Skip to main content

Apple’s iCloud encryption update hasn’t pleased everyone

Apple’s announcement this week that it’s boosting security for some iCloud data hasn’t pleased everyone.

Advanced Data Protection for iCloud began rolling out to users on Thursday as an opt-in feature. It offers end-to-end encryption for iCloud backups, Photos, and Notes, though at this stage it doesn’t include iCloud Mail, Contacts, and Calendar.

The new layer of security is a step up from the current on-device encryption as it prevents any kind of access by Apple — for example in response to requests from law enforcement — to a chunk of a user’s iCloud data. It also better protects user data if Apple’s systems were ever breached.

Many privacy-focused groups welcomed the new security feature, among them the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF).

“We applaud Apple for listening to experts, child advocates, and users who want to protect their most sensitive data,” the EFF said in a statement. “Encryption is one of the most important tools we have for maintaining privacy and security online.”

It continued: “Apple’s on-device encryption is strong, but some especially sensitive iCloud data, such as photos and backups, has continued to be vulnerable to government demands and hackers. Users who opt in to Apple’s new proposed feature … will be protected even if there is a data breach in the cloud, a government demand, or a breach from within Apple (such as a rogue employee).”

However, offering a broad view on the matter to the Washington Post, the FBI made clear that it felt differently, saying it was “deeply concerned with the threat [that] end-to-end and user-only-access encryption pose,” as it “hinders our ability to protect the American people from criminal acts ranging from cyberattacks and violence against children to drug trafficking, organized crime, and terrorism.” The FBI added: “In this age of cybersecurity and demands for ‘security by design,’ the FBI and law enforcement partners need ‘lawful access by design.'”

Apple’s new security feature could also lead to a clash with the U.K. government, the Guardian reported, as incoming legislation places demands on messaging apps to deal with extreme content and gives regulators the power to order changes to such platforms if they fail to comply.

A spokesperson for the U.K. government said that while it supports strong encryption, “it cannot come at the expense of protecting the public. End-to-end encryption cannot be allowed to hamper efforts to catch perpetrators of the most serious crimes.”

Apple’s move to offer end-to-end encryption for some of its iCloud services highlights once again the ongoing issue of balancing user privacy and security with law enforcement’s desire to have the ability to access such data to help it successfully investigate criminal cases.

Advanced Data Protection for iCloud is available in the U.S. now to members of the Apple Beta Software Program, and to all U.S. users by the end of the year. Global rollout is targeted for early 2023.

Been holding off using iCloud but are now keen to give it a go? Digital Trends has you covered.

Editors' Recommendations

Trevor Mogg
Contributing Editor
Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…
I won’t upgrade my Apple Watch Series 5 until Apple adds this one feature
Apple Watch Series 5 on wrist with a pink gradient Modular watch face

Since it debuted in 2015, the Apple Watch went from one of those products we didn’t know we needed to something that some of us literally cannot live without. It’s not just a smartwatch with notifications and other functionality for our iPhone, but a complete health, activity, and wellness tracker too.

I remember when the first Apple Watch came out, and I scoffed at it — I had a Fitbit at the time, so why would I need an Apple Watch? Now, it’s something I can’t be without, even for a day (got to keep that Move streak going!)

Read more
I don’t understand why Apple hates the 10th Gen iPad so much
Apple iPad Gen 10 with the official keyboard accessory.

I love using the iPad as my primary computer. No self-respecting digital nomad should be allowed to say those words. At least not in 2022, when iPadOS is still miles behind macOS, primarily because of Apple’s walled-garden approach to the iPad app ecosystem.

But after spending well over $800 on the whole kit with the new Magic Keyboard Folio and Apple Pencil, maybe I’ve downed the bitter potion of its cons and learned to love it. Or, to put it more accurately, be at peace with its limitations. Whatever way you put it, this sleek tablet is impressive, and infuriating, to the same measure.
Performance champ, middling execution

Read more
In 2023, Apple needs to fix its embarrassing 5GB iCloud limit
Apple ID banner in the Settings app on an iPhone 14 Pro

The year is 2030 and Apple has released its first foldable iPhone, the iPhone 21 Pro Ultra Max Fold. You can get up to 4TB of storage, and prices start at $2,500. But you still only have 5GB of free iCloud storage.

Just kidding. Well, about the hardware part. It’s almost 2023, and yes, Apple still only gives you 5GB of storage for free with iCloud. Seriously? There's no arguing that 5GB is literally nothing these days. It’s shocking how Apple continues to only offer 5GB for free, despite the fact that even competitors offer a little more than that before going to paid tiers. Heading into 2023, it’s time for Apple to bump that up — even just a little bit.
5GB is no longer a realistic number

Read more