Skip to main content

Apple fails to get lawsuit over its troublesome butterfly keyboard dismissed

Apple has failed in its effort to persuade a judge to dismiss a class-action lawsuit launched against the company in connection with the faulty “butterfly” keyboard that sold with some of its laptops.

The lawsuit, which was filed in May 2018, claims that a keyboard design that launched with MacBook and MacBook Pro laptops starting in 2015 (it doesn’t cover MacBook Air machines with the same issue) allowed dust and other debris to settle beneath the keys, causing them to stick or stop working altogether. While many keyboards can suffer similar issues over time, it’s been suggested that Apple’s keyboard had an inherent design flaw that resulted in a greater failure rate, which ultimately led to the class action lawsuit.

Despite Apple’s wish to have the lawsuit thrown out of court, U.S. District Judge Edward Davila in San Jose, California, said it should be allowed to proceed, Reuters reported. The decision means the tech giant will have to defend itself against a number of allegations, including that its troubleshooting program failed to provide an effective fix for the keyboard issue.

The lawsuit also accuses the company of failing to fully compensate customers for costs incurred while they went about arranging repairs for the faulty keyboard.

We’ve reached out to Apple for comment on the case and we will update this piece if we hear back.

Keyboard woes

Beginning with the launch of the MacBook in 2015, Apple replaced the traditional “scissor” key mechanism with the “butterfly” design as part of efforts to make the machine as slim as possible. MacBook Pro and MacBook Air updates over the following years included the same mechanism, but a growing number of complaints suggested there was something seriously wrong with the design.

In response, Apple launched a special webpage showing users how to resolve the issue by holding the laptop at 75 degrees before spraying compressed air at the malfunctioning keys. One angry owner even wrote a song about it to vent his frustrations.

In 2018, the company followed up with a repair program for affected MacBook, ‌MacBook Pro‌, and MacBook Air laptops. The program is still running, but the faulty keyboards are being replaced with one sporting a similar mechanism and are therefore also at risk of failing — a point also raised in the lawsuit.

The launch of the 16-inch MacBook Pro in 2019 finally saw Apple give up on the troublesome butterfly keyboard, with the company reverting to a more traditional design that should prove more reliable for owners.

Apple will be keen to put this damaging episode behind it, but this week’s ruling means it still has plenty of work ahead to deal with the disgruntled users who launched the class action lawsuit.

Editors' Recommendations

Trevor Mogg
Contributing Editor
Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…
The biggest Apple design fails and screw-ups of all time
Apple Pencil

Apple is world-famous for its design success stories, from the iMac G3 to all the best iPhones. But things don’t always go according to plan, even for the most design-savvy tech firm on the planet.

No, Apple has had its fair share of design howlers over the years. Here, we’ve rounded up eight of the most egregious design sins Apple has ever committed. It’s a good reminder that no one is above dropping a few absolute clunkers -- even Apple.
The butterfly keyboard

Read more
Apple could soon put an M3 chip in its worst laptop
Fortnite running on a Macbook M1.

Apple’s MacBook lineup is full of great laptops, but the 13-inch MacBook Pro really doesn’t feel like it belongs. Yet a new report claims Apple will update that device with an M3 chip later this year instead of simply killing it off.

The news comes from 9to5Mac, and the website says its sources have confirmed the 13-inch MacBook Pro is going to get a refresh with a new M3 chip, potentially at Apple’s Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) in June.

Read more
A new iMac and 15-inch MacBook Air are almost ready to launch
A student types at a desk on a pink Apple iMac 24-inch M1 desktop computer.

The M1 iMac made a big splash when it launched in spring 2021, but it’s been a long two years without updates since then. There’s some good news for Apple fans, though, as a new iMac is apparently almost upon us.

That’s according to a new report from Bloomberg journalist Mark Gurman, who claims the next iMac is undergoing production tests as we speak. This stage of development (known as engineering validation testing, or EVT) means the product is getting close to launching.

Read more