Skip to main content

Stop talking to your car: Voice-activated systems shown to distract drivers

car voice activated systems cause distractions audi a7 autonomous hands free driving 1500x1000
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Cars don’t make for very good conversationalists, so you probably shouldn’t be talking to them while you’re driving. In fact, they’re so poor as conversationalists go that a new study suggests the voice-activated systems that many vehicles tout as your smart interaction system are distracting drivers from the road, and potentially causing accidents in the meantime. According to Thursday’s results from the American Automobile Association, the “mental workload” associated with talking to your car is “surprisingly high,” significantly more so than talking to an actual human being, and about as high sending a text or an email.

While voice-activated systems are heralded by several companies as the safe alternative to interacting with your smartphone while on the road, the latest research suggests that this is far from accurate. With some of the most complicated systems, like those found in the Mazda 6, the Hyundai Sonata, or the Chrysler 200C, drivers remained distracted for up to 27 seconds after they ended their conversations with their cars. Even less complex systems resulted in long-tail attention deficits of up to 15 seconds — not great for reacting to sudden changes or dangerous roadway conditions.

1-upto27second
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The study, which involved 257 drivers, ages 21 to 70, used 10 different 2015 model cars to “assess cognitive workload” of the drivers in the vehicles. All participants were given five days to practice and familiarize themselves with the cars and their voice systems before being tested on the resulting effects of their car interactions on their driving. Ultimately, says AAA Chief Executive Peter Kissinger, “the lasting effects of mental distraction pose a hidden and pervasive danger that would likely come as a surprise to most drivers.”

David Strayer, a neuroscientist at the University of Utah who led the research, compared controlling a car’s “smart” system to “balancing a checkbook while driving.”

“When you hang up, you have to figure out where you are, how fast you’re going, where other vehicles are,” he explained. And this mental recalibration not only takes time, but is potentially dangerous to do mid-road.

And it’s not just the systems in your car that are proving to be problematic — the research also suggests that smartphone systems like Microsoft’s Cortana, Apple’s Siri, and Google Now are distracting for drivers, so just because you’re hands-free doesn’t mean you’re mind-free too. The concern, researchers note, is that “with the explosive growth in technology, the problem of driver distraction is poised to become much more acute.”

Editors' Recommendations

Lulu Chang
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Fascinated by the effects of technology on human interaction, Lulu believes that if her parents can use your new app…
Waymo is now running autonomous car trips without backup drivers
waymo orders thousands of chrysler pacifica minivans self driving car softens in pedestrian collison

Riders using Waymo’s robo-taxi service in Arizona are now taking trips in vehicles without backup drivers.

In an email sent recently to its rider community, the Alphabet-owned company said passengers will be notified via the Waymo app if it sends them a fully driverless car in response to a ride request. Waymo CEO John Krafcik subsequently confirmed to a group of reporters that so-called "rider only" trips had begun in the Phoenix, Arizona, area, according to Reuters.

Read more
Waymo asks the government to stop requiring steering wheels for autonomous cars
waymo orders thousands of chrysler pacifica minivans self driving car softens in pedestrian collison

Waymo wants a future without steering wheels. The unit of Google parent Alphabet doesn't believe its self-driving cars need them, and it just asked the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) to "promptly" remove requirements for steering wheels, as well as brake pedals, reports Reuters.

Companies must currently meet 75 safety requirements for self-driving cars, but many of them were written under the assumption that a human driver will still be at the controls, according to Reuters. It's another important dimension of the push to take self-driving cars mainstream. As the technology develops, regulations will have to evolve with it. Waymo wants to speed up that process.

Read more
How selectable driving modes are able to turn your car from Dr Jekyll to Mr Hyde
selectable drive modes turn your car from commuter to racer driving 1

Let’s pretend for a moment that you’ve got an unlimited amount of money to buy any vehicle you want, but just one. Do you buy a Bugatti Chiron, with back-breaking acceleration, laser-sharp handling, and a legendary top speed? Or do you buy a Ford Raptor and jump sand dunes all day long? The odds are great that you’d be happy with either of those vehicles for a while, but that everyday life would eventually come knocking and you’d be left pining for something more practical to haul the kids around, or even just park in a normal parking garage.

This is where selectable driving modes and technology come into play. No, they’re not going to turn your Toyota Sienna into a Ferrari Portofino, but drive modes can dramatically change the way a vehicle feels, performs, and even how it sounds. When done right, a vehicle with a proper sport mode can go from soccer practice with the kids to hot laps at a track day event with the flick of a switch – and hopefully a stop to drop off the kids somewhere in between.

Read more