Study: THC blood tests not a reliable measure of marijuana impairment

2016 NHTSA Fatality Report
kadmy / 123RF Stock Photo
New research indicates that blood THC tests don’t work, with the level of impairment not showing a correlation to the level of THC present in a driver’s bloodstream. As a result, scientific, objective tests of marijuana impairment are needed fast. These blood THC test judgments come from a study by the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety, as reported by Ars Technica. THC, which is short for delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol, is the main psychoactive component of weed. The lack of accurate marijuana impairment tests is a growing problem bound to get bigger.

Marijuana-related traffic fatalities in Washington state increased from 8 percent in 2013 to 17 percent in 2014. Washington legalized marijuana for medical use in 2012. Like most statistics, this one can be seen in different ways. Although, the overall number of fatalities involving THC use increased, in most cases alcohol and/or other drugs were used as well. Regardless of how you slice and dice the numbers, however, the fact that blood THC levels did not accurately indicate marijuana impairment calls for new tests that will.

According to the AAA study, individuals who had very low levels of THC in their blood could act totally out of it while others who acted and seemed normal and unimpaired could have THC levels that were “off the charts.”

In the testing, the Foundation compared the results of the standard Drug Recognition Expert (DRE) tests administered to 349 volunteers with no THC in their blood and to 602 people who at the time of their arrests had only marijuana in their systems and who had their blood measured. The DRE roadside test includes walking a straight line and turning, standing on one foot, and touching your own nose. While 55.5 percent of the volunteers passed the walk and turn test, only 6 percent of the arrested people passed. So while it’s not 100 percent accurate, the DRE behavioral test does indicate impairment.

Next, the testers checked the THC blood levels of the arrested population. The levels ranged from 1 to 47 nanograms per millilitre of blood. While the nose-touching test showed some correlation with THC levels, the other elements of the DRE did not.

Several states are passing THC blood level laws to determine marijuana impairment. Colorado, Washington, and Montana have set a limit of 5 nanograms per millilitre as the legal limit and others may follow.

Not only did the researchers fail to find a clear correlation between those who failed the DRE test and THC limits, it also found that 30 percent of those who passed the test had THC levels of 1 ng/mL or higher. The Foundation stated, “Based on this analysis, a quantitative threshold for per se laws for THC following cannabis use cannot be scientifically supported.”

Driving while stoned is dangerous and with marijuana-related fatality rates increasing the Foundation suggests that, in the absence of accurate scientific tests, law enforcement use psychological and behavioral measures such as the DRE to determine fitness to drive. As things stand, relying on blood THC levels could allow some seriously wasted people to get back in their cars and drive away, a danger to themselves and others.

Emerging Tech

How pioneering pilot Jackie Cochran helped and hurt the Women in Space Program

Before Valentina Tereshkova became the first woman in space, Jackie Cochran funded the Women in Space Program. The pioneering woman pilot never realized her dream of venturing into space.
Smart Home

Eight Sleep's Pod bed cools, heats, and tracks sleep data for couples

The Pod bed by Eight Sleep measures data to determine a sleep fitness score. It also creates the ideal temperature environment to help you get better sleep. How does the Pod bed measure up?

Younger motorists may be banned from night driving in U.K. safety push

The U.K. is considering banning newly qualified motorists from driving at night in a bid to boost safety on its roads. Other measures could include banning passengers under a certain age from traveling with young drivers.
Home Theater

Is bigger really better? How to figure out what size TV you need

What size TV do you need? Here are a few tips for picking the right size, including where to find a TV’s measurements, ideal viewing distance, and picture quality versus size. Not sure what to look for? This guide is for you.

The last two affordable station wagons in America are about to retire

Volkswagen confirmed it will stop making the Golf Sportwagen and the Golf Alltrack by the end of 2019. Both station wagons are at the end of their life cycle, but they won't be replaced because they compete in a shrinking segment of the…

Formula E races aren’t just exciting, they’re driving EV tech into the future

Formula E made its annual trip to the Big Apple, showing just how far the all-electric racing series has come. The cars are faster, and the racing is closer, but the tailpipe emissions are still at zero.

How Lexus, one of the industry’s hybrid champions, is preparing for the 2020s

Lexus predicts significant shifts will reshape the automotive industry during the 2020s. The hybrid champion is preparing to branch out into electric cars, it's investing in autonomous technology, and it wants to keep focusing on SUVs.

Cadillac’s new 2020 CT5 sedan lets you Super Cruise across America

The 2020 Cadillac CT5 proves the General Motors-owned luxury brand still cares about sedans. Introduced at the 2019 New York Auto Show, it's optionally available with Cadillac's Super Cruise technology and a lineup of turbocharged engines.

Toyota’s futuristic golf cart will transport people around at the 2020 Olympics

Toyota is reinventing the golf cart for the 2020 Tokyo Olympic Games. The company designed a vehicle named the Accessible People Mover that will transport visitors, athletes, and staff members from venue to venue.

The 2020 Chevrolet Corvette arrives with supercar specs and a bargain price tag

Chevrolet completely reinvented the Corvette Stingray for the 2020 model year. While the first seven generations of the car came with a front-mounted engine, the eighth-generation model switches to a mid-engined layout.

The five key things we learned during the 2020 Chevrolet Corvette’s unveiling

Digital Trends attended the mid-engined, 2020 Chevrolet Corvette's unveiling in Los Angeles. Here are five important points that stood out to us after seeing the car in person, and chatting with the people who developed it.

Built-in coolers, tents, and kitchenettes make these the best cars for camping

For a successful camping trip, you’ll need a tent, s’mores, and some quality humans to share them with. A good car can transform the entire experience, though, so we’re counting down 15 of the best cars for camping.

Hooked on gas? Porsche is about to give you a good reason to go electric

Porsche's Mission E concept won't change much as it transitions to a production model named Taycan that's scheduled to arrive in 2019. That means the sedan will keep the sleek design and its 800-volt charging system.

The evolution of NASA’s moon buggy is even wilder than where it landed

In 1971, NASA launched the first car to go to the moon. They also sent astronauts to drive it. The further you dig into their design, the more amazing the rovers, which still reside on the moon, become.