Skip to main content

Microsoft’s Surface Laptop is a Trojan horse to sneak Windows 10 S into your life

Microsoft Education: Empowering students to achieve more
Until now, Microsoft has made it perfectly clear what each one of its Surface machines is meant to accomplish. The Surface Pro is the tablet that can replace your notebook. The Surface Book is the notebook that can replace your tablet. And the Surface Studio is the desktop PC that can turn your office into a creative studio.

Today’s introduction of the Surface Laptop isn’t so clear. While the machine is obviously Microsoft’s newest halo product, this time for the traditional notebook market, the company has raised more questions than answers by introducing it along with the education-focused Windows 10 S.

Windows 10 S and the Surface Laptop – For education, or not?

At first glance, Windows 10 S serves an obvious and timely purpose. It’s a version of Windows 10 that Microsoft can position as the educational alternative to Google’s lightweight Chromebook platform. Working with its partner OEMs, Microsoft can now offer solutions that combine extremely low-cost hardware with a version of Windows 10 that’s easier to manage, starts up faster, and comes bundled with other software like Minecraft: Education Edition, and Office 365 for Education.

Sounds great, right?

Yet the Surface Laptop flies in the face of that strategy. It’s certainly not an inexpensive machine, with a starting price of $999, that tops out at $2,199. That’s high-end notebook territory. In fact, it looks like a direct competitor to the Apple MacBook and MacBook Pro, not to mention Microsoft’s own Surface Book.

In short, the Surface Laptop is not a machine that schools are going to purchase in bulk to build into computers-on-wheels (COWs) and cart from classroom to classroom. School IT administrators aren’t likely to hand them over to students, who won’t care about staining the Alcantara fabric lining the keyboard deck, or cracking the 13.5-inch PixelSense 3:2 display.

And yet, according to Microsoft, the Surface Laptop was “Designed for Windows 10 S,” an operating system that by the company’s own admission is intended to offer less functionality in the name of better security and easier administration – not enhanced productivity and power.

Laptop, or Trojan horse?

A skeptical geek might look at Windows 10 S and assume that it’s the beginning of an effort to compel people to download all their apps from the Windows Store. Office 365 is making its way there right now, and it’s possible that the standalone version of Office could eventually disappear. Toss in the fact that Windows 10 S doesn’t allow users to change the default browser from Edge, and the future doesn’t look bright.

In fact, Windows 10 S starts to look like a Trojan horse. Its focus on education makes its limitations excusable, glossing over fundamental changes to how the operating system works. Yet the operating system is bundled into a high-end laptop that many people will desire. The hope, it seems, is that users will give Microsoft’s vision of a Store-centric, Edge-centric, Bing-centric Windows a second chance.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

The company knows that it can’t simply pivot Windows all at once, so it’s instead sneaking in Windows 10 S under the pretense of a purpose-built Windows incarnation. Then, if Microsoft decides to shift other versions of Windows in the same direction, then the company can say it’s because people loved the Surface Laptop.

Of course, Microsoft could easily shift to Windows 10 Pro on the Surface Laptop without any fanfare, and write the change off to customer preference. It could also offer new configurations with an upcharge to Windows 10 Pro, leaving Windows 10 S as a budget option. These escape strategies would allow Microsoft to smooth over poor reception as nothing more than a misstep.

Even if that happens, however, it would be foolish to pass Windows 10 S off as a blip, an experiment, or a merely niche branch of mainstream Windows. While Microsoft talks about education in this light, it seems to be forming a shadowy plan to transition Windows into a tighter, more locked-down operating system — one where browser choice, search engine choice, and application choice are no longer up to user preference.

It’s a plan that would indeed make the operating system more secure and easier to use, but it’s also one that would have many howling “the sky is falling!” – and, perhaps, for good reason. Whatever its fate, Windows 10 S and the Surface Laptop have shown us Microsoft’s darkest desires.

Mark Coppock
Mark has been a geek since MS-DOS gave way to Windows and the PalmPilot was a thing. He’s translated his love for…
Don’t buy the Surface Laptop Go 3 — here’s what you should get instead
Microsoft Surface Laptop Go 3 front view showing display and keyboard.

As a former marketing professional and a laptop reviewer, I often find myself surprised and sometimes confused by the decisions companies make when launching a laptop. An example is when a company introduces just one or two configurations that may not meet the needs of a range of users and, as a result, starts a laptop off on the wrong foot. In that case, I can at least understand the complexity of manufacturing and component sourcing. Although I'll mention a lack of options in a review, I won't necessarily ding a laptop because of it.

Some mistakes, though, are harder to overlook. That's how I feel about Microsoft's Surface Laptop Go 3, which the company introduced at a significantly higher price than its predecessors. The laptop, which is designed and configured like a budget machine, starts at $800 and runs up to $1,000. Those are midrange prices, but the Surface just can't compete against many midrange laptops.
$800 is too much
Asus Zenbook 14 OLED Mark Coppock / Digital Trends

Read more
Everything Microsoft didn’t announce at its 2023 Surface event
Microsoft showing off the new Surface laptop Go 3 at its September event.

Microsoft unveiled several new products during its 2023 Surface event. We got lots of updates about Windows Copilot and other AI-driven software upgrades, as well as plenty of hardware, including the Surface Laptop Studio 2 and the Surface Laptop Go 3.

While a lot of our early predictions came true during the Microsoft September event, there are still a few things that were noticeably missing from this year's lineup. Here's what Microsoft could have announced, but didn't.
Surface Pro 10

Read more
Microsoft’s Surface Laptop Go 3 is a more capable budget laptop
Surface Laptop Go 3 at Microsoft debut event.

At today's Surface event, Microsoft announced the third generation of its budget-priced Surface Laptop Go, the premium Surface Laptop Studio 2, and the Surface Go 4. Sporting a Microsoft pedigree, the Surface Laptop Go 3 is worth considering if you're looking for a nice-looking touchscreen notebook.

Microsoft upgraded several components in this year's offering to make the Surface Laptop Go 3 more competitive. Microsoft upgraded the processor to a 12th Gen Core i5-1235U, which deliversa massive upgrade of 88% faster performance. Memory and storage capacity are larger than ever for a Surface Laptop Go, with 8GB of RAM and a 256GB SSD. At the same time, battery life increases from 13 to 15 hours, so you can go all day with this laptop.

Read more