Skip to main content

Turns out DirectStorage isn’t killing frame rates in Forspoken after all

Yesterday, we published that DirectStorage might be killing your frame rate in Forspoken. This claim was based on some early testing from the PC Games Hardware YouTube channel, which claimed upwards of a 10% drop in frame rate when using DirectStorage. As some new testing has proven, that’s has turned out to not be true.

It’s a classic case of assuming on my part, and you know what they say about that. Although generally a reliable German source for PC hardware coverage, the YouTube channel didn’t take into account loading screens when running its benchmarks. Naturally, a SATA SSD took longer to load than a PCIe SSD, boosting the average frame rate for the slower drive.

Frey is handcuffed and guarded in Forspoken.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

A thanks goes out to ComputerBase and Tom Warren at The Verge for highlighting this mistake. But lest I fall into the trap of assuming third-party data is accurate again, I booted up Forspoken and decided to test a PCIe 3.0 SSD and SATA SSD for myself.

DirectStorage shines best on PCIe 4.0 SSDs, but the original claim from PC Games Hardware showed a difference between SATA and PCIe — there wasn’t a difference between Gen 3 and Gen 4 drives in performance. Instead of relying on the in-game benchmark, I went out into the open world for some testing instead.

Get your weekly teardown of the tech behind PC gaming
Check your inbox!

And there is a minor difference in performance. At 4K with the AMD RX 7900 XTX, I measured 52.4 frames per second (fps) with the PCIe SSD and 53.9 fps with the SATA SSD. Given the rather poor optimization of Forspoken on PC, it’s safe to chalk up this difference to variance in the game, not DirectStorage.

Much more interesting were the loading times. Again, I tried to boot from a cold save rather than using the in-game benchmark. This meant completely closing the game and trying to load a save, as resuming a save after already playing the game can lead to slightly faster loading times.

DirectStorage loading times in Forspoken.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Although it’s not the fraction of a second that you see in the benchmark, Forspoken loads significantly faster with a PCIe SSD. That’s no shock, but DirectStorage itself also shaves off nearly a full second. Thankfully, that benefit applies to the SATA SSD, as well, though to a lesser degree.

It’s early days for Microsoft’s DirectStorage tech, with Forspoken being the only showcase on PC of it. It’s a problematic PC release for a number of reasons — visual bugs and constant hitching chief among them — but one thing is certain: DirectStorage isn’t causing problems in the game.

Still, it’s important to keep an eye on DirectStorage in future releases. GPU decompression in Microsoft’s tech promises to reduce CPU usage in games by offloading some work onto the graphics card. This shouldn’t impact your frame rate, as the CPU is a critical bottleneck for I/O operations like streaming in-game assets. However, it’s possible DirectStorage could represent a minor performance difference in the future, especially on less powerful graphics cards.

It’s far too early to make assumptions about what DirectStorage could do in the future. With the first look at Forspoken, it vastly improves loading times as Microsoft promises. And once those games arrive, I promise to do first-hand testing rather than relying on potentially inaccurate data from third-party sources.

Jacob Roach
Lead Reporter, PC Hardware
Jacob Roach is the lead reporter for PC hardware at Digital Trends. In addition to covering the latest PC components, from…
I can’t believe I’m recommending Forspoken on PS5 over PC
Frey using magic in Forspoken.

I'll almost always recommend a PC release over a console release. You have access to more graphics options, more opportunities to optimize your performance, and a community-driven support system for modifying or repairing your games. That's especially true as the current generation of consoles begin to show their age.

But there is still an unsung advantage of playing games on console over a PC, and Square Enix's Forspoken brings that advantage the PS5 has over PC into the spotlight.
Forspoken on PS5
Forspoken PS5 Quality vs. Performance vs. Ray Tracing

Read more
DirectX 12 vs. DirectX 11: which is best for PC gaming?
Control protagonist Jesse explores the game's facility.

DirectX 12 is the latest graphics API that powers Windows 11, but many of the best PC games still either run on DirectX 11 or include an option to switch. Which should you choose?

Although most updates to DirectX are iterative, DirectX 12 represents a massive shift for the API Microsoft has been developing for several decades. It can massively improve performance in your games, and it has a few unique features that DirectX 11 doesn't have access to.
Graphics APIs aren't equal

Read more
Microsoft’s DirectStorage can now boost your game loading times by 200%
Person using a gaming monitor.

Microsoft's DirectStorage 1.1 update is here, and it's definitely one that gamers won't want to miss.

With the new version of the API, Microsoft promises up to 200% faster game load times -- all thanks to GPU decompression. Here's how you can try it out for yourself.

Read more