So who are the most fascinating TV serial killers to have ever graced our living rooms? Follow along to discover our top 10 picks. (Spoiler alert! Read on at your own risk.)
Viewers often sided with Miami Metro blood spatter analyst Dexter Morgan (Michael C. Hall) over his victims. That’s because he was a strange breed: A vigilante killer, trained to use his urges only for good by painstakingly researching, then ritualistically killing bad guys and gals once he was sure they were serial killers themselves — a species eradicating predator. His day job gave him unprecedented access to the tools and information needed to fulfill his night-time occupation of ridding the world of fellow killers, one garbage bag of body parts in the ocean at a time. And yet, while he ostensibly used his compulsions for good, the hypocrisy of it all was never far from site.
While most viewers know him better as Christian Grey, Jamie Dornan’s turn as serial killer Paul Spector in this highly-addictive British-Irish series was as masterful as any you’ll see on TV. A seemingly well-adjusted husband, psychologist, and father of two, Spector’s double life took him on the hunt for young professional women. He eventually acted on his deep desire to kill them, sometimes meticulously positioning their bodies and even bathing and painting their nails before fleeing the scene. Once he finally met his match in inspector Stella Gibson — played brilliantly by X-Files star Gillian Anderson — his disturbed life began to unravel. If you think Dornan is all cheese and little talent, you’ll definitely want to catch all three seasons of this nail-biting series on Netflix.
The Miniature Killer
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
The only female on the list, Natalie Davis, a.k.a. The Miniature Killer (Jessica Collins) from CSI season 7 got her name due to her affinity for creating highly-detailed, scale models that reflected each of her crime scenes, inspired by the scene she witnessed after pushing her little sister to her death from a treehouse. She’d leave her creations on site, or deliver them to someone involved in the investigation. Her method of murder was always brutal, ranging from bludgeoning to poisoning and even electrocution.
First appearing on screen in Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho (based on the Robert Bloch novel), Norman Bates was given a refresh via this A&E series. The show serves as a prequel to Bates’ later escapades, providing a glimpse into the killer’s life prior to becoming the mousy, yet sadistic killer from the film franchise. As the series progressed through its five seasons, Norman (Freddie Highmore) fell deeper into madness, while his mother Norma (Vera Farmiga) tried to protect and help him. If you’ve seen Psycho, you know how that turns out for both Bates and “Mother.”
Despite Kevin Bacon being at the center of the story as FBI agent Ryan Hardy, the scene-stealer was antagonist and serial killer Joe Carroll (James Purefoy), an attractive and charismatic former literary professor who guided a group of loyal cult followers to conduct brutal murders. The genuine pleasure Carroll got from taunting Hardy could make the hairs on your neck stand up while oddly almost making you like him – almost. It’s no surprise the show went downhill once the cat and mouse game between Carroll and Hardy ended.
This choice is a standout on the list for its demonic connection. The murders at the hand of this terrifying character, featured in the show’s revival on Showtime and played by Ray Wise, were actually the doings of an evil spirit named “BOB.” Despite Leland urging BOB to stop the kills, which include his own daughter Laura Palmer, BOB’s possession was just too powerful. Incidentally, has their ever been a spirit with a name as subtly evil as BOB?
With a revolving door of seemingly infinite serial killers, it’s hard to pick the top killer from this over-the-top drama. One of the most engaging was season 2’s Frank Breitkopf, thanks in large part to the performance of the oft-overlooked Keith Carradine (brother of the late David Carradine). As is common in the series, Breitkopf developed sexually sadistic behaviors, in this case due in part to witnessing his prostitute mother entertain clients in their home as a child. With his makeshift camper/torture chamber, Breitkopf would abduct and brutally torture his victims, then live off their possessions and money. Always one step ahead of the law, Breitkopf later fell for one of his potential victims, gifting her wind chimes made from human rib bones.
The Trinity Killer
Dexter came face-to-face with a number of formidable killers through the series, like season 1’s Ice Truck Killer. But none was as fascinating as the Trinity Killer, played by the great John Lithgow. Hiding in plain sight, Arthur Mitchell travelled the U.S. building houses for the less fortunate, using his charitable work as a cover for his dirty deeds. His kills were always performed in threes to mimic the deaths of his own family members. A young woman is murdered in a bathtub, a mother falls to her death, and a man gets bludgeoned. What truly made him terrifying, though, was his effect on the show’s anti-hero, Dexter himself.
Every list of serial killers needs a masked man, and Cameron Pell (Lee Ingleby) fits this bill with frightful gusto, donning a hooded jacket and Mr. Punch mask to perform his kills by slashing his victims’ throats or stabbing them to death. Pell would even spice things up by sending the police a live webcam feed. A lunatic of epic proportions, he longed to be remembered alongside his “heroes,” like Jack the Ripper, but Detective Luther (Idris Elba) had other plans for his legacy.
As anyone who’s seen Silence of the Lambs can attest, it was a daunting task undertaking this fiendish character from the mind of Thomas Harris after the great Anthony Hopkins left his indelible mark. But Hannibal’s Mads Mikkelson made the character all his own for all three seasons of this haunting NBC series, crafting an elegant and wonderfully measured monster in the guise of a brilliant psychiatrist. Keeping his enemies close, and his victims closer, this masterful performance is the stuff from which careers are made.
- The 50 best movies on Netflix right now
- The 60 best shows on Amazon Prime Video right now
- The 91 best movies on HBO Max right now
- The 49 best movies on Amazon Prime Video right now
- The best shows to binge-watch on Netflix right now