Hard shell buying guide: How to choose the best jacket

hard shell jacket buying guide hiker in
If you browse for a new hard shell jacket either online or at a retail store you might be overwhelmed by the vast number of products and featured technologies. What is the difference between a shell that costs $100 and one that costs $700? When should you go with Gore-Tex? Do you need a two-layer jacket or a three-layer jacket, and what does that even mean? Well, we’ve put together a comprehensive guide highlighting the ins and outs of hard shells, so you can get a better understanding regarding the fabric and waterproofing that goes into each product offering.

What is a hard shell?

A “hard shell” is an outer layer of waterproof — as opposed to water-resistant — clothing worn to protect yourself from heat-sapping natural phenomena like wind, falling water (in its various states), or miserable and hazardous combinations thereof.

Hard shells exist in contrast to “soft shells,” which offer light protection from mild weather in fair conditions but typically are not seam-taped and without an inner membrane or coating. Hard shells often feature fully-taped waterproof seams along with a beefy outer layer of chemically-treated nylon designed to repel water, as well as an inner coating or membrane of waterproof fabric that will help prevent precipitation from soaking through the jacket.

Hard shells are also made to withstand whatever nature can throw at you while soft shells are made for light protection in fair weather.

What is a waterproof breathable membrane?

A “waterproof breathable membrane” is a piece of fabric designed to allow sweaty perspiration to “breathe” out through the jacket as water vapor while keeping more dense liquid rain and solid snow out. The high-end “pro-sumer” shell market is led by Gore-Tex-branded products that make use of lifetime-warrantied, buy-it-once, chemically inert expanded polytetrafluoroethylene WPB membranes. Competing membrane technologies include the air-permeable eVent and NeoShell, but all of these PTFE technologies will keep the rain and snow out.

hard shell jacket buying guide goretex image 1

Without added pressure such as contact with the straps of a heavy pack, a product with a number at or larger than a 10,000-millimeter hydrostatic head rating — a measurement of how tall a literal column of water can be placed on a piece of fabric before water seeps through — is considered properly waterproof in moderate rain or snow, and you will be hard pressed to find any PTFE hard shell rated below that.

Instead of using a pricey, name-brand membrane to justify a high price, entry-level consumer shells often feature a proprietary “house brand” polyurethane coating as the primary waterproofing. Polyurethane coatings provide a lower cost to the consumer but have lower moisture vapor transmission rates (MVTR) under high exertion. Lower MVTR translates into reduced ability to prevent condensation on the inside of a jacket that is supposed to be keeping you dry. Moisture build up on your insulating layers can lead to hypothermia in certain situations and the wet-out mitigating, high MVTRs found in PTFE products are a major reason to consider shelling out the cash for their loftier prices.

hard shell jacket buying guide goretex image 2

It is important to have reasonable expectations about the so-called “breathability” advertisers mention on a product description page or hang tag of both PTFE shells and PU-coated shells. While most modern shells allow vapor transfer at a much greater rate than a trash bag or rubber coat of old, even the most expensive hard shells will leave you soaked from your own sweat if you try a hard workout in them.

How many layers?

Jacket manufacturers use different numbers of material layers on their products to create a range of shells that offer the right mix of durability, packability, and weight for your intended use. Two-layer jackets are less durable but usually lighter in weight than 2.5 or three-layer shells, and offer only an outer layer of abrasion-resistant material and an inner waterproof layer.

Most 2.5-layer products are a common middle ground offering that use a printed pattern of protective material on the inside layer to prolong the long-term weather protection of the product while keeping the bulk low and the price down.

Outdoor guides and power users who live in their shells should look to three-layer products that sandwich the WPB membrane between two layers of protective material to resist abrasion and membrane-clogging oils and sediments from both the skin of the user and the outside world.

Outer face fabrics?

The recent trend among hard shells targeting users in agile, high-mobility sports is to use a dynamic, stretch fabric instead of a traditional static nylon exterior fabric. These come in two flavors: A two-way unidirectional stretch, and a four-way “all-direction” stretch for comfortable wear for climbers and trekkers. Stretch fabrics are found more often on athletic-fit shells, and offer an increased range of motion for your appendages without using a baggier arrangement of fabrics in the shell.

Shell shoppers with durability in mind will want to pay attention to the “denier” or “ounce per square yard” weight of the fabrics, which are used to gauge the ability of the fabric to hold up to real world use. Denier is the mass in grams of 9,000 meters of a given fiber, and is often displayed as a number followed by the letter “D,” as in “90D.” Ounce per yard is the weight of a 1 x 1-yard piece of the fabric. Both metrics can be used as general indicators of the durability of a fabric when you’re choosing between products.

Bombproof hard shells like the Arc’teryx Beta SV feature a burly 80-denier nylon exterior that’s built to withstand bumps into jagged rocks and sharp ice, while the Patagonia Alpine Houdini uses a lighter 20-denier face for easy “just in case” carrying. For help comparison purposes, consider that the popular workhorse Marmot PreCip Jacket uses a 2.2 ounce per square yard fabric whereas the super packable ZPacks Challenger Ultralight Rain Jacket uses a barely-there 1.62 ounce per square yard material.

Which hard shell is right for my activity?

Have you done all the research you can stomach but still aren’t sure what sort of shell to buy? Think of the activity you are realistically going to spend most of your time doing while wearing the hard shell. If all you plan to do is wear the shell to the bleachers at a November football match, you will stay dry in any waterproof shell you put on, but may appreciate a wider fit for comfort when wearing winter layers underneath.

Are you more of a distance runner or a general minimalist in need of emergency protection? The Arc’teryx Norvan SL offers no protective face fabric, no pockets, and no pit zips, but it provides a scant 4.2 ounce of waterproof protection.

hard shell jacket buying guide arcteryx lifestye image 1

Bleeding-edge, ultralight backpackers who need material that is both light and durable should take a look at the made-to-order ZPacks Challenger Ultralight Rain Jacket, which uses an exotic three-layer construction of eVent on the inside for breathability, protective nylon on the outside, and lightweight but super strong Dyneema threads sandwiched in the middle.

If you plan on skiing or snowboarding at a resort, consider an option like the Trew Cosmic or Stella, both of which offer a helmet-compatible hood and RECCO reflective inserts that bounce signals back to a corresponding receiver and help resort staff locate you under the snow in case of an avalanche. Do you expect to see equal parts wintertime and summertime activity with your shell? You may benefit from a detachable powder skirt, which will allow you to keep fresh snow out during the colder months and shed the excess weight during the warmer parts of the year. Planning on wearing waterproof hand protection along with your jacket? Be sure the adjustable wrist cuffs on your jacket are wide enough to accommodate your gloves or mittens.

Emerging Tech

Scientists want to bore holes through clouds using lasers from satellites

Researchers at the University of Geneva in Switzerland have proposed a plan to use ultra-hot and ultra-short laser beams to punch through cloud layers and transmit information from satellites to Earth.

A strap for everyone: The best Apple Watch bands you can buy right now

If you have an Apple Watch, you know how easy it is to take off the strap it came with, so why not buy yourself another one? Here we've gathered the best Apple Watch bands we've seen so far and there's something for everyone.

Keep your new Google phone pixel perfect with the best Pixel 3 cases

If you want your new Google phone to stay pixel perfect, then you should snag one of the best Pixel 3 cases. We've scoped out some of your best options so far based on different styles, levels of protection, and budgets.

Sleep comfortably under the stars in one of the best tents

An essential piece of gear whether you're camping in your backyard or on a multi-day backpacking trip, here are our picks of the best tents currently on the market from car camping varieties to the best three-person option.

These zip-on bike tires change up your tread to match the terrain

Retyre gives cyclists the ability to change the tread on their bike tires simply by zipping on an overlay designed to provide better grip on trails or in the snow, without replacing the existing tires.

From filters to mounts, these 16 GoPro accessories help you shoot all the action

A GoPro is only as good as the tools you use with it. Here, we've rounded up the best GoPro accessories currently available, from rotating time-lapse mounts to a wearable camera harness for your best friend.
Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: DIY smartphones and zip-on bike tires

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!
Product Review

Withings Steel HR Sport is a fitness tracker you’ll love wearing

Withings jumps back in the wearables game with the new Steel HR Sport, a hybrid smartwatch that is as much a fitness tracker as it is a timepiece. It's so good that it hasn't left our wrist since we pulled it out of the package.

Here are all the best rain jackets on the market right now

Spring is here which means it's officially raincoat season. From high-tech, lightweight shells to modern-looking, waterproof trench coats, check out our list of the best rain jackets built to keep you dry.

Garmin’s new Instinct GPS watch is built for the sportsman in all of us

The new Garmin Instinct is a GPS multisport watch for people who love to be outdoors. The $300 Instinct takes the best features of the company's popular Fenix watches and packages them into rugged, military-grade package.

Our favorite fitness trackers make it fun to keep moving

Looking for your first fitness tracker, or an upgrade to the one you're already wearing? There are plenty of the wrist-worn gadgets available. Here are our picks for the best fitness trackers available right now.

The Wau stands out in the crowded ebike market with its 60-mile range

The Wau ebike is a high-tech commuter that offers onboard GPS tracking, geofenced alarm systems, built-in front and rear lights, and pedal-assist speeds of up to 20 mph, with a range of as much as 60 miles between charges.
Emerging Tech

Here’s all the best gear and gadgetry you can snag for $100 or less

A $100 bill can get you further than you might think -- so long as you know where to look. Check out our picks for the best tech under $100, whether you're in the market for headphones or a virtual-reality headset.
Smart Home

These awesome treehouses will make you question life on solid ground

Check out these truly awesome treehouses from around the world. From a three-story treehouse in the Costa Rican jungle to a mirrored cube hidden among the trees of Sweden, we’ve got you covered.