Skip to main content

Apple marketing VP Phil Schiller responds to backlash over MacBook Pro design

2016 macbook pro touch bar supported apps v2
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Apple’s refreshed MacBook Pro line offers a thinner, lighter, and somewhat touch-sensitive vision of the MacOS flagship machines that has left many longtime Mac users a bit underwhelmed. The new line adds the Touch Bar as a new app-specific interface and Touch ID support, both of which were welcome, but last year’s Skylake processors and some other compromises weren’t so well-received.

Apple executives aren’t oblivious to those concerns, and they didn’t develop the new MacBook Pro machines in a vacuum. There were conscious decisions made about each and every aspect of their design, and Apple Vice President of Worldwide Marketing Phil Schiller spent some time talking to the Independent about those decisions and the concerns voiced by Apple customers.

When asked about all of the noise surrounding the new machines, Schiller said, “There has certainly been a lot of passionate dialogue and debate about the new MacBook Pro. Many things have impressed people about it, and some have caused some controversy. I hope everyone gets a chance to try it for themselves and see how great the MacBook Pro is. It is a really big step forward and an example of how much we continue to invest in the Mac. We love the Mac and are as committed to it, in both desktops and notebooks, as we ever have been.”

Of course, that’s what Apple would say, no matter the response to the MacBook. Apple isn’t shy about making controversial and unpopular decisions, an example of which is the removal of the headphone jack from the recently released iPhone 7. But has the strength of the negative reaction surprised Schiller? Apparently so — at least a little bit: “To be fair, it has been a bit of a surprise to me. But then, it shouldn’t be. I have never seen a great new Apple product that didn’t have its share of early criticism and debate — and that’s cool. We took a bold risk, and, of course, with every step forward there is also some change to deal with. Our customers are so passionate, which is amazing.”

While it’s possible to argue that some of the design choices were poor, like making the notebooks so incredibly thin at the expense of expandability and battery life, some might make sense when you consider the bigger picture. For example, Schiller justifies retaining the 3.5mm headphone jack in the MacBook Pro because the machines don’t connect only to headphones. They’re professional-grade machines that need to be connect edto audio gear like studio monitors and amps that don’t currently have any other way to connect.

Another change that wasn’t well-received by MacBook fans but that did yield an explanation from Schiller is the removal of the SD card slot from the MacBook Pro. According to the Apple exec, the slot is cumbersome and limits the options for users — why not CompactFlash, for example? — and there are also more cameras providing wireless transfer in any event. It’s better, says Schiller, to use a USB card reader that provides good performance along with supporting other formats.

Some of Schiller’s accounting might not add up so neatly. For example, he says that Siri in MacOS doesn’t support invoking by voice (“Hey Siri”) because that would require different electronics and wouldn’t be supported when a machine is asleep. Of course, Windows 10’s Cortana supports “Hey Cortana” functionality that works well with a wide variety of machines, and so while the lack of sleep responsiveness is a valid concern with PCs, generally speaking, Schiller’s answer might fall a little flat for some.

Schiller also covers the development of the Touch Bar, which he considers a natural progression of the platform. He also touts the new MacBook Pro’s thinness and lightness as being the result of some advances in engineering. In the end, the entire interview provides a nice look into the minds of Apple executives in demonstrating how such an iconic product can be so dramatically altered in spite of the potential for customer backlash.

Editors' Recommendations

Mark Coppock
Mark has been a geek since MS-DOS gave way to Windows and the PalmPilot was a thing. He’s translated his love for…
The 6 best ways Macs work with your other Apple devices
A person holds an iPhone in front of a MacBook.

One of the best things about using more than one Apple device is the way they interact with each other. Apple has built all kinds of clever features into its famous ecosystem, and it means your devices all work together in a way that you just don’t get from any other manufacturer.

AirDrop might be the ultimate expression of this, though that's fairly well-known. Here, we’ve picked out six other great ways your Mac works with other Apple products. Most require you to have Bluetooth and Wi-Fi enabled, as well as for you to be using the same Apple ID on all your devices. Check the System Settings app on your devices to make sure the specific features are enabled, although most should be by default.

Read more
Another excellent laptop challenges the MacBook Pro and falls short
The keyboard and trackpad of the MacBook Pro.

The MacBook Pro 16 remains undefeated as the best 16-inch laptop you can buy. From the incredible battery life to the impressive performance, the M3 Max MacBook Pro has become an unstoppable force.

Still, plenty of competitors have come along to potentially challenge it, and when I came across the updated HP Spectre x360 16, I wondered if it might make a worthy rival. As impressive as it is, though, it still doesn't have what it takes to dethrone the MacBook Pro.
Specs and configurations

Read more
Why one of my favorite laptops still struggles against the MacBook Pro
HP Spectre x360 14 2023 front angled view showing display and keyboard.

HP released an updated version of its premier consumer laptop, the excellent Spectre x360 14, and it remains one of the best 2-in-1s you can buy. It's well-made, offers a ton of flexibility, and is one of my favorite laptops I've reviewed.

But it's going up against the Apple MacBook Pro 14, which sits alongside the HP on our list of best laptops. When it comes to laptops that are both portable and powerful, though, the Spectre x360 still falls behind the MacBook Pro in some important ways.
Specs and configurations

Read more