Skip to main content

‘Twin Peaks’ just keeps getting stranger in Part 5, for Agent Cooper and all of us

twin peaks the return part 5 analysis header
Five episodes into the new run of Twin Peaks, viewers may be growing impatient with one particular storyline: That of the show’s protagonist, Agent Dale Cooper. Audiences may have expected that, after more than two decades off the air, Cooper would quickly be back in the thick of things. Instead, he spends Part 5 shambling around in an oversized suit, parroting other people’s words and struggling to use the bathroom. While a triumphant return to the town of Twin Peaks may have been a little too straightforward for a David Lynch project, Cooper’s time in limbo could seem excessive.

Yet Cooper’s time living the life of Dougie Jones, his insurance agent doppelgänger, is par for the course with the new season, which has so far bucked the popular trends in television storytelling, just as the first season of Twin Peaks toyed with the tropes of its contemporaries, soap operas. In the age of binge watching, shows that still air weekly have to figure out how to pace themselves to keep audiences coming back week after week. Twin Peaks’ answer seems to be a refusal to play the game, telling, in its own way, a story about the passage of time and the difficulties of returning home.

Cooper struggles to operate his body

Since returning to the “real” world after his decades in the Black Lodge, Cooper has seemed a shell of himself, barely able to speak or act on his own. To the world, he is Dougie Jones, an insurance agent. Dougie’s wife dresses him, drops him off at work, and must even unbuckle his seatbelt and push him out of the car.

After years in a spiritual dimension where time flows any which way, Cooper seems completely lost, having returned to his flesh. Hunched over in the hallway at work, clutching his groin as he seems unable to locate a bathroom, he seems more like a toddler than the charming, competent Cooper of Twin Peaks past. It’s an undignified position for him to be in.

It makes sense, given where he has been. Having existed for so long without a body, the constraints of flesh — the urge to consume, to fill oneself up, followed by the swelling and straining of a bladder — must be disorienting. Cooper’s struggle also works on a thematic level. Twin Peaks: The Return has so far kept the old characters and locales at a distance, only occasionally checking in with characters like Hawk and Shelly. Time has passed, the world has changed, and it just isn’t easy to go home again.

Becky’s story shows that the world changes, except when it doesn’t

So far, the actual town of Twin Peaks has been a minor part of The Return, which has expanded the show’s setting New York, South Dakota, even Argentina. When the show does go back to Twin Peaks, the feelings it evokes are complex. On the one hand, there are the familiar faces: Shelly, Bobby, Lucy, still working the same jobs, still drinking at the roadhouse at night.

But the differences stand out. The Bang Bang Bar is no longer hosting Julee Cruise — not yet, anyway — but new acts like Chromatics. Doctor Jacoby still wears his red and blue shades, but now he broadcasts conspiracy theories to audiences via internet streaming, which Jerry Horne watches while smoking now-legal weed.

Even as the world has changed, some things stay the same. Shelly’s daughter Becky (Amanda Seyfried) is the latest incarnation of a common figure in Twin Peaks: The good girl caught up in bad business. After borrowing money from her mother, Becky gets into a car with her boyfriend, disheveled and unemployed, who offers her a line of coke. Despite some reluctance, she takes it, and drifts into a reverie, the camera focusing on her face the car rumbles on.

It’s a scene with many of Lynch’s signature touches — a beautiful girl, drug-induced euphoria, a vintage ‘60s pop song playing in the background — and it reveals that, no matter how much time may trample aspects of society, human behavior remains the same. Like Laura Palmer before her, Becky is a seemingly lovely young woman on a dark path of drugs and dangerous men.

The original Twin Peaks was a product of its era, not just in the genres it drew from, but in the world it presented. The opening credits of the first two seasons showed an industrial society, with factories running, machines sharpening saw blades. These images are absent from the new credits. The world has changed, and Twin Peaks, like Cooper, is adjusting. What hasn’t changed is the show’s willingness to be different, no matter how obtuse it may come across.

As with Cooper, the show refuses to give us an easy grasp on things, even in its format. After Parts 2-4 ended with musical performances, Part 5 subverts expectations, rolling credits as Cooper stares at a statue of a lawman, drawn to an emblem of his former life.

Here’s what you missed in Twin Peaks: The Return, Part 4.

Editors' Recommendations

Will Nicol
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Will Nicol is a Senior Writer at Digital Trends. He covers a variety of subjects, particularly emerging technologies, movies…
‘Twin Peaks’ explained, ‘Part 10:’ Men behaving badly
Twin Peaks Explained Part 10

Amid the various digressions and riddles presented in each new episode of Twin Peaks, you'd be excused for openly wondering on occasion just what exactly this show is about -- not just narratively, but thematically. While there are many angles you could take -- the town of Twin Peaks itself, beset by substance abuse, could be read as a requiem for small town America -- one of the most prominent strains in the show, both in the original run and the new, is the presentation of evil.

Evil in Twin Peaks is often depicted in otherworldly figures, such as the woodsmen or the Black Lodge, the nightmarish home of menacing spirits like BOB and the Man from Another Place. But evil also tends to manifest in mundane ways. Even BOB, the body-snatching archvillain of the original show, most often took the form of an ordinary, if creepy, man in a trucker jacket. In The Return, Cooper’s doppelgänger, the primary antagonist, is similarly ordinary: He’s just Cooper with a leather jacket and a flowing mane, the kind of person who wouldn’t look out of place browsing the metal section at a record store.

Read more
‘Twin Peaks’ Explained: ‘Part 9’ starts to pull things together
Twin Peaks Gordon and Diane

After the controlled madness of Part 8, viewers could only guess what the next episode of Twin Peaks would entail. A 20-minute scene presenting a cell’s eye view of endocytosis, maybe? As it turns out, Part 9 offers a return to form that's at times closer in tone to the original series than the experimental phantasmagoria that has defined "The Return" so far. Part 9 starts to slowly bring the various storylines together, and while it is not as daring as the previous chapter, it still shows an exceptional patience, as well as a reluctance to make the audience comfortable.

Halfway through Twin Peaks: The Return, where does everything stand? Agent Dale Cooper remains stranded in the life of Dougie Jones, insurance agent, though a return to his old self seems imminent. He survives an attack by hitman Ike “The Spike” Stadtler, whom he disarms -- or dispalms -- with the help of The Arm, by superheating Ike’s gun and burning off his flesh. As a result, Dougie draws the further attention of the three detectives, all with the last name Fusco, who suspect there is more to Dougie than his one-word answers and blank stare suggest. Heightening their suspicions is the fact that there are no records of Dougie before 1997; it’s as if he appeared out of thin air (or emerged from an electrical socket, as Cooper did in Part 3).

Read more
‘Twin Peaks’ explained: ‘Part 8’ takes an experimental journey through darkness
twin peaks part 8 doppelganger

One of the great difficulties of writing about Twin Peaks, or even just watching it, is David Lynch’s “18 hour movie” approach to the new season. With most weekly shows, even more serialized ones like Breaking Bad, episodes have a distinct story arc. During the course of our Twin Peaks evaluation and analysis, it's become clear that each episode is like a chapter of a novel, and without having seen the story from beginning to end, the importance and meaning of each episode can seem inscrutable.

That’s what makes Part 8 so fascinating. If a viewer is hoping for forward movement in Agent Cooper’s story, or ready answers to any of the pestilential questions the show has raised, this episode provides neither. What it does offer is a stunning experiment in form, and perhaps even an origin story for the evils that plague the world of Twin Peaks.
A dark (but conventional) beginning
Part 8 begins with Cooper’s doppelgänger and Ray, fresh off their early release from jail, driving down a dark and winding road. No director makes the simple act of driving feel as sinister as David Lynch does. The world outside the car is pitch black, the headlights making a shallow cut in the darkness.

Read more