Skip to main content

Car dealers association says people like price haggling, customers say ‘Nope’

prodigy car dealership sales platform colorful cars in a lot
welcomia / 123RF Stock Photo
If it were up to consumers, where would they prefer to buy a car? That is the question posed by the chairman of the National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA), Jeff Carlson, who answered his own question, saying consumers prefer the status quo conventional car dealer model, according to Electrek . A recent Harris Poll, suggests otherwise, that consumers are not satisfied with the traditional dealership model.

Carlson was addressing the Automotive Press Association. His opinion is consumers prefer traditional car dealers because they can haggle over prices and get discounts. He stated they prefer that method over Tesla Motor’s retail model where car prices are not negotiated.

Recommended Videos

The 2016 Beepi Consumer Automotive Index based on an online Harris Poll survey — admittedly conducted on behalf of a nontraditional car sales outlet —  surveyed 2,135 American adults about their feelings about buying cars through dealers. Of those polled, 61 percent believed they were taken advantage of at dealerships and 87 percent found one or more elements of car shopping at dealers they dislike. When it comes to negotiating, 24 percent said they would rather have a root canal than negotiate with a car dealer. Among parents with kids under 18, 80 percent “would rather do anything else unpleasant.”

Please enable Javascript to view this content

In Carlson’s presentation, he mentioned a 2015 Phoenix Center study that found consumers often receive discounts worth hundreds of dollars when buying new cars and that competition between dealers often results in lower prices.

The NADA and some of its associated state car dealer associations have successfully argued against Tesla’s direct sales, with no discount model in several states, including North Carolina and Michigan.

In Michigan, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) sided with Tesla, stating, “Absent some legitimate public purpose, consumers would be better served if the choice of distribution method were left to motor vehicle manufacturers and the consumers to whom they sell their products.” In July, 400 Tesla owners in Michigan banded together to give test rides to prospective Tesla buyers, who would then have to go out of state to buy and get service for a Tesla vehicle.

Bruce Brown
Bruce Brown Contributing Editor   As a Contributing Editor to the Auto teams at Digital Trends and TheManual.com, Bruce…
Honda unveils sleek electric sedan and SUV prototypes at CES 2025
Honda 0 Saloon and Honda 0 SUV prototypes.

Honda’s next-generation electric vehicles are a step closer to production. At CES 2025, the automaker unveiled prototypes of the 0 Saloon and 0 SUV, the first two of its 0 Series EVs that will start rolling off assembly lines in Ohio next year.

The two EVs follow 0 Series concept cars Honda unveiled at CES 2024. These are closer to what buyers can expect to see in showrooms, hence the label of “prototype” rather than “concept.” How close exactly? When Honda unveils a prototype, that vehicle generally makes the transition to production with minimal changes. But that would be particularly remarkable here.
They still look like concept cars

Read more
Digital Trends’ Top Tech of CES 2025 Awards
Top Tech of CES

Las Vegas is overrun. Every billboard in town is shouting about AI, hotel bar tops now sport a sea of laptops, and after hours The Strip is elbow to elbow with engineers toting yard-long beers.

That means CES, the year’s biggest tech bacchanalia, has come to town, and Digital Trends editors have spent the last four days frolicking among next year’s crop of incredible TVs, computers, tablets, and EVs. We’re in heaven.

Read more
Sony and Honda’s Afeela 1 EV makes more sense at CES than in the real world
Afeela 1 front quarter view.

The Sony car is almost here. After its creation via a joint venture with Honda in 2022 and two years’ worth of prototypes, the electronics giant’s Afeela brand is finally taking reservations for its first electric vehicle, with deliveries scheduled to start in 2026.

But will it be worth the wait? Coinciding with the opening of reservations, Sony Honda Mobility brought updated prototypes of the Afeela 1 (as it’s now officially known) to CES 2025, representing what California customers (Afeela is only taking reservations in that state) who put down a $200 refundable deposit can expect when they take delivery.

Read more