Skip to main content

Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Why trust us?

The one thing Katy Perry and Taylor Swift agree on: The fight against YouTube

When’s the last time you can remember Taylor Swift and Katy Perry agreeing on anything? Well, the embattled pop stars have something in common now: The pair have joined hundreds of musicians and labels who have signed a new petition calling for reforms of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. The two-decades old piece of legislation makes it legal for sites like YouTube to host any piece of user-uploaded content, which makes it nearly impossible to rid the net of illegally-hosted material.

Signed by a huge collection of major labels and artists, from Perry and Swift to Paul McCartney and Queens of the Stone Age (even Kenny G inked this thing), the petition contends the law is outdated. The artists, copyright holders, and labels argue that YouTube and companies like it use the DMCA to their advantage, largely because the modern world of streaming came into existence well after the law was signed. The advocates claim that reforms to the law would help industry members avoid the losses and hassles from persistent copyright infringement.

Recommended Videos

“They put ads before everything, making big money and artists don’t get paid – or don’t get paid enough – and that’s fine, apparently,” said Radiohead frontman Thom Yorke of the service in an interview with the Telegraph last December, “[But] if they don’t get profit from [ad-blocking] then no, it’s not fair” … “I don’t have a solution for these problems. I just know [YouTube] makes money [from] the work of so many artists that don’t make any profit.” A copy of the petition below outlines a wide variety of artists looking to impede YouTube, and other sites like it.

DMCA Petition
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The petition originally appeared in print on Tuesday as an advertisement in Washington DC magazines Politico, The Hill, and Roll Call, with 180 musician signatures and 19 music-affiliated organizations and companies. The list has since grown to include even more big names, such as that of indie rocker/producer Jack White. And though it doesn’t name YouTube in particular, it’s clear where the group’s cross-hairs are aimed.

“I could probably find 250 songs in five minutes on YouTube which the artist isn’t getting paid for,” said Black Keys drummer Patrick Carney recently on Twitter.

Artists are usually a tough bunch to wrangle together on any issue, and that perhaps points to the relative severity of this one. For its part, YouTube remains resolute that its Content ID system, which allows labels and musicians to remove or monetize music on the service, is effective. That said, there isn’t a clear metric at present to find out how much music slips through the cracks, and a simple search on YouTube confirms that a lot does.

Digital Trends reached out to YouTube for comment about the petition, and a company spokesperson responded with the following:

“Digital services are not the enemy. YouTube is working collaboratively with the music industry to bring more money to artists beyond the $3 billion we’ve already paid out to date. The overwhelming majority of labels and publishers have licensing agreements in place with YouTube, and choose to leave fan uploads up on the platform and earn money from them 95% of the time. Our rights management system, Content ID, goes above and beyond what the law requires to help rights owners manage their content on YouTube, with fan uploads driving 50% of their revenue today. Ultimately we believe that by providing more transparency into payouts to artists we can address many of these concerns.”

We’ll continue to follow this story as events unfold, so stay tuned.

Updated on 06-22-2016 by Parker Hall: Updated to add a response from a YouTube spokesperson.

Parker Hall
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Parker Hall is a writer and musician from Portland, OR. He is a graduate of the Oberlin Conservatory of Music in Oberlin…
What is YouTube Music? Everything you need to know
iPhone 15 Pro Max showing the YouTube Music app.

YouTube, long renowned for its vast video library, has quietly established itself as a formidable music streaming service. Its dedicated app, YouTube Music, offers a curated collection of songs, albums, and podcasts catering to various music lovers. With millions of songs and countless music videos, YouTube Music boasts a comprehensive catalog that rivals industry giants like Spotify and Apple Music.

The app utilizes advanced algorithms to suggest music based on your listening habits, ensuring a tailored and enjoyable experience. YouTube Premium subscribers can download their favorite tracks for offline playback, perfect for commutes, workouts, or areas with limited internet connectivity.

Read more
What is YouTube Premium? Price, content, and more
YouTube Music

When it comes to watching videos on the internet, YouTube remains the most common place to do it. It's been around since 2005, delivering a hub for video content and includes everything from the newest music videos, to live-streaming events. While the website itself is free to use, its filled with ads that have a tendency to interrupt your videos at the worst possible time. However, with YouTube Premium you can eliminate those pesky ads, and get back to watching the content you want to see -- without interruptions.

The YouTube family of products can be a bit confusing, however. In addition to YouTube Premium, there are other paid services like YouTube Music, YouTube TV, and the now-defunct YouTube Go, plus some free movies on YouTube you don't want to miss. The price of YouTube Premium has changes since launch, and with new services like YouTube Premium Lite, its worth considering which option is right for you. There are even bundling options that could save you some money like the YouTube Premium family plan, or the free trial.

Read more
YouTube TV: plans, pricing, channels, how to cancel, and more
An NFL Sunday Ticket multiview option on YouTube TV.

Streamers like Netflix continue to fight for dominance of original content in TV and film against the seemingly endless number of VOD platforms available today. With new apps and services landing regularly, it can be hard to tell what platforms to pay attention to. But heed our words, friends: trust in YouTube TV. 

Similar to Hulu Plus Live TV, Sling TV, Fubo, and DirecTV Stream, YouTube TV offers access to live local and cable only channels, as well as on-demand YouTube movies and shows. There are several other perks to enjoy too, and we’ve broken everything down in this complete guide to YouTube TV.

Read more