Skip to main content

TiVo Sues AT&T, Verizon for DVR Patent Violations

Tivo
Tivo Image used with permission by copyright holder

DVR pioneer TiVo has been in a long-running dispute with Echostar regarding its core DVR technology…and while the case seemed to be tilting in TiVo’s favor, Echostar recently saw a glimmer of hope in a preliminary ruling that declared the patent invalid. TiVo doesn’t seem to worried about the possibility its patents might be set aside, however: the company has just filed suits against AT&T and Verizon for infringing on three of its DVR technology patents, including the famous “time warp” technology.

As in the Echostar case, TiVo is seeking damages for past infringement and a permanent injunction that would bar the communications companies from offering products that infringe on TiVo’s patents. The suits were filed in the infamously patent-holder-friendly Eastern District of Texas.

“We will continue to pursue enforcement where necessary to stop infringement of our intellectual property,” TiVo CEO Tom Rogers said in a statement. TiVo has apparently been in negotiations with both AT&T and Verizon about licensing the DVR technology, but no agreements have been reached, and TiVo apparently feels it has no alternative but to take the companies to court.

Neither Verizon nor AT&T have publicly commended on the suits.

Editors' Recommendations

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Best TCL TV deals: 4K TVs as low as $150
TCL's 5-Series 4K QLED Google TV.

The best TV brands make a number of TVs at different price points, and whether they utilize QLED or OLED technology, they almost universally produce an high quality image. One problem with shopping some of the more traditionally-known TV brands can be the cost. TCL, however, offers picture quality and affordability among its TV. When you shop TCL TV deals you can save even more, as TCL TVs are frequently found among the best TV deals taking place. It’s a good time to turn to TCL for your home theater, as there are a lot of TCL TV deals to choose from. We’ve rounded up the best TCL TV deals below, so read onward for pricing and links.
Today’s best TCL TV deals

TCL 40-inch 3-Series 1080p HD TV —
TCL 50-inch 4-Series 4K TV —
TCL 55-inch 4-Series 4K TV —
TCL 55-inch Q6-Series 4K QLED TV —
TCL 65-inch S-Series 4K TV —
TCL 55-inch Q7 4K QLED TV --
TCL 75-inch S-Series 4K TV —
TCL 65-inch Q7-Series 4K QLED TV —
TCL 85-inch S-Series 4K TV —
TCL 65-inch QM8 4K QLED TV --
TCL 98-inch S5 4K TV --

Read more
Best headphone deals: AirPods, Sony, Sennheiser and more
Beats Studio Pro sitting on travel case.

Whether music or movies, TV shows or sports events, a new set of headphones is a great way to get into your favorite content. And whether you’ve been shopping TV deals, gaming console deals, phone deals, or tablet deals, landing a discount on a great sound of headphones can pair nicely with any of your other devices. There are a lot of headphone deals out there, and they include discounts on brands like Apple, Sony, and Sennheiser, among others. We’ve rounded up all of the best headphone deals you can shop right now, so whether you’re in the market for a set of wireless earbuds or noise-canceling headphones, read onward for details on how to save.
Apple AirPods 2 -- $89, was $129

Apple has long been known for making premium tech products that please the eye aesthetically and produce a simple yet impactful user experience. This is true of the Apple AirPods 2, which, despite being a few years removed from their original release, still hold up as a great set of wireless earbuds. Just like their newer iteration, the Apple AirPods 3, the AirPods 2 produce high quality audio that pack a punch whether you’re playing games, listening to music, watching movies, or relaxing with a podcast. It has an H1 chip that delivers a stable wireless connection, and manages to produce high-quality sound far better than many other wireless headphones. Battery life is about as good as it gets, with the AirPods 2 offering up to five hours of listening time on one charge, and more than 24 hours with the included charging case.

Read more
How to tell if your AirPods are fake. Yes, counterfeits are out there
The third-generation Apple AirPods, outside of their charging case.

Apple AirPods are incredibly popular, whether you're the proud owner of the latest AirPods Pro 2, AirPods (3rd generation), or AirPods Max, or even some of the ubiquitous brand's older models. Unfortunately, there are many counterfeit AirPods circulating. Fortunately, you can do a few things to ensure you have genuine AirPods before or after purchase.

Read more