First drive: 2016 Mini Cooper Clubman S

The biggest Mini to date is a contradiction, but not a disappointment

The steady march of the Mini brand away from its original diminutive philosophy takes its most deliberate step yet with the latest Clubman, a model which the company isn’t shy about labeling the biggest Mini to date. At 3,300 pounds it’s no longer a featherweight, and with dimensions that are nearly identical for a four-door Golf, it’s not all that miniature, either.

Instead, this Mini is geared toward practically, utility and a rich feature set. While the classic Mini traits of spritely, engaging performance and quirky design still exist here, as the company’s design focus continues to evolve with the market, it’s not surprising to discover that they’re largely relegated to the periphery now.

It isn’t so much an indicator of an identity crisis as it is a purposeful shift toward the priorities of Mini’s customer base, who today are more likely to head to yoga class than the autocross. So it’s through that lens that one must look at the 2016 Cooper S Clubman, a Mini which casts its net far wider than its core fanbase in hopes of reeling in a number of Mazda3, Ford Focus and VW Golf Sportwagen converts along the way.

Maximum Mini

The 2016 Clubman sees substantial design changes over the previous generation model, ones which address some key points of contention with its predecessor. Gone is the single “club” door that provided access to the rear seats, replaced by two normally hinged, grown-up sized doors to make ingress and egress a far easier task for rear seat passengers.

The Cooper S Clubman places comfort above corner carving.

Interior room for those passengers has improved substantially as well, as the new Clubman has increased in overall length to 168.3 inches and body has been widened by three inches. But while this may be the largest Mini ever built, it’s still nearly a foot shorter in overall length than a VW Golf Sportwagen, putting it within half an inch of the standard four-door Golf’s length. The result is a Mini that maintains a reasonably small footprint while providing significantly more breathing room on the inside.

Of course there’s a give and take when it comes to vehicle growth, and in the case of the Cooper S Clubman, out on the road it translates to a driving experience that is less go-kart and more grand tourer. Sure, there’s a Sport button, three pedals on the floor and a turbocharger under the hood, but the Cooper S Clubman has clearly been tuned more for comfort than corner carving.

In comparison to the Mini Hardtop, the Clubman’s suspension tuning is noticeably softer, with body roll and brake dive quickly beginning becoming evident on demanding roads. Likewise, the Clubman’s steering feels more relaxed as well, with an electrically assisted setup that is easy to pilot but lower on feedback than some Mini loyalists might hope for, and enthusiastic drivers will likely find themselves pushing deeper into the brake pedal that they might expect to in order to reign in this big Mini at speed. But despite these concessions to commuting comfort, the Cooper S Clubman is still notably more driver-focused than most of its direct competition, even if it has given up a step or two for sake of wider appeal.

Under the hood is a turbocharged 2.0-liter four cylinder motor that generates 189 horsepower and 207 pound-feet of torque, which is mated to either a six-speed manual gearbox or an eight speed automatic. While it doesn’t push the Cooper S Clubman with the same level of urgency as does in the Cooper S Hardtop, the Clubman is still capable of getting to 60 mph in a brisk 6.9 seconds, and the gearing of my six speed-equipped tester made weaving through freeway traffic a fairly effortless proposition in practice.

Yet it’s clear that the Clubman does its best work when it is asked to provide some reprieve from the outside world. The cabin’s well thought out ergonomics places everything where your body expects it to be, yielding a relaxed driving position that’s ideally suited to long stints behind the wheel, and the Clubman’s BMW-like isolation from road noise helps to bolster the Mini’s premium vibe.

Potentially very, very well equipped

While the Clubman S starts at $27,650 before destination, it doesn’t take a shopping spree on the options sheet to send the price tag into $40,000 range, as the handful my test car was equipped with (which notably did not include the available adaptive suspension dampers – an upgrade I would recommend) rung up an even $37,000 all in.

The Clubman does its best work when asked to provide a reprieve from the outside world.

That changes the Clubman’s story a bit, but then again, how often do you find heads-up displays, panoramic sun roofs, and LED headlights on the options sheet for a compact wagon?

And to its credit, the iDrive-like infotainment system with navigation and 6.5-inch display comes as standard, as does the vast majority of the Clubman’s “Mininess,” like the adjustable, mutli-colored ambient lighting placed throughout the cabin, the two-tone exterior paintwork, and well-bolstered sport seats.

Playing to your audience

The Clubman’s newfound maturity might make this big Mini a more compelling option among its competitive set, but it’s the brand’s aesthetic that will likely do the most to lure potential buyers away from perceivably safer harbors.

While purists might find frustration in the company’s change in priorities – one which increasingly relies on the perception of performance while focusing instead on ease-of-use – it’s hard to deny that the logic is sound. The new Clubman, like most of the rest of the current Mini lineup, will likely find favor with buyers looking for more personality than the alternatives offer — but would prefer to forego the potential drawbacks in comfort and convenience that are inherent to high performance tuning, diminutive proportions, and quirkiness.

And the plan seems to be working: The more the brand moves away from its toy-like reputation, the better the cars sell, so clearly the public has made its desires heard. With the 2016 Clubman, Mini takes its most deliberate step yet toward mainstream appeal, and while the result may not fully resonate with those looking for a driver’s car, it has the potential to turn a lot more commuters into drivers, and I certainly take no issue with that.


  • Stylish Mini design cues
  • Redesign yields two full-sized rear passenger doors and more interior space
  • DNA from BMW provides a premium feel


  • Softer than expected handling
  • Underwhelming braking performance
  • Price tag jumps up quickly with additional options
Product Review

By adding features, tech, and all-wheel drive, Mazda puts the 3 in a class of one

Since its introduction in 2003, Mazda’s compact Mazda3 has been a mainstay of the brand’s driver-oriented strategy. Mazda now plans to move upmarket, and the all-new 2019 Mazda3 offers some clues about how that’s going to work.
Product Review

2019 Volkswagen Jetta offers German refinement and tech at an affordable price

With enough tech to make villains jealous, the Volkswagen Jetta punches above its class as a forward-thinking sedan. Spacious, comfortable, and efficient, the Jetta is a refined offering. German refinement comes with a serious attitude.
Product Review

The Ferrari Portofino is the super stallion you’ll want to drive every day

With the introduction of the Portofino, Ferrari addresses the California T’s stylistic shortcomings while improving comfort, convenience, and performance. There’s little “entry-level” about this super stallion.
Product Review

Who needs a Range Rover? BMW’s X7 has better tech and just as much luxury

The 2019 BMW X7 is the German automaker’s long-overdue entry into the full-size luxury SUV segment. Packing three rows of seats and plenty of tech, can the new BMW take on Mercedes-Benz and Land Rover?

Protect yourself and your ride with our favorite dash cams

Dashboard cameras can assist drivers in car accident claims, settle speeding ticket disputes, and even catch glimpses of incoming meteors, among other things. Here, we've compiled a list of the most noteworthy offerings available.

Tesla revives its referral program with chances to win a Roadster

Tesla has revived its referral program that ended in February because of cost pressures. This time around the perks aren't quite as diverse, though it does offer regular chances to win a Roadster or Model Y.

From cars to computers: How data is transforming F1 racing

After a single weekend of racing, a Formula 1 pit crew typically pulls around 2TB of data from the car. Everything, from tire pressure to the temperature of the track, is recorded and analyzed in the name of boosting performance -- and not…

Tesla ends scheduled servicing because electric cars need less maintenance

Tesla will longer offer scheduled maintenance plans, switching to an "as needed" model. This reflects the fact that electric cars need less regular maintenance than gasoline or diesel cars.

The go kart-like Mini Cooper will soon add zero emissions to its resume

Mini is in the final stages of developing an electric version of the Cooper. The 2020 Cooper SE will receive powertrain components from the BMW i3, including a 181-horsepower electric motor and battery technology.
Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: Robotic companions and computer-aided karaoke

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it's fun to gawk!

Tesla Model 3 vulnerability exposed at Pwn2Own; hackers take home the car

A Tesla Model 3 vulnerability was exposed at the Pwn2Own hacking competition. The hackers, who were able to display a message on the electric vehicle's internet browser, won $35,000 and took home the car.

Is this electric car startup the next Tesla, or will it go the way of Coda?

The electric car startup formerly known as EVelozcity has changed its name to Canoo. It also announced a lineup of four cars including a commuter-friendly model and a lifestyle-oriented car. Its first electric vehicles will begin to appear…

Ford’s born-again Bronco off-roader will soothe your 1990s nostalgia

Ford confirmed it will bring the Bronco back to American showrooms in 2020. We haven't seen the truck yet, but dealers who got a preview of it during a private event say it's a true off-roader aimed directly at the Jeep Wrangler.

Recall bounty hunters needed as millions ignore deadly Takata airbag recall

It's the recall campaign from hell and too many people aren't responding. Toyota Motor North America (TMNA) and Carma Project want to give financial rewards to people who alert family and friends to the deadly Takata airbag recall.