When it comes to your phone password, you can plead the Fifth in court

iPhone 5 unlock screen
The lock and key of the 21st century looks very different from that of a few hundred years ago. Gone are the padlocks, the chains, the actual, physical keys. Rather, when it comes to the storage and protection of our most valuable assets (and even that has changed from gold and jewels to gigabytes of data), we’ve come to rely on something much simpler — a phone password. Behind the four-digit lockscreens of many of our iPhones lies a veritable treasure trove of personal information, and lucky for you, a court ruling on a securities fraud action has just ruled that the government can’t touch it. (Not legally, at least.)

According to a federal district court judge in Pennsylvania, the Fifth Amendment protects smartphone passcodes, as releasing such information would constitute self-incrimination. It’s a sticky subject that will likely continue drawing judicial attention, but for the time being, pleading the Fifth will get you off the hook when it comes to sensitive data hidden in plain view on your phone.

The decision comes in connection with the SEC v. Huang lawsuit, an action that pits the Securities and Exchange Commission against Bonan and Nan Huang, two former Capital One data analysts accused of insider trading. According to the SEC, the defendants used proprietary company information to conjure a $150,000 investment into a $2.8 million return, a big no-no on Wall Street.

In order to prove their case, the SEC has asked for access to the ex-employees’ smartphones, but there was one big problem. While company records can be turned over, personal records fall under a slightly different category. The phones were Capital One property, but Bonan and Nan set the passcodes themselves. And because neither of the Huangs ever told Capital One what their passwords were, the federal district court which heard the case concluded that the information contained on the phones was to be considered considered personal, and therefore subject to Fifth Amendment privilege.

Moreover, according to the judge, the SEC “has no evidence any documents it seeks are actually located on the work-issued smartphones, or that they exist at all,” making the requirement of the passcodes a nearly moot point. As Greg Morvillo, the New York-based lawyer who represents the Huangs, said, “The SEC is just guessing that there’s something there on the phone.” Morvillo asserted that the judge’s decision gives credence to the notion that “personal and professional can coexist without an individual’s rights being sacrificed to the corporate entity.”

Experts are divided on the legitimacy of this latest ruling, which is largely based on the “foregone conclusion” doctrine. By this principle, if the government is aware that you are in possession of certain records (that may or may not be incriminating), they can legally force you to turn them over, and you forfeit the Fifth Amendment defense. If, on the other hand, the government has no evidence that these records exist (which is what Morvillo argues and the Pennsylsvania judge believes), then its hands are tied.

The issue of the inviolability of smartphone passcodes is far from resolved. When it comes to digital information, it would appear that the potential for loopholes and confusion concerning the right against self-incrimination (and the right to be protected from unreasonable searches and seizures) will continue for the foreseeable future. So plead the Fifth while you can, friends. Who knows how long it’ll last.


Millions of health records may be at stake in ransomware attack

LabCorps revealed that it was a victim of a data breach, and the FBI confirmed it was notified of a ransomware attack. With millions of health records at stake, it's still unclear what information, if any, the attackers accessed.

Not sure if Amazon Prime is right for you? Here is everything you need to know

So what is Amazon Prime? Is the premium membership really worth the cost of admission? Here, we break down the service's multitude of features, so you can make an informed decision.

Lost your router? Here's how to find its IP address to help track it down

Changing the login information for your router isn't always easy, that's why so many have that little card on the back. But in order to use it, you need to know where to go. Here's how to find the IP address of your router.

Ex-Apple engineer pleads not guilty to stealing autonomous car trade secrets

The FBI arrested a former Apple engineer named Xiaolang Zhang after he downloaded confidential files from the firm's self-driving car division. Zhang admitted that he planned to provide them to Chinese startup Xiaopeng Motors.

How to improve your Android privacy

If you have an Android device and you’re concerned about your privacy, then we have a few tips for you. Learn about the settings you can change to improve your Android privacy and safeguard your personal data.

Apple's third iOS 12 beta may help you save a lot of data

At this year's Worldwide Developer Conference, Apple unveiled its latest operating system, iOS 12. From app updates to group FaceTime, ARKit 2.0, and more, here are all the new features in iOS 12.

Tech Armor says its new screen protector improves iPhone performance. We tested it

Tech Armor has a new screen protector for the iPhone, the Enhance, that can redirect harmful radiation, while improving cell signal and battery life. Skeptical? So were we, so we put it to the test.

We tried all the latest and greatest smartphones to find the best of 2018

Smartphones are perhaps the most important and personal piece of tech on the planet. That’s why it’s important to pick the best phone for your individual needs. Here are the best smartphones you can buy.
Movies & TV

The best movies on Netflix in July 2018, from ‘Coco’ to ‘Jurassic Park’

Save yourself from hours wasted scrolling through Netflix's massive library by checking out our picks for the streamer's best movies available right now, whether you're into explosive action, subdued humor, or anything in between.

The upcoming Galaxy Note 9 may mark the end of Samsung's Note line

The Samsung Galaxy Note 9 will surely be big, bold, and pricey, but will it be foldable, or have an under-display fingerprint sensor? Those are just some of the rumors swirling around one of 2018's most anticipated phones.

Keep your driving record squeaky clean with these top-flight radar detectors

Nobody likes getting a speeding ticket, but these gadgets can help. Check out our picks for the best radar detectors on the market, from the likes of Valentine One, Escort, and Whistler.
Product Review

Stop stringing cords and replacing batteries with Ring's Spotlight Cam Solar

We like outdoor wireless cameras but dread the low-battery warning that inevitably comes with them. We tested the Ring Spotlight Cam Solar to see if it was the answer to our dead-battery prayers.
Product Review

The Moto Z3 Play packs a lot of juice with its included battery mod

Motorola’s latest phone is the mid-range Moto Z3 Play. It costs $500, so why wouldn’t you just get the OnePlus 6? The answer isn’t so simple. There’s a lot to like here, and the phone comes with a battery mod that extends its life…

Google’s $5.1 billion antitrust fine could mean the end of free Android

The European Commission has fined Google a record breaking $5.1 billion. The EU is accusing the company of severe antitrust infractions related to the search engine giant's handling of the Android ecosystem.

What is Android? All your questions about the operating system answered

Despite being on more than 2 billion phones, it's still possible to be unsure about parts of Android. What is stock Android, what's Oreo, and should you know about Android Go? We've got your answers.
Movies & TV

The best shows on Netflix in July, from ‘Arrested Development’ to ‘Mad Men’

Looking for a new show to binge? Lucky for you, we've curated a list of the best shows on Netflix, whether you're a fan of outlandish anime, dramatic period pieces, or shows that leave you questioning what lies beyond.

Best iOS app deals of the day! 6 paid iPhone apps are free for a limited time

Everyone likes apps, but sometimes the best ones are a bit expensive. Developers put paid apps on sale for a limited time, but you have to snatch them up fast. Here are the latest and greatest iOS app deals offered in the iOS App Store.

Here’s how to unlock your phone automatically with Android Smart Lock

Tired of unlocking your smartphone with a PIN or passcode? Android Smart Lock unlocks it automatically using your location, face, and more. Here's how to set it up, and everything you need to know about it.

FCC begins accepting petitions to deny the T-Mobile and Sprint merger

T-Mobile and Sprint are hoping the third time is the charm for a merger. It comes just months after the carriers cited an inability to find common ground, extending yet again the long dance between the two telecom giants.

Huawei may use a perforated LCD display to create a bezel-less Huawei Mate 20

Huawei has apparently put in an order for massive, 6.9-inch OLED screens, which will be used on a new smartphone coming later this year. Potentially its 2018 Mate series phone, it will challenge other big-screen devices we're expecting.
Home Theater

Set your ears free with the best completely wireless earbuds

If you can't stand the tangle of cords, or you're just excited about completely wireless earbuds, you're going to need some help separating the wheat from the chaff. Our list serves up the best wireless earbuds around.

Some Samsung phones aren’t alerting users of app background processes

Worried that Facebook is spying on you? Some Samsung phones aren't correctly showing some apps on the App Permission Monitor, so users won't be alerted if an app tries to access certain permissions.

Google, Microsoft, Twitter, and Facebook team up on new data transfer project

Some of the largest tech companies in the world have teamed up to make data portability a little easier. The initiative is called the Data Transfer Project, and the likes of Google, Twitter, Microsoft, and Facebook are all on board.