Skip to main content

The Gray Man stinks! Why Netflix has never made a great action movie

Few streaming services have worked as hard as Netflix has in recent years to launch a true blockbuster. The Gray Man has been a tremendous success for the service, at least according to their own internal metrics, but it’s hardly the first time that they’ve attempted to launch a piece of original intellectual property by throwing massive amounts of money at it. In spite of all that money, though, Netflix has yet to produce the kind of brilliant action spectacle that makes for a truly great movie.

That doesn’t mean, though, that Netflix has never made a great movie. Plenty of their prestige, awards-season plays have totally panned out, and movies like The Power of the Dog and Marriage Story have proven that the streamer can get behind great movies. In the world of action, though, their movies have been pretty thoroughly lacking. The Gray Man is just one of many attempts that seems great on paper but doesn’t ultimately deliver on its promise.

And The Gray Man isn’t alone: Red Notice, 6 Underground, Extraction, and The Army of the Dead are all movies that came and went fairly quickly and had virtually no legacy in the pop culture imagination. That’s not to say that all of these movies are irredeemably awful, but the action movies that debut on Netflix often seem like pale imitations of similar types of movies that still debut on the big screen.

Netflix needs to take a prestige approach to its blockbusters

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Two of the more successful action movies to debut on Netflix, at least in terms of their stickiness, were The Old Guard and Triple Frontier. Those movies, for all their faults, were decent in part because they didn’t seem to be totally fueled by the needs of the algorithm. Instead, they had at least some personal flair from the filmmakers behind them, and especially in the case of The Old Guard, they were also weighted with some serious thematic heft.

Unfortunately, projects like these are outliers in Netflix’s action oeuvre, even if they are still common in other parts of the service. If the streamer is serious about making the quality of its content better, it should consider taking the approach to its action movies that it already takes in the prestige space: Give trusted creative voices the chance to make whatever they want, and pray that the results are as good as you’d hoped.

Of course, this approach comes freighted with some risk. Not every creative endeavor is going to pan out, and sometimes, even great directors and writers don’t ultimately make successful projects. To Netflix’s credit, it seems like they gave the Russo brothers a fairly free hand on The Gray Man, although the result was less than a slam dunk.

Part of the reason The Gray Man failed to satisfy action snobs is its heavy reliance on CGI. In 2022, the best action often feels a lot more like what’s in Top Gun: Maverick. Having a movie star like Tom Cruise anchoring the project certainly doesn’t hurt anything either, but what makes Maverick work is that Cruise and the filmmakers spent their money on the right things. Instead of dedicating a large chunk of their budget to CGI, they went the other way, filming as much of the movie as practically possible.

In an era where anything is possible with a computer, what viewers crave is a sense that there is something tangible on screen, and that is what so many of Netflix’s biggest action vehicles have lacked.

Netflix has no incentive to change its ways

Netflix

There are certainly plenty of action fans out there who have found Netflix’s entries in the genre to be wanting, but for plenty of others, Netflix’s output is fulfilling the purpose it exists for. The Gray Man is not a great action movie if all you’re doing is putting your phone down to watch it. If you’re second-screening, though, or folding laundry, then The Gray Man is exactly as good as it needs to be.

Your time is Netflix’s money

If you want to do some chores and need something to put on in the background, Extraction might do the trick. These movies, for whatever their admirable qualities may be, aren’t meant to completely absorb you. They’re there to keep you logged in, and Netflix doesn’t really care if you put the movie on to take detailed notes or because you like to have something on in the background. Your time is their money, and the popularity of all of these action movies suggests that they know exactly what they’re doing.

For as much as an action snob may want Netflix to find a way to start making these action movies better, then, the truth of the matter is that the service has very little incentive to start doing anything differently. They have the eyeballs they need on these movies, even if all of them evaporate from your brain the second the credits start to roll.

Streaming won’t save the action movie

Tom Cruise looks down in Top Gun: Maverick.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

There are plenty of kinds of movies that streaming has proven to be remarkably adept at revitalizing. A separate conversation about romantic comedies is necessary, but it’s hard to deny that Netflix and its ilk have allowed the genre to exist in a way it no longer does in the theater. The same is true of mid-budget, awards season fare. While studios still make those kinds of movies, streamers like Apple and Netflix have also made plenty of great movies in that mold.

When it comes to action spectacle, though, the streamers haven’t cracked the code yet. And so, those of us who love action movies and all that they represent can’t look to these services as the source of our salvation. Fortunately, though, the big screen has had the kind of offerings that so often seem to be missing on Netflix.

Top Gun: Maverick isn’t alone. The past few years have seen a glut of good to great action movies on this big screen, from the John Wick series to Mad Max to Mission: Impossible. Even Bullet Train seems to be at least slightly ahead of where most Netflix titles fall. These theatrical experiences have been the backbone of the action movie for decades, and despite streaming’s disruptive promise, it seems like that model isn’t going anywhere.

Editors' Recommendations

Joe Allen
Joe Allen is a freelance writer based in upstate New York focused on movies and TV.
This action film is one of the most popular movies on Netflix. Here’s why you should watch it
the mother reasons why you should watch netflix action movie holding a rifle

The action genre is a tried and true formula that will never cease to be popular. It's often the spectacle of watching a sole individual achieve the impossible through the sheer force of will. And while the climactic moments of these films are often miles from reality, it's the power fantasy and the jolt of adrenaline these explosive sequences often deliver that make action movies so appealing. What ultimately makes or breaks an action film are the characters at the heart of the story. We'll return time and time again to watch Tom Holland's plucky Spider-Man experience the next big upset in his web-slinging career. And let's not forget Vin Diesel's Dom Toretto and his family of specialists who seem to hold an unshakeable power over death itself.

But in Netflix's latest offering, The Mother, the breathless velocity is laced with a serious edge. Jennifer Lopez sheds her rom-com persona and assumes a tough, surprisingly effective action-hero persona. As an expert assassin, Lopez must protect the child she gave up years ago from being killed by former associates who want both of them dead. The Mother is a lean, often brutal action movie, one that has proven to be a hit with audiences as it's one of the most popular movies on Netflix. Here's why you should watch it right now.
Jennifer Lopez shines in an action-heavy role

Read more
Heat is one of the best movies ever. Here’s why you should watch it on Netflix right now
Three men stand and get ready to fight in Heat.

There's a reason why Netflix has a reputation as being the best streaming service out there. It consistently streams some of the best TV shows around, with this year alone bringing such wonderful and diverse programs as Beef, The Night Agent, The Diplomat, and Queen Charlotte. It's movies, however, are more hit-or-miss. For every Oscar-nominated The Power of the Dog, there are a half-dozen Extractions or Red Notices, bland, forgettable movies that don't have any lasting effect on the viewer beyond their initial debut.

That probably explains why Heat, a movie made nearly 30 years ago, is one of the most popular movies on Netflix right now, ranking in the top 10 for the last two weeks. The Al Pacino/Robert De Niro action drama, which was praised when it was first released in December 1995, has stood the test of time not only due to its stellar acting, pitch-perfect direction, beautiful cinematography, and moody score, but also because it's simply one of the best movies ever made. That's a lofty claim to make, sure, but it's one that is justified. If you've already watched Heat, or have not ever heard of it and are curious to watch the Michael Mann film, here are a few reasons why it's worth a stream.
Heat has a great story that is both simple and sprawling

Read more
A Man Called Otto is a hit on Netflix. Here are 3 reasons why it’s so popular
Mariana Treviño shows a drawing to Tom Hanks in A Man Called Otto.

Following its release in theaters at the beginning of the year, A Man Called Otto has finally arrived on Netflix. The film, which is based on a 2015 Swedish movie called A Man Called Ove, follows an aging, cynical widower who finds that his life is opened up after he develops a relationship with his neighbors. Although the movie didn't make an insane amount of money in theaters, A Man Called Otto is doing quite well for itself on the streaming service, ranking consistently high on Netflix's most popular movies of the week list.

Anyone who tells you that they know exactly why a certain movie connects with audiences is lying. In this case, though, there are some factors we can examine which may offer some clues as to why A Man Called Otto has become such an incredible phenomenon since it hit the service a few weeks ago.
1. Tom Hanks's star power
A MAN CALLED OTTO - Official Trailer #2 (HD)

Read more