DVD Format Wars

Everyone loves DVD. Most big-screen TVs sold nowadays are HDTVs. So you?d think a high-definition version of the DVD format would a natural­splashing a sharper and more detailed picture onto a screen that can show the difference.
 
Yet high-definition DVD remains stuck at the starting gate. The reason is yet another self-destructive format war from a consumer electronics industry that seems incapable of learning the lessons of its own history. Who will win the high-def DVD sweepstakes­HD-DVD or Blu-ray?
 
HD-DVD is backed by Toshiba and NEC. Toshiba was a prime mover behind the existing DVD format. The Blu-ray Disc Founders Group (BDFG) includes Hitachi, HP, LG (Zenith), Matsushita (Panasonic), Mitsubishi, Philips, Pioneer, Samsung, Sharp, TDK, Thomson (RCA)­and especially Sony, which has offered a Blu-ray recorder for some time, albeit in Japan and at a stiff price.

HD-DVD has been endorsed by the DVD Forum, a consortium whose purpose is to keep the DVD format from descending into chaos. But for the sheer bulk of corporate supporters, Blu-ray has an edge.

Besides political muscle, Blu-ray has the added advantage of being recordable. However, it?s hobbled by the fragility of the disc, which must be enclosed in a caddy, much like Sony?s MiniDisc. BDFG member TDK is developing a coating technology that would give the disc a harder and more durable surface.

Have I mentioned that the governments of China and Taiwan both have high-definition DVD formats of their own in development? Taiwan alone has two!

So what exactly is going on here? What?s the reason for this format fiasco? I?ve got two little words for you: licensing revenues. Every time an electronic product gets sold, someone, somewhere gets paid. The manufacturer isn?t the only one who profits. Whoever developed the underlying technology (or technologies)  also does.

The licensing fee may constitute only a small part of the product?s overall cost. But multiply it by millions (or hundreds of millions) of products rolling off assembly lines around the world and you?ll have a general idea of why every manufacturing player in the CE industry wants to be a format-licensing player as well.

Format wars are nothing new. They?ve been going on since Thomas Edison?s cylinder phonograph lost out to Alexander Graham Bell?s flat disc?the forerunner of today?s many flat disc formats.

The most notorious format war of recent times was Beta vs. VHS. Videophiles swore Sony?s Betamax was better, citing the elegance of its U-load mechanism over VHS?s clunky M-load, but the VHS people were wilier. Prodded by its U.S. licensee RCA, Matsushita/JVC made VHS the first consumer videocassette format to record for a movie-length two hours. By the time Sony added slower speeds to the Beta format, it was too late.

Another notable format war from the same era was the laserdisc (or as it was originally known, LaserVision) vs. the CED (Capacitance Electronic Disc). Pioneer was the corporate champion of LD while CED was an ambitious effort by RCA, already doing well in VHS VCRs, to generate licensing revenue from videodiscs. For awhile they were in a dead heat, but in the end, the high-end videophile public chose the laser-read LD over the stylus-read, caddy-enclosed CED, which some derided as ?needlevision.?

RCA lost tens of millions of dollars on the CED and, in the process, its independence. The once proud company was sold first to General Electric, then to Thomson of France, and most recently has become a partner of the Chinese giant TCL. The RCA brand is still a major presence in the U.S. marketplace, and RCA has a glorious history?having had a significant hand in developing and/or popularizing the current analog television standard, FM radio, the DirecTV satellite system, and the quarter-inch jack that festoons your a/v components?but it has not flown an independent banner for quite some time.

Meanwhile, Sony lost none of its zest for developing new formats. Its MiniDisc more or less won over Philips? Digital Compact Cassette during the 1990s. Both used early versions of compressed digital audio. DCC was backward-compatible with the analog cassette format, but the MiniDisc was cooler and more mechanically reliable, and became popular in Japan. In the States both were eclipsed by the nascent CD-R.

The latest Sony format gladiator is the Super Audio CD, rival to the DVD-Audio (as opposed to the more common DVD-Video) format. Both support surround sound and provide higher sound quality than the CD. Both come packaged with DVD-Video players (though there are a few SACD-only players out there). Not all SACD players support DVD-Audio; by the same token, there are some DVD-Audio players that don?t support SACD.

If you want to hear Pink Floyd?s Dark Side of the Moon in high-res surround, you?ll need an SACD-compatible player. If you want to hear Living Colour?s Collideøscope in high-res surround, you?ll need something with DVD-Audio capability. If you want a player that can handle both, there are so-called universal players from Apex, Denon, Integra, Onkyo, Pioneer, Yamaha, and Zenith, among others.

If you want all this to stop, you?re screwed.

Occasionally format peace breaks out. RCA?s 45 rpm record happily coexisted with CBS?s 33 rpm LP for decades. People bought singles on 45s and longform recordings on LPs (which stands for Long Playing record).

A more recent exception to the rule has been the DVD-Video format, the one you rent movies on at Blockbuster. DVD nearly fell victim to a format war between Toshiba and its partners and Sony and its partners. Luckily for DVD?and for us?Warner Home Video?s Warren Lieberfarb stepped in between the warring factions.

As an admiring profile on MS-NBC puts it: ?He cajoled, strong-armed and bargained with industry players around the world to set aside their parochial interests and sign on to a universal standard for the new format.? Today, it?s Lieberfarb?not Toshiba or Sony?who?s remembered as ?the father of DVD.? Under the compromise he brokered, Toshiba, Sony, and various other players share format licensing revenue from DVD.

More important, the entire consumer electronics industry benefits from the unified format. Filmmakers benefit too?a lot of movies simply wouldn?t get made if it weren?t for the prospective revenue stream from DVD release?and of course Hollywood studios love DVD because it adds millions to their bottom lines. (?Not that there?s anything wrong with that,? as they used to say on Seinfeld.

But the happiest beneficiaries are you and me. DVD enables us to collect films in a format with a better picture, better surround sound, and more durability than we ever enjoyed with VHS (or Beta).

Given the proven popularity of DVD, and the proven benefits of cooperative format development, it?s all the more frustrating that a unified high-definition DVD format hasn?t emerged. Where is the next Warren Lieberfarb? Who will broker the peace agreement that will bring a high-def DVD format safe enough to invest in to a public that?s already bought millions of HDTVs?

That statesman has yet to step forward. So we wait, and what we?re waiting for may be yet another confusing format war. These corporations, they?re worse than the Republicans and the Democrats?and that?s pretty bad!

So, what dead formats do you have sitting in the back of your closet? And are you as eager for high-definition DVD as I am?

_____________________________________________________

Mark Fleischmann is the author of Practical Home Theater (http://www.quietriverpress.com/).

*Edited 1/10/05 – We found a serious error which has been corrected. Originally we stated that HD DVD uses a red laser which is incorrect, it uses a blue laser like Blu-ray. We apologize for any inconvenience this may have caused.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.

Home Theater

Here's how to preserve your precious VHS memories in a modern format

There's no reason you should have to lose those precious home videos just because VHS is a dying format. Here, we'll show you how to convert VHS tapes to a digital format, and save those memories forever.
Home Theater

The best Dolby Atmos movies for your home theater sound as good as they look

If you've got your hands on some sweet Dolby Atmos gear, the next step is to find films that take advantage of it. These are our picks in every genre for the best Dolby Atmos movies currently available on Blu-ray and streaming services.
Home Theater

The ultimate surround sound guide: Different formats explained

Wondering which is the best surround sound format for your home theater system? Start by learning the technical differences between the various formats with our ultimate surround sound guide.
Home Theater

Need more contrast in your life? Here’s what you need to know about HDR TVs

So what is HDR TV? In a nutshell, it’s the best thing to happen to TV since the arrival of 4K. Here's everything you need to know about the technology, what it can do, and why it’s a must-have.
Deals

Time to upgrade! Here are the best 4K TV deals for July 2018

There's no doubt that a good 4K smart TV is the best way to take your home entertainment setup to the next level so you can enjoy all of your favorite shows, movies, and games in glorious Ultra HD. We've got the best 4K TV deals right here.
Home Theater

These awesome A/V receivers will swarm you with surround sound at any budget

There is no one-size-fits-all approach to shopping for a receiver, so we assembled our favorites for 2018, at multiple price points and all loaded with features, from Dolby Atmos to 4K HDR, and much more.
Movies & TV

Binge away with our guide to the best on-demand streaming services

Looking to waste a weekend bingeing or just putting together a movie night? Find out everything you need, from prices to features, in our guide to the best online streaming sites and services for on-demand movies and TV shows.
Home Theater

Time for a TV upgrade? Here’s what you need to know about 4K Ultra HD TV

Ultra HD 4K has quickly taken over the world of TVs. But what is Ultra HD 4K, how does it work, and most importantly, should you upgrade, or keep your old TV? We explain it all right here.
Gaming

Xbox One S vs. Xbox One X: Is the costly upgrade worth the money?

The Xbox One X is officially here and pretty much everything rumored about it was true. Is the higher price point worth it, or does it put it out of reach for most consumers? Here's how it matches up to the Xbox One S.
Home Theater

5 gorgeous turntables that spin stacks of wax in style for less than $500

Vinyl records are awesome, but they're also finicky. To get the best out of your stacks of wax, it's best to play them on a quality turntable. Here are the best turntables to be had for under $500.
Gaming

One game console is better than the rest, and we're not afraid to say it

We've seen a relatively large influx of new consoles in the last year, including the Nintendo Switch and Xbox One X, so we've updated our recommendations for the best dedicated game hardware.
Home Theater

The 7 best TVs you can buy right now, from budget to big screen

Looking for a new television? In an oversaturated market, buying power is at an all-time high, but you'll need to cut through the rough to find a diamond. We're here to help with our picks for the best TVs of 2018.
Home Theater

We all cut cable, and now we’re just as screwed on streaming

As live TV streaming services like Sling TV and PlayStation Vue raise prices in tandem, it raises questions about whether these services were ever a viable alternative to cable in the first place.
Home Theater

Are there reasons to own a projector when big TVs are so cheap? Glad you asked

Since no aspect of your home theater setup is more important than your display, we weigh in on the projectors vs. TVs debate. We've put together this comprehensive guide to help you find the right option for your lifestyle.
Home Theater

Netflix vs. Hulu vs. Amazon Prime: Battle of the streaming giants

Trying to figure out which subscription streaming service to use while sticking to a frugal entertainment budget? Check out our updated comparison of the big three: Netflix, Amazon Instant Video, and Hulu.
Home Theater

How to install an HD antenna so you can start enjoying free television

Today's TV antennas will get you loads of free over-the-air broadcast TV, but setting them up can be a challenge. We walk you through how to install a TV antenna, and provide tips on picking the best antenna for your home.
Home Theater

AT&T wants to make HBO more like Netflix, and it could be a disaster

After acquiring HBO parent company Time Warner, AT&T is pushing HBO to become more like Netflix, but for all of Netflix’s success, this plan might not be great for either HBO or its customers.
Home Theater

Why I still won’t wear wireless headphones

Wireless headphones promise liberation from cords, tangles, and snags, but there’s just one issue holding them back: battery life. And until manufacturers figure it out, sales numbers prove consumers aren’t yet biting.
Gaming

Google might be planning a game console. That doesn’t mean it will happen

A new report suggests that Google is working on a game console, code-named Yeti. The reports about Google's game console are likely true, but that doesn't mean we will ever see it.
Computing

MacOS Mojave brings evening elegance to your Mac experience

The MacOS Mojave public beta is out now, with an official release coming later this fall. Chock-full of quality-of-life upgrades, we took it for a test drive to get a sneak peek at what you can expect from the next major update to MacOS…
Health & Fitness

Ugh. I’m done with fitness trackers, and so is the world

In 2016, everyone was tracking their fitness. In 2017, people grew tired of it. In 2018, I’m done with it. I’m going tracker-free in my workouts from now on.
Mobile

iOS 12 is more evidence you should buy an iPhone, not an Android phone

The next version of Apple’s mobile operating system, iOS 12, will be compatible with devices all the way back to 2013’s iPhone 5S. Android phones from the same era didn’t even see 2016’s software update. It’s further evidence you…
Mobile

5 obviously stupid iPhone problems that iOS 12 doesn’t even try to fix

At WWDC 2018, Apple took the wraps off the latest version of its iOS operating system. iOS 12 introduces quite a bit of changes -- visually and under the hood -- but there are still some basics that it doesn’t address. Here are a few of…