Web

The Digital Self: Can the 4th Amendment fit in 140 characters?

The Digital Self Can the 4th Amendment fit in 140 characters

As the media continues to lather itself into a frothy frenzy over Edward Snowden, the now famous and infamous leaker of classified National Security Administration surveillance operations, it is important to remember that it is us, the people, for whom this ongoing story matters most. It is a story about both technology and law, and the unholy nether region where the two cross paths. And it is this aspect of this wild tale that we need to focus on most – even if the legal mumbo jumbo makes us want to spend a whole day browsing BuzzFeed.

The legal debate surrounding the NSA’s PRISM surveillance program boils down to this: Supporters of the programs in the U.S. government say the gathering of data on citizens and foreigners is completely legal. Opponents say it may be legal – but it’s not constitutional.

This disconnect between our hopes and cynicism helps create the perfect wiggle room for “legal” dragnet surveillance.

This is an important distinction. The U.S. Constitution is, of course, the ultimate law of the land – the document on which all our laws are based, and by which they must abide. It’s entirely possible that the laws directly governing PRISM – the FISA Amendments Act and the Patriot Act – are unconstitutional, or are being used to justify unconstitutional activities, in which case the “it’s legal” argument means little. (Because these laws are interpreted by a secret court, nobody this side of top secret clearance can say so with certainty.) This is the premise on which some legal experts condemn NSA spying activities.

“The National Security Agency’s recently revealed surveillance programs undermine the purpose of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, which was established to prevent this kind of overreach,” writes Georgetown University law professor Laura K. Donohue in the Washington Post. “They violate the Fourth Amendment’s guarantee against unreasonable search and seizure.”

So what, exactly, constitutes “unreasonable searches and seizures” in this age of Facebook status updates and tweets? The answer, if you can even call it that, is far more complicated than you might think.

First, some background: “Analysis of a Fourth Amendment issue is typically based on two questions: (1) did a search or seizure occur? and (2) was the government action reasonable under the circumstances?” explains Alan Butler, Appellate Advocacy Counsel for the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) and an expert on digital Fourth Amendment issues. For a “search” to occur, the person being searched must have a “reasonable expectation of privacy” – reasonable to her or him, and reasonable to society as a whole – in which case law enforcement must obtain a warrant or consent to search before snagging whatever it is they want to snag.

However, a pair of profound court decisions from the 1970s – Smith v. Maryland and United States v. Miller – established what’s now known as the “third party doctrine,” which made it perfectly reasonable for Johnny Law to grab telephone records and some bank documents without a warrant “because the individuals had no ‘reasonable expectation of privacy’ in records held by third parties,” says Butler. This is the reason the NSA can collect all Verzion’s phone records without court approval.

“Law enforcement has taken the position that once an item is ‘shared,’ the user has no reasonable expectation of privacy.”

The good news for privacy hawks is that this “third party doctrine” has come under increased scrutiny, most notably by Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor in the recent United States v. Jones decision. And the seizure of telephone conversations, letters sent through the U.S. Postal Service, and even emails (that are less than six months old) all enjoy firm protections under the Fourth Amendment, courts have ruled. But social media? Well, that’s a whole other beast.

“Social media presents a number of interesting and unique Fourth Amendment issues that courts are only beginning to address,” says Butler. “One important question in this area is whether social media content is protected by the Fourth Amendment at all.”

For now, the courts have failed to fully answer this question, leaving law enforcement with ample leeway to go after a variety of data, including Facebook status updates, tweets, and other forms of social media communications.

“So far, law enforcement has taken the position that once an item is ‘shared,’ the user has no reasonable expectation of privacy and the Fourth Amendment doesn’t apply,” says Butler. “But, the Department of Justice acknowledges that the contents of e-mails and other electronic communications are protected by the Fourth Amendment even though they might be ‘held’ by third parties. Courts are still divided, as there is not yet clear guidance on this issue.”

In short, the jury is still out on what “searches and seizures” means with regards to social media. But what about the “unreasonable” part of the Fourth Amendment? That too has its complications.

In a 2012 Congressional Research Service report (pdf), attorney Richard M. Thompson II explains how our changing view of privacy and technology affects the Fourth Amendment. He’s writing here about domestic drone surveillance, but it applies equally to social media, Google Glass, or any other technology that becomes ingrained into modern life.

“The touchstone of the Fourth Amendment is reasonableness,” writes Thompson. “A reviewing court’s determination of the reasonableness of a drone search would likely be informed by … society’s conception of privacy in an age of rapid technological advancement.”

It is our rapidly evolving “conception of privacy in an age of rapid technological advancement” that makes interpreting the Fourth Amendment infinitely more difficult. We collectively share an unprecedented amount about our lives on the public Web; we even know instinctively that government agencies like the NSA have access to what we do online – a fact that, even alone, muddles what kind of privacy we truly expect. And yet, we continue to fret over Facebook privacy settings and Instagram terms of service. We install AdBlock Plus and sign up for VPNs. We strive for privacy, for control of our data, but expect none of it. This disconnect between our hopes and cynicism helps create the perfect wiggle room for “legal” dragnet surveillance.

The dangers inherent in our changing expectations of privacy are “something I bring up a lot to explain why being vigilant about privacy is important,” says Sarah Downey, an attorney and privacy analyst for anti-tracking software company Abine.

“If American society gets complacent about things like widespread sharing of restricted information, NSA spying, and corporate data collection, we weaken our constitutional protections against privacy invasions and searches,” she says. In other words, the very act of sharing parts of your life online, or agreeing to hand over your data recklessly, potentially weakens the constitutional protections awarded to us all.

Going forward, “courts will be forced to update their Fourth Amendment analysis to adjust for new technologies,” says Butler. Hopefully, he says, “widespread use of Internet storage and services will force courts to reconsider the antiquated notion that all records held by third parties are subject to government inspection without regard for the Fourth Amendment.”

If not, we will all be forced to rely on Congress to “prevent the erosion of our basic Fourth Amendment rights under the new technological and economic models,” Butler says. Given the legal status of PRISM, we can all guess how that will turn out.

Now, where’s that BuzzFeed list?

Mobile

Amazon Prime Day 2019 will likely be on July 15, according to leaked email

It looks like we now have an idea of when Amazon Prime Day 2019 will be, thanks to a leaked email that was sent out to promote a vacuum cleaner deal for Prime Day. According to the email, the massive shopping event will take place on July…
Social Media

Here's how to unblock someone on Facebook when you've had a change of heart

Maybe you were a little too hasty blocking that one person on Facebook ... or maybe you just want to do a little spying to see what they're up to. Either way, you can fix the situation easily. Here's how to unblock someone on Facebook.
Music

The best free music download sites that are totally legal

Finding music that is both free and legal to download can be difficult. We've hand-picked a selection of the best free music download sites for you to legally download your next favorite album.
Computing

Dropbox’s all-new desktop app wants to be your one and only workspace

Dropbox has unveiled its most significant update yet as it continues to move away from its original core service as a place to store files in the cloud, toward a virtual workspace solution that offers all services in-app.
Social Media

Here's how to link your Instagram, Facebook accounts for social syncing

Instagram and Facebook go hand in hand. Here's how you can make the most of the superior integration offered by the two social media behemoths, which should help your pics gain more exposure in the long run.
Outdoors

For $5,000, Airbnb will take you around the world in 80 days. Airfare included

Airbnb's new Adventures allow travelers can book a mix of accommodations, food, and experiences in what Airbnb calls "bucket list" worthy trips, including a round-the-world trip for just $5,000
Smart Home

Walmart Grocery challenges Amazon with a new $98-a-year delivery option

The grocery delivery wars are hotting up. Walmart's latest effort is a $98-a-year subscription fee that offers free delivery on orders over $30. The service, called Delivery Unlimited, can be tried free for 15 days.
Home Theater

Netflix can drain your data in a hurry. Here's how to turn it down a notch

Ever wondered how much data you need to stream a show (or movie) on Netflix? You aren't alone. The answer could be anywhere from 1GB per hour to 7GB per hour, but there's more to it than that. Here's how to control your Netflix data.
Small Business

The 15 best tech jobs boast top salaries, high satisfaction, lots of openings

May may be coming to an end, but the bonanza of tech jobs just keeps coming. High-paying jobs abound at companies where people love to work. If you’re ready to make a change, this is a great time to look for something more fulfilling…
Mobile

American Airlines expands its fast in-flight Wi-Fi, but it will still cost you

American Airlines has completed the installation of satellite-based in-flight Wi-Fi for the whole of its mainline narrowbody fleet comprising more than 700 planes, mainly on its domestic routes. But the service still costs.
Computing

Genius uses 19th-century tech to prove Google copied its song lyrics

Song lyrics website Genius says that it proved that Google has been copying its lyrics and posting them on its own search results page. And Genius says it was able to do it by using a decidedly old-school form communications tech.
Photography

Adobe concocts an A.I. that can detect — and reverse — manipulated photos

The company behind the software that's often used to manipulate photographs may help make it easy to spot a fake photo. Researchers at Adobe recently created an artificially intelligent program that can recognize fake photos of faces.
Computing

Facebook’s crypto isn’t a new Bitcoin, it’s Disney Dollars for a new world order

Facebook has already secured tens of millions in investments for its new cryptocurrency for Facebook known as Libra. The platform is still being developed, but has already brought in backing from Visa, Mastercard and PayPal.
Computing

What is Libra? Here’s what you need to know about Facebook’s new cryptocurrency

Facebook released a white paper announcing its new cryptocurrency, Libra, which it intends as a way to enable more people around the world to process online payments. Here's how the new blockchain technology works.