Skip to main content

Google Books Facing Suit from Visual Artists

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Google’s ambitious digital library project—wherein it is scanning the contents of millions of books in order to make them available via the Internet—looks like it may be facing yet another legal challenge. Today, the American Society of Media Photographers and other industry groups representing visual artists announced they have filed a class action lawsuit against Google over the project, claiming it infringes on copyrights of photographers and other visual artists by reproducing and redistributing their work without permission.

“We are seeking justice and fair compensation for visual artists whose work appears in the twelve million books and other publications Google has illegally scanned to date,” said ASMP general counsel Victor Perlman, in a statement. “In doing so, we are giving voice to thousands of disenfranchised creators of visual artworks whose rights we hope to enforce through this class action.”

The new ASMP lawsuit is analogous to the 2005 suits from authors’ groups and publishers over the Google Library Project; that suit is currently awaiting approval of a $125 million settlement agreement that would enable Google to digitize and sell copies of millions of out-of-print titles. The groups of photographers and visual artists tried to join that suit, but the request was denied by the court. So they’re launching their own case instead. The ASMP suit doesn’t just cover the Google Digital Library; it also target Google partnerships that have some publishers permitting Google to include their titles in Google’s book search service.

Google’s proposed $125 million settlement with publishers mostly excludes visual works like photographs. It also faces opposition from other Internet industry giants like Amazon, Yahoo, and Microsoft, and even the U.S. Justice Department has expressed concerns over legal issues with the settlement.

Other groups participating in the new class action suit include the Graphic Artists Guild, the North American Nature Photography Association, and the Professional Photographers of America, along with a number of individual photographers and illustrators.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Report: Apple’s 2024 MacBooks may face some serious shortages
Apple's John Ternus stands next to an image of the 15-inch MacBook Air at Apple's Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) in June 2023.

Looking forward to getting a new MacBook in the next year or so? You might have to wait longer than expected, as Apple chip supplier TSMC is reportedly struggling to get enough skilled workers for its forthcoming Arizona factory. That could mean we see serious shortages of Apple laptops and a struggle to get hold of stock.

The bad news comes from The Wall Street Journal. According to the outlet, TSMC has said that “people with expertise erecting semiconductor facilities were in short supply in the U.S.” As a result, the Arizona factory “would miss its target of starting mass production next year.”

Read more
Apple’s 12-inch MacBook might soon come back from the dead
cheap macbook deals

Apple’s 12-inch MacBook was a highly advanced laptop, but one where its fatal compromises eventually led to its abandonment. Yet there are rumors Apple is planning to resurrect the tiny device, and a Korean source has seemingly confirmed that -- yet there are questions over the report’s trustworthiness.

The claim was made on Korean website Naver by yeux1122 (translated version), an account that has something of a mixed track record for Apple rumors. According to the Naver post, Apple is preparing laptop parts and “major activities” relating to the 12-inch MacBook.

Read more
What MacBooks needs to learn from competitors about transparency
A MacBook Pro M2 sits on a wooden table with a nice bokeh background.

Look, I get it. When you buy an entry-level laptop, you're not getting the same components as with more expensive models. But usually, that covers things like the size of the SSD, the amount of RAM, or the specific CPU. These are obvious choices that you know you're making when you're putting down your cash.

But Apple's been taking things a step further. It all started with the MacBook Air M2 and MacBook Pro M2, where the entry-level models with 256GB of storage use slower single-NAND SSDs compared to faster dual-NAND SSDs. Without going into unnecessary technical detail, I'll just say that the smaller drives are slower than the larger drives -- around half as fast, in fact. And then, to make matters worse, Apple has done the same with the performance-oriented M2 MacBook Pro, with the smallest 512GB SSD being single-NAND as well and considerably slower.

Read more