Skip to main content

RIAA says YouTube isn’t willing to make a ‘real negotiation’ for higher music royalties

With the world’s three biggest labels — Universal Music Group, Sony Music, and Warner Music Group — set to re-negotiate contracts with YouTube this year, the musical powers that be want to figure out how to get a better shake.

The RIAA and the the labels’ global trade group, the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI), are looking to coax more from the notoriously low-paying streaming video giant — but the current situation when it comes to music copyright law makes that goal look like a long shot.

Recommended Videos

Despite labels’ best efforts, millions of unlicensed songs continue to be illegally uploaded to the streaming video service annually. And due to vast protections afforded to YouTube under 1998’s Digital Millennium Copyright Act, the service doesn’t have any legal mandate to better combat piracy.

That’s largely due to the DMCA’s “Notice and takedown” policy, which RIAA head Cary Sherman lambasted in a recent interview with Re/Code for being outdated and not reaching far enough in the new streaming paradigm.

“There are 100 copies of a song. We can’t just say to YouTube, ‘we didn’t license this Pharrell song, take it down.’ They will not just take down all 100 copies. They’ll take down only the one file that we’ve identified. We have to find every one of them, and notice them, and then they’re taken down, and then immediately put right back up. You can never get all the songs off the system.”

When negotiating with a streaming service like YouTube, which sees a steady flow of illegal uploads of copyrighted material, it’s nearly impossible for labels to combat the problem under the current legal structure. And though YouTube does bring in ad-based revenue for licensed content, Sherman and others assert royalty rates from YouTube and other user-uploaded services are abysmally low.

“Advertising-supported user upload services comprise the biggest on-demand music audience in the world, with over 900 million users,” wrote IFPI CEO Frances Moore in a statement about the industry, “Yet they form part of an advertising-supported revenue sector that makes up only four per cent [sic] of global music industry revenues. This is, emphatically, not a fair correlation between the consumption of music and the value that it is generating for artists, creators and investors.”

Sherman joins Moore in agreeing that YouTube and others do not have rights holders’ best interest at heart, and Sherman is not optimistic about this year’s contract renegotiations. In fact, he describes the new round of upcoming negotiations between major labels and Google’s streaming juggernaut almost like a mafia shakedown.

“The way the negotiation goes is something like this: ‘Look. This is all we can afford to pay you,’ YouTube says. ‘We hope that you’ll find that reasonable. But that’s the best we can do. And if you don’t want to give us a license, okay. You know that your music is still going to be up on the service anyway. So send us notices, and we’ll take ’em down as fast we can, and we know they’ll keep coming back up. We’ll do what we can. It’s your decision as to whether you want to take our deal, or whether you just want to keep sending us takedown notices.’ That’s not a real negotiation. That’s like saying, ‘That’s a real nice song you got there. Be a shame if anything happened to it.’”

For now, the two parties appear to be at an impasse, so it will be interesting to see how the negotiations shake out. We’ll be keeping a close eye on this, so stay with us as details develop.

Parker Hall
Former Senior Writer, Home Theater/Music
Parker Hall is a writer and musician from Portland, OR. He is a graduate of the Oberlin Conservatory of Music in Oberlin…
What is YouTube Music? Everything you need to know
iPhone 15 Pro Max showing the YouTube Music app.

YouTube, long renowned for its vast video library, has quietly established itself as a formidable music streaming service. Its dedicated app, YouTube Music, offers a curated collection of songs, albums, and podcasts catering to various music lovers. With millions of songs and countless music videos, YouTube Music boasts a comprehensive catalog that rivals industry giants like Spotify and Apple Music.

The app utilizes advanced algorithms to suggest music based on your listening habits, ensuring a tailored and enjoyable experience. YouTube Premium subscribers can download their favorite tracks for offline playback, perfect for commutes, workouts, or areas with limited internet connectivity.

Read more
What is YouTube Premium? Price, content, and more
YouTube Music

When it comes to watching videos on the internet, YouTube remains the most common place to do it. It's been around since 2005, delivering a hub for video content and includes everything from the newest music videos, to live-streaming events. While the website itself is free to use, its filled with ads that have a tendency to interrupt your videos at the worst possible time. However, with YouTube Premium you can eliminate those pesky ads, and get back to watching the content you want to see -- without interruptions.

The YouTube family of products can be a bit confusing, however. In addition to YouTube Premium, there are other paid services like YouTube Music, YouTube TV, and the now-defunct YouTube Go, plus some free movies on YouTube you don't want to miss. The price of YouTube Premium has changes since launch, and with new services like YouTube Premium Lite, its worth considering which option is right for you. There are even bundling options that could save you some money like the YouTube Premium family plan, or the free trial.

Read more
YouTube TV: plans, pricing, channels, how to cancel, and more
An NFL Sunday Ticket multiview option on YouTube TV.

Streamers like Netflix continue to fight for dominance of original content in TV and film against the seemingly endless number of VOD platforms available today. With new apps and services landing regularly, it can be hard to tell what platforms to pay attention to. But heed our words, friends: trust in YouTube TV. 

Similar to Hulu Plus Live TV, Sling TV, Fubo, and DirecTV Stream, YouTube TV offers access to live local and cable only channels, as well as on-demand YouTube movies and shows. There are several other perks to enjoy too, and we’ve broken everything down in this complete guide to YouTube TV.

Read more