Skip to main content

Bills aimed at making Tesla dealerships illegal in New York on hold; battle has likely just begun

Tesla Model S DealershipA pair of bills being considered in New York aimed at making it illegal for Tesla to sell vehicles “the Tesla way” in the state now appear to be hold.

Well, at least for the moment.

While the bills don’t specifically name Tesla, they would essentially prohibit any car manufacturer from selling a vehicle in New York without a third party or essentially a dealership, according to Green Car Reports.

The legislation would also make it illegal to renew the license of a current store that does fit that bill, which threatens both current and futures stores operated by the California-based electric car company. 

Unlike the traditional dealership system where carmakers sell their cars through an affiliated but independently owned dealership network, Tesla operates more like Apple Computer, with showroom stores (above) that allow customers to test drive a car before buying the vehicle online directly from Tesla at a set price.  

Tesla’s official website currently lists three stores in the state of New York including one in Roosevelt Field, Garden City; New York City and Westchester, White Plains.

The opposing legislation, which is being backed by New York State auto dealers, has reportedly been set aside in the New York State assembly, which doesn’t convene until January.

But the battleground has already been laid, and the issue isn’t likely to just go away.

Green Car reports, on Friday, Tesla CEO Elon Musk tweeted, “NY Assembly passing bill to shut down Tesla, but Senate holding the line. Appreciate senators resisting influence of auto dealer lobby.”

According to the news source, a letter directed to New York legislators urging them to pass the legislation, is supported by the Alliance of Automotive Manufacturers, the Global Alliance of Manufacturers as well as all of the New York State Dealer Associations.

Tesla has faced a similar fight in North Carolina, fueled by dealer associations for what’s being called “unfair competition,” according to a Slate report.   

Whether Telsa will be able to weather that kind of storm remains to be seen, but neither party is likely to back down without a fight.

Photo Source: Car Scoops

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Marcus Amick
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Marcus Amick has been writing about the world of cars for more than ten years and has covered everything from new automobiles…
Rivian R2 vs R1S: How will Rivian’s cheaper SUV compare?
The front three-quarter view of a 2022 Rivian against a rocky backdrop.

Rivian has finally unveiled the R2, its long-awaited attempt at a more affordable electric SUV. The new vehicle may not be available just yet, but fans of Rivian's design aesthetics and feature set are already looking forward to being able to order the new car. The R2 is targeted at being a more affordable take on the electric SUV and will sit alongside the flagship-tier R1S.

Let's get this out of the way right now: The R1S is most likely going to be a better vehicle than the R2. Rivian isn't replacing the R1S with the R2 — it's releasing the R2 as a more affordable alternative, and there will be some compromises when buying the R2 over the R1S.

Read more
Cybertruck production reportedly halted over pedal issue
Tesla CEO Elon Musk behind the wheel of a Cybertruck.

Tesla CEO Elon Musk behind the wheel of a Cybertruck. Tesla

Tesla’s Cybertruck has been hit by a production delay caused by an issue with a part of the vehicle, a number of media reports have claimed.

Read more
Don’t let the gimmicks fool you. The Ioniq 5 N is a serious track car
2025 Hyundai Ioniq 5 N drifting.

We’re finally getting to the fun part of automakers’ methodical quest to replicate their lineups with electric cars.

Performance versions of ordinary cars have been a staple of the auto industry for decades. But while we’ve already seen some variants of EVs boasting more power and more impressive stats — think Tesla Model S Plaid or Lucid Air Sapphire — the 2025 Hyundai Ioniq 5 N is the first to truly apply that format to an EV.

Read more