Skip to main content

Senator McCain joins the call for new laws against end-to-end encryption

Senator John McCain is calling for legislation that requires companies to place encryption backdoors in their products for law enforcement to access communications of suspected terrorists, provided they have a warrant.

Writing in an op-ed for Bloomberg, the Arizona senator said that encryption provided terrorists like ISIS, as well as criminals, with “cyber safe havens” to evade the authorities. “This is unacceptable,” he said.

Recommended Videos

Tech companies have argued that weakening encryption or allowing backdoors is a detriment to user privacy, which could be exploited. This is a claim that McCain refuses to fully accept. “This position is ideologically motivated and profit-driven, though not without merit,” he said.

“Americans of course need access to technology that keeps our personal and business communications private, but this must be balanced with concerns over national security,” the senator wrote, claiming Silicon Valley must play a role in the fight against terror.

McCain proposes a need for alternatives to end-to-end encryption, which would allow manufacturers to open up users’ data under a warrant, referencing 1990s legislation that allows for wiretapping as inspiration. However, Owen Barder, the European director of the Center for Global Development has called McCain’s comments “embarrassingly incoherent.”

The use of encryption by terrorists has been an issue of heated debate. McCain is just the latest politician to make such remarks. Senate Intelligence Committee Chairman Richard Burr and Senator Dianne Feinstein for example are continuing work on a bill that would require companies to decrypt data if there’s a court order. However, these would still only be domestic laws and, if ever passed, would have no effect on the use of encryption by terrorists in other countries.

Encryption has many ardent defenders, such as the EFF, in the face of these proposals and criticisms. Just recently, a Harvard study challenged law enforcement’s stance that encryption severely inhibits investigations while NSA director Michael Rogers has even questioned the need for this ongoing debate.

Jonathan Keane
Jonathan is a freelance technology journalist living in Dublin, Ireland. He's previously written for publications and sites…
A coding blunder just ruined a moment of joy for lottery winners
Eurojackpot lottery slips.

Imagine the joy of being notified of a huge lottery win. What would be the first thing you’d do? Get the champagne in? Book a fancy vacation? Call your boss and tell him where to go?

And then imagine being informed that the notification had, in fact, been sent in error. Well, you can always send the booze back and cancel the holiday, but trying to convince your boss that you were just joking ... well, that may be a bigger challenge.

Read more
This TP-Link Wi-Fi 6 router is 45% off in early Prime Day deal
The TP-Link AX1800 Archer AX21 Wi-FI 6 Router on a white background.

If you're planning to buy a new router to improve your home's Wi-Fi network, the good news is that you don't have to wait for Prime Day 2025 to take advantage of huge discounts on router deals from Amazon. Here's an excellent offer — the TP-Link Archer AX21 with an eye-catching 45% discount, which drops its price from $100 to just $55. The $45 in savings will only be available for a limited time though, so you better act fast and proceed with your purchase immediately as this early Prime Day deal may disappear at any moment.

Buy Now

Read more
Watch these AI humanoid robots play soccer like Mbappé … sort of
Humanoid robots playing soccer.

Watching these humanoid robots battle it out on the soccer field, you quickly realize that Kylian Mbappé and his fellow professionals really have little to worry about. At least, for now.

The footage (top) was captured last week in Beijing at the RoBoLeague World Robot Soccer League, China's first-ever three-on-three humanoid robot soccer league.

Read more