’t so taken with.

A few days with the Pixel Watch reminded me why it was a disappointment. Make no mistake: If you’ve got $350 to spend on an Android smartwatch, there’s only one model that should be on your list.
A step back in performance